BACKGROUND: Recent studies have suggested that endoscopic vein harvest (EVH) compromises graft patency. To test whether the learning curve for EVH alters conduit integrity owing to increased trauma compared with an open harvest, we analyzed the quality and early patency of conduits procured by technicians with varying EVH experience. METHODS: During coronary artery bypass grafting, veins were harvested open (n=10) or by EVH (n=85) performed by experienced (>900 cases, >30/month) versus novice<100 cases, <3/month) technicians. Harvested conduits were imaged intraoperatively using optical coherence tomography and on day 5 to assess graft patency using computed tomographic angiography. RESULTS: Conduits from experienced (n=55) versus novice (n=30) harvesters had similar lengths (33 versus 34 cm) and harvest times (32.4 versus 31.8 minutes). Conduit injury was noted in both EVH groups with similar distribution among disruption of the adventitia (62%), intimal tears at branch points (23%), and intimal or medial dissections (15%), but the incidence of these injuries was less with experienced harvesters and rare in veins procured with an open technique. Overall, the rate of graft attrition was similar between the two EVH groups (6.45% versus 4.34% of grafts; p=0.552). However, vein grafts with at least 4 intimal or medial dissections showed significantly worse patency (67% versus 96% patency; p=0.05). CONCLUSIONS: High-resolution imaging confirmed that technicians inexperienced with EVH are more likely to cause intimal and deep vessel injury to the saphenous vein graft, which increases graft failure risk. Endoscopic vein harvest remains the most common technique for conduit harvest, making efforts to better monitor the learning curve an important public health issue.
BACKGROUND: Recent studies have suggested that endoscopic vein harvest (EVH) compromises graft patency. To test whether the learning curve for EVH alters conduit integrity owing to increased trauma compared with an open harvest, we analyzed the quality and early patency of conduits procured by technicians with varying EVH experience. METHODS: During coronary artery bypass grafting, veins were harvested open (n=10) or by EVH (n=85) performed by experienced (>900 cases, >30/month) versus novice<100 cases, <3/month) technicians. Harvested conduits were imaged intraoperatively using optical coherence tomography and on day 5 to assess graft patency using computed tomographic angiography. RESULTS: Conduits from experienced (n=55) versus novice (n=30) harvesters had similar lengths (33 versus 34 cm) and harvest times (32.4 versus 31.8 minutes). Conduit injury was noted in both EVH groups with similar distribution among disruption of the adventitia (62%), intimal tears at branch points (23%), and intimal or medial dissections (15%), but the incidence of these injuries was less with experienced harvesters and rare in veins procured with an open technique. Overall, the rate of graft attrition was similar between the two EVH groups (6.45% versus 4.34% of grafts; p=0.552). However, vein grafts with at least 4 intimal or medial dissections showed significantly worse patency (67% versus 96% patency; p=0.05). CONCLUSIONS: High-resolution imaging confirmed that technicians inexperienced with EVH are more likely to cause intimal and deep vessel injury to the saphenous vein graft, which increases graft failure risk. Endoscopic vein harvest remains the most common technique for conduit harvest, making efforts to better monitor the learning curve an important public health issue.
Authors: Keith Allen; Davy Cheng; William Cohn; Mark Connolly; James Edgerton; Volkmar Falk; Janet Martin; Toshiya Ohtsuka; Richard Vitali Journal: Innovations (Phila) Date: 2005
Authors: Aletta Ann Frazier; Fauzia Qureshi; Katrina M Read; Robert C Gilkeson; Robert S Poston; Charles S White Journal: Radiographics Date: 2005 Jul-Aug Impact factor: 5.333
Authors: Steven Goldman; Gulshan K Sethi; William Holman; Hoang Thai; Edward McFalls; Herbert B Ward; Rosemary F Kelly; Birger Rhenman; Gareth H Tobler; Faisal G Bakaeen; Joseph Huh; Ernesto Soltero; Mohammed Moursi; Miguel Haime; Michael Crittenden; Vigneshwar Kasirajan; Michelle Ratliff; Stewart Pett; Anand Irimpen; William Gunnar; Donald Thomas; Stephen Fremes; Thomas Moritz; Domenic Reda; Lynn Harrison; Todd H Wagner; Yajie Wang; Lori Planting; Meredith Miller; Yvette Rodriguez; Elizabeth Juneman; Douglass Morrison; Mary Kaye Pierce; Sandra Kreamer; Mei-Chiung Shih; Kelvin Lee Journal: JAMA Date: 2011-01-12 Impact factor: 56.272
Authors: K B Allen; D A Heimansohn; R J Robison; J J Schier; G L Griffith; E B Fitzgerald; J H Isch; S Abraham; C J Shaar Journal: Heart Surg Forum Date: 2000 Impact factor: 0.676
Authors: Nicholas S Burris; Emile N Brown; Michael Grant; Zachary N Kon; Marc Gibber; Junyen Gu; Kimberly Schwartz; Seeta Kallam; Ashish Joshi; Richard Vitali; Robert S Poston Journal: Ann Thorac Surg Date: 2008-04 Impact factor: 4.330
Authors: John D Puskas; Michael E Halkos; Husam Balkhy; Michael Caskey; Mark Connolly; John Crouch; Anno Diegeler; Jan Gummert; Wolfgang Harringer; Valavanur Subramanian; Francis Sutter; Klaus Matschke Journal: J Thorac Cardiovasc Surg Date: 2009-03-26 Impact factor: 5.209
Authors: Soroosh Kiani; Pranjal H Desai; Nannan Thirumvalavan; Dinesh John Kurian; Mary Margaret Flynn; XiaoQing Zhao; Robert S Poston Journal: Ann Thorac Surg Date: 2011-10-13 Impact factor: 4.330
Authors: Bhuvaneswari Krishnamoorthy; Joesph Zacharias; William R Critchley; Melissa Rochon; Iryna Stalpinskaya; Azita Rajai; Rajamiyer V Venkateswaran; Shahzad G Raja; Toufan Bahrami Journal: NIHR Open Res Date: 2021-07-08
Authors: Sean van Diepen; J Matthew Brennan; Gail E Hafley; Eric M Reyes; Keith B Allen; T Bruce Ferguson; Eric D Peterson; Judson B Williams; C Michael Gibson; Michael J Mack; Nicholas T Kouchoukos; John H Alexander; Renato D Lopes Journal: Ann Surg Date: 2014-08 Impact factor: 12.969
Authors: Bhuvaneswari Krishnamoorthy; William R Critchley; Rajamiyer V Venkateswaran; James Barnard; Ann Caress; James E Fildes; Nizar Yonan Journal: J Cardiothorac Surg Date: 2016-04-08 Impact factor: 1.637
Authors: Karishma Kodia; Sinal Patel; Matthew P Weber; Jessica G Y Luc; Jae Hwan Choi; Elizabeth J Maynes; Syed-Saif Abbas Rizvi; Dylan P Horan; H Todd Massey; John W Entwistle; Rohinton J Morris; Vakhtang Tchantchaleishvili Journal: Ann Cardiothorac Surg Date: 2018-09