Shayne P Taback1, Guy Van Vliet. 1. Department of Pediatrics and Child Health, University of Manitoba, Winnipeg, MB, R3T 2N2, Canada. tabacksp@cc.umanitoba.ca
Abstract
BACKGROUND: There are limited long-term randomized controlled trials of growth hormone (GH) supplementation to adult height and few published reports of the health-related quality of life (HRQOL) following treatment. The present follow-up study of young adults from a long-term controlled trial of GH treatment in patients with Turner syndrome (TS) yielded data to examine whether GH supplementation resulted in a higher HRQOL (either due to taller stature or from the knowledge that active treatment and not placebo had been received) or alternatively a lower HRQOL (due to medicalization from years of injections). METHODS: The original trial randomized 154 Canadian girls with TS aged 7-13 years from 13 centres to receive eitherlong-term GH injections at the pharmacologic dose of 0.3 mg/kg/week or to receive no injections; estrogen prescription for induction of puberty was standardized. Patients were eligible for the follow-up study if they were at least 16 years old at the time of follow-up. The instrument used to study HRQOL was the SF-36, summarized into physical and mental component scales (PCS and MCS); higher scores indicate better HRQOL. RESULTS:Thirty-four of the 48 eligible participants (71%) consented to participate; data were missing for one patient. Both groups (GH and no treatment) had normal HRQOL at this post-treatment assessment. The GH group had a (mean ± SD) PCS score of 56 ± 5; the untreated group 58 ± 4; mean score for 16-24 year old females in the general population 53.5 ± 6.9. The GH group had a mean MCS score of 52 ± 6; the untreated group 49 ± 13; mean score for 16-24 year old females in the general population 49.6 ± 9.8. Secondary analyses showed no relationship between HRQOL and height. CONCLUSIONS: We found no benefit or adverse effect on HRQOL either from receiving or not receiving growth hormone injections in a long-term randomized controlled trial, confirming larger observational studies. We suggest that it remains ethically acceptable as well as necessary to maintain a long-term untreated control group to estimate the effects of pharmacological agents to manipulate adult height. Young adult women with TS have normal HRQOL suggesting that they adjust well to their challenges in life. TRIAL REGISTRATION: ClinicalTrials.gov Identifier NCT00191113.
RCT Entities:
BACKGROUND: There are limited long-term randomized controlled trials of growth hormone (GH) supplementation to adult height and few published reports of the health-related quality of life (HRQOL) following treatment. The present follow-up study of young adults from a long-term controlled trial of GH treatment in patients with Turner syndrome (TS) yielded data to examine whether GH supplementation resulted in a higher HRQOL (either due to taller stature or from the knowledge that active treatment and not placebo had been received) or alternatively a lower HRQOL (due to medicalization from years of injections). METHODS: The original trial randomized 154 Canadian girls with TS aged 7-13 years from 13 centres to receive either long-term GH injections at the pharmacologic dose of 0.3 mg/kg/week or to receive no injections; estrogen prescription for induction of puberty was standardized. Patients were eligible for the follow-up study if they were at least 16 years old at the time of follow-up. The instrument used to study HRQOL was the SF-36, summarized into physical and mental component scales (PCS and MCS); higher scores indicate better HRQOL. RESULTS: Thirty-four of the 48 eligible participants (71%) consented to participate; data were missing for one patient. Both groups (GH and no treatment) had normal HRQOL at this post-treatment assessment. The GH group had a (mean ± SD) PCS score of 56 ± 5; the untreated group 58 ± 4; mean score for 16-24 year old females in the general population 53.5 ± 6.9. The GH group had a mean MCS score of 52 ± 6; the untreated group 49 ± 13; mean score for 16-24 year old females in the general population 49.6 ± 9.8. Secondary analyses showed no relationship between HRQOL and height. CONCLUSIONS: We found no benefit or adverse effect on HRQOL either from receiving or not receiving growth hormone injections in a long-term randomized controlled trial, confirming larger observational studies. We suggest that it remains ethically acceptable as well as necessary to maintain a long-term untreated control group to estimate the effects of pharmacological agents to manipulate adult height. Young adult women with TS have normal HRQOL suggesting that they adjust well to their challenges in life. TRIAL REGISTRATION: ClinicalTrials.gov Identifier NCT00191113.
Authors: Judith L Ross; Charmian A Quigley; Dachuang Cao; Penelope Feuillan; Karen Kowal; John J Chipman; Gordon B Cutler Journal: N Engl J Med Date: 2011-03-31 Impact factor: 91.245
Authors: Wilma M Hopman; Claudie Berger; Lawrence Joseph; Tanveer Towheed; Jerilynn C Prior; Tassos Anastassiades; Suzette Poliquin; Wei Zhou; Jonathan D Adachi; David A Hanley; Emmanuel A Papadimitropoulos; Alan Tenenhouse Journal: Can J Public Health Date: 2009 Nov-Dec
Authors: Christian Trolle; Britta Hjerrild; Line Cleemann; Kristian H Mortensen; Claus H Gravholt Journal: Endocrine Date: 2011-12-07 Impact factor: 3.633
Authors: Carolina Trombeta Reis; Maíra Seabra de Assumpção; Gil Guerra-Junior; Sofia Helena Valente de Lemos-Marini Journal: Qual Life Res Date: 2018-02-09 Impact factor: 4.147
Authors: Allard T van den Hoven; Lidia R Bons; Ramon H M Dykgraaf; Arianne B Dessens; Hester Pastoor; Laura C G de Graaff; Mick R Metselaar; Annemiek Kneppers-Swets; Isabella Kardys; Hester Mijnarends; Frank Zweerus; Jan A Hazelzet; Elisabeth M W J Utens; Annemien E van den Bosch; Jolien W Roos-Hesselink Journal: Clin Endocrinol (Oxf) Date: 2020-02-18 Impact factor: 3.478