The defensive role of Ni hyperaccumulation by plants: a field experiment.

Hyperaccumulation of Ni by plants is hypothesized to function as an elemental defense against herbivores and pathogens. Laboratory experiments have documented toxic effects to herbivores consuming high-Ni plant tissues, but this paper reports the first experiment to examine the defensive effectiveness of Ni hyperaccumulation under field conditions. The experiment was conducted at an ultramafic soil site naturally inhabited by the Ni hyperaccumulator Streptanthus polygaloides (Brassicaceae). Experimental treatments examined the response of herbivores to hyperaccumulated Ni, using exclosure and insecticide treatments to divide herbivores into groups based primarily upon herbivore size. Three soils (Ni-amended greenhouse soil, unamended greenhouse soil, ultramafic soil), three exclosure treatments (exclosure, control exclosure, no exclosure), and a systemic insecticide treatment were combined in a fractional factorial experimental design. Streptanthus polygaloides plants were grown in a greenhouse for 2 mo, transplanted into the field by inserting potted plants into holes dug on the experimental site, and periodically examined for herbivore damage during a 41-d period. Initial surveys showed greater amounts of insect damage to plants with low tissue Ni levels, confirming the defensive effect of Ni against some insect herbivores, but large herbivores (probably vertebrates) later consumed entire plants regardless of plant Ni status. We concluded that Ni was not an effective defense against these large herbivores, probably because their diets mix high-Ni S. polygaloides foliage with that of associated non-hyperaccumulating species. We suggest that such dietary dilution is one mechanism whereby some herbivores can circumvent elemental plant defenses.