Carin Björngren Cuadra1. 1. Faculty of Health and Society, Malmö University, Malmö, Sweden.
Abstract
BACKGROUND: The aim of this article is to characterize policies regarding the right of access to health care for undocumented migrants in the 27 Member States of the European Union and to identify the extent to which these entitlements are congruent with human rights standards. METHODS: The study is based on a questionnaire sent to experts, non-governmental organizations and authorities in the Member States between April and December 2009, as well as on available reports and official websites. Primary sources were also consulted as regards legislation. RESULTS: Right of access to health care differs considerably between Member States. States can be grouped into 3 clusters: in 5 countries undocumented migrants have the right to access care that is more extensive than emergency care; in 12 countries they can only access emergency care and in 10 countries not even emergency care can be accessed. These variations are independent of the system of financing or the numbers of undocumented migrants present. Rather, they seem to relate to the intersection between practices of control of migration, the main types of undocumented migrants present and the basic norms of the welfare state-the 'moral economy' of the work society. CONCLUSION: International obligations articulated in human rights standards are not fully met in the majority of Member States. A more complete understanding of the differing policies might be obtained by considering the relationship between the formal and informal economy, as well as the role of human rights standards within the current 'moral economy'.
BACKGROUND: The aim of this article is to characterize policies regarding the right of access to health care for undocumented migrants in the 27 Member States of the European Union and to identify the extent to which these entitlements are congruent with human rights standards. METHODS: The study is based on a questionnaire sent to experts, non-governmental organizations and authorities in the Member States between April and December 2009, as well as on available reports and official websites. Primary sources were also consulted as regards legislation. RESULTS: Right of access to health care differs considerably between Member States. States can be grouped into 3 clusters: in 5 countries undocumented migrants have the right to access care that is more extensive than emergency care; in 12 countries they can only access emergency care and in 10 countries not even emergency care can be accessed. These variations are independent of the system of financing or the numbers of undocumented migrants present. Rather, they seem to relate to the intersection between practices of control of migration, the main types of undocumented migrants present and the basic norms of the welfare state-the 'moral economy' of the work society. CONCLUSION: International obligations articulated in human rights standards are not fully met in the majority of Member States. A more complete understanding of the differing policies might be obtained by considering the relationship between the formal and informal economy, as well as the role of human rights standards within the current 'moral economy'.
Authors: Patrick Brzoska; Ute Ellert; Ahmet Kimil; Oliver Razum; Anke-Christine Sass; Ramazan Salman; Hajo Zeeb Journal: Int J Public Health Date: 2014-11-12 Impact factor: 3.380
Authors: Anne Jolivet; Emmanuelle Cadot; Olivier Angénieux; Sophie Florence; Sophie Lesieur; Jacques Lebas; Pierre Chauvin Journal: J Immigr Minor Health Date: 2014-08
Authors: Teresa Fasciana; Giuseppina Capra; Paola Di Carlo; Cinzia Calà; Marco Vella; Giuseppe Pistone; Claudia Colomba; Anna Giammanco Journal: Int J Environ Res Public Health Date: 2021-04-28 Impact factor: 3.390
Authors: Marie Dauvrin; Vincent Lorant; Sima Sandhu; Walter Devillé; Hamidou Dia; Sónia Dias; Andrea Gaddini; Elisabeth Ioannidis; Natasja K Jensen; Ulrike Kluge; Ritva Mertaniemi; Rosa Puigpinós I Riera; Attila Sárváry; Christa Strabmayr; Mindaugas Stankunas; Joaquim Jf Soares; Marta Welbel; Stefan Priebe Journal: BMC Res Notes Date: 2012-02-16
Authors: Ibrahim Abubakar; Robert W Aldridge; Delan Devakumar; Miriam Orcutt; Rachel Burns; Mauricio L Barreto; Poonam Dhavan; Fouad M Fouad; Nora Groce; Yan Guo; Sally Hargreaves; Michael Knipper; J Jaime Miranda; Nyovani Madise; Bernadette Kumar; Davide Mosca; Terry McGovern; Leonard Rubenstein; Peter Sammonds; Susan M Sawyer; Kabir Sheikh; Stephen Tollman; Paul Spiegel; Cathy Zimmerman Journal: Lancet Date: 2018-12-05 Impact factor: 202.731
Authors: Jessika Deblonde; André Sasse; Julia Del Amo; Fiona Burns; Valerie Delpech; Susan Cowan; Michele Levoy; Lilana Keith; Anastasia Pharris; Andrew Amato-Gauci; Teymur Noori Journal: BMC Public Health Date: 2015-12-10 Impact factor: 3.295
Authors: Pietro A Modesti; Piergiuseppe Agostoni; Charles Agyemang; Sanjay Basu; Athanase Benetos; Francesco P Cappuccio; Antonio Ceriello; Stefano Del Prato; Robert Kalyesubula; Eoin O'Brien; Michael O Kilama; Stefano Perlini; Eugenio Picano; Gianpaolo Reboldi; Giuseppe Remuzzi; David Stuckler; Marc Twagirumukiza; Luc M Van Bortel; Ghassan Watfa; Dong Zhao; Gianfranco Parati Journal: J Hypertens Date: 2014-05 Impact factor: 4.844