BACKGROUND: Given their applicability in diverse settings and for a wide range of purposes, the generalizability of self-report symptom measures is particularly important. An understudied factor in the development and validation of self-report measures is the degree to which they are difficult to comprehend. This study evaluated the difficulty of self-report measures of anxiety with respect to several domains, including formatting, length, and linguistic problems. METHODS: Ninety-two evidence based measures of anxiety were evaluated for comprehension level. RESULTS: The majority of anxiety measures included challenging elements of formatting, linguistic ability, and readability. Measures of obsessive-compulsive disorder were associated with the highest level of comprehension (i.e., greatest difficulty). CONCLUSIONS: The validity of self-report measures relies on the ability of respondents to understand the instructions and measure items. Factors related to the comprehension of self-report measures should be included among the basic psychometric properties in measure development and validation. Future research on the development of self-report measures that can be more broadly applicable across levels of education and literacy are of particular importance to research, clinical, and public health agendas.
BACKGROUND: Given their applicability in diverse settings and for a wide range of purposes, the generalizability of self-report symptom measures is particularly important. An understudied factor in the development and validation of self-report measures is the degree to which they are difficult to comprehend. This study evaluated the difficulty of self-report measures of anxiety with respect to several domains, including formatting, length, and linguistic problems. METHODS: Ninety-two evidence based measures of anxiety were evaluated for comprehension level. RESULTS: The majority of anxiety measures included challenging elements of formatting, linguistic ability, and readability. Measures of obsessive-compulsive disorder were associated with the highest level of comprehension (i.e., greatest difficulty). CONCLUSIONS: The validity of self-report measures relies on the ability of respondents to understand the instructions and measure items. Factors related to the comprehension of self-report measures should be included among the basic psychometric properties in measure development and validation. Future research on the development of self-report measures that can be more broadly applicable across levels of education and literacy are of particular importance to research, clinical, and public health agendas.
Authors: Samantha J Moshier; R Kathryn McHugh; Amanda W Calkins; Bridget A Hearon; Anthony J Rosellini; Meara L Weitzman; Michael W Otto Journal: Psychol Addict Behav Date: 2012-06-25
Authors: R Kathryn McHugh; Dawn E Sugarman; Julia S Kaufman; Sara Park; Roger D Weiss; Shelly F Greenfield Journal: J Stud Alcohol Drugs Date: 2014-03 Impact factor: 2.582
Authors: Benjamin D Schalet; Patrick Janulis; Michele D Kipke; Brian Mustanski; Steven Shoptaw; Richard Moore; Marianna Baum; Soyeon Kim; Suzanne Siminski; Amy Ragsdale; Pamina M Gorbach Journal: AIDS Behav Date: 2020-11
Authors: Benjamin D Schalet; Paul A Pilkonis; Lan Yu; Nathan Dodds; Kelly L Johnston; Susan Yount; William Riley; David Cella Journal: J Clin Epidemiol Date: 2016-02-27 Impact factor: 6.437