Elizabeth McInnes1, Kate Seers, Liz Tutton. 1. Nursing Research Institute, St Vincent's & Mater Health Sydney-Australian Catholic University, Sydney, Australia. liz.mcinnes@acu.edu.au
Abstract
AIM: This paper is a report of a meta-ethnography of qualitative studies of older peoples' views on risk of falling and need for intervention. BACKGROUND: Falls and falls-related injuries in older people are worldwide problems. A conceptual understanding of older people's views about falls risk and need for intervention is useful for understanding factors likely to impact on acceptance of risk and recommended interventions. DATA SOURCES: Seven electronic databases were searched 1999-2009. Reference lists of included articles were screened for eligible papers. REVIEW METHODS: Assessment of quality was carried out. Themes and concepts were extracted using a meta-ethnographic approach to compare similarities and differences across the retrieved studies. A line of argument was developed to produce an explanatory framework of the extracted themes and concepts. RESULTS: Eleven relevant qualitative research articles of reasonable quality were identified. Six key concepts were identified: beyond personal control; rationalizing; salience; life-change and identity; taking control and self-management. A line of argument synthesis describes how older people approach self-appraisal of falls risk and intervention need, and how they cope and adapt to falls risk and intervention need. CONCLUSION: In response to having an elevated risk status and perceived associations with frailty and impact on an independent life-style, some prefer to adapt to this reality by taking control and implementing self-management strategies. Healthcare professionals should take into account beliefs about risk and negotiate choices for intervention, recognizing that some individuals prefer to drive the decision-making process to preserve identity as a competent and independent person.
AIM: This paper is a report of a meta-ethnography of qualitative studies of older peoples' views on risk of falling and need for intervention. BACKGROUND: Falls and falls-related injuries in older people are worldwide problems. A conceptual understanding of older people's views about falls risk and need for intervention is useful for understanding factors likely to impact on acceptance of risk and recommended interventions. DATA SOURCES: Seven electronic databases were searched 1999-2009. Reference lists of included articles were screened for eligible papers. REVIEW METHODS: Assessment of quality was carried out. Themes and concepts were extracted using a meta-ethnographic approach to compare similarities and differences across the retrieved studies. A line of argument was developed to produce an explanatory framework of the extracted themes and concepts. RESULTS: Eleven relevant qualitative research articles of reasonable quality were identified. Six key concepts were identified: beyond personal control; rationalizing; salience; life-change and identity; taking control and self-management. A line of argument synthesis describes how older people approach self-appraisal of falls risk and intervention need, and how they cope and adapt to falls risk and intervention need. CONCLUSION: In response to having an elevated risk status and perceived associations with frailty and impact on an independent life-style, some prefer to adapt to this reality by taking control and implementing self-management strategies. Healthcare professionals should take into account beliefs about risk and negotiate choices for intervention, recognizing that some individuals prefer to drive the decision-making process to preserve identity as a competent and independent person.
Authors: Hannah M L Young; Nicki Ruddock; Mary Harrison; Samantha Goodliffe; Courtney J Lightfoot; Juliet Mayes; Andrew C Nixon; Sharlene A Greenwood; Simon Conroy; Sally J Singh; James O Burton; Alice C Smith; Helen Eborall Journal: Int J Environ Res Public Health Date: 2022-03-24 Impact factor: 3.390