Mutations in the enzyme superoxide dismutase-1 (SOD1) cause hereditary variants of the fatal motor neuronal disease Amyotrophic lateral sclerosis (ALS). Pathophysiology of the disease is non-cell-autonomous: neurotoxicity is derived not only from mutant motor neurons but also from mutant neighbouring non-neuronal cells. In vivo imaging by two-photon laser-scanning microscopy was used to compare the role of microglia/macrophage-related neuroinflammation in the CNS and PNS using ALS-linked transgenic SOD1(G93A) mice. These mice contained labeled projection neurons and labeled microglia/macrophages. In the affected lateral spinal cord (in contrast to non-affected dorsal columns), different phases of microglia-mediated inflammation were observed: highly reactive microglial cells in preclinical stages (in 60-day-old mice the reaction to axonal transection was ∼180% of control) and morphologically transformed microglia that have lost their function of tissue surveillance and injury-directed response in clinical stages (reaction to axonal transection was lower than 50% of control). Furthermore, unlike CNS microglia, macrophages of the PNS lack any substantial morphological reaction while preclinical degeneration of peripheral motor axons and neuromuscular junctions was observed. We present in vivo evidence for a different inflammatory activity of microglia and macrophages: an aberrant neuroinflammatory response of microglia in the CNS and an apparently mainly neurodegenerative process in the PNS.
Mutations in the enzyme superoxide dismutase-1 (SOD1) cause hereditary variants of the fatal motor neuronal disease Amyotrophic lateral sclerosis (ALS). Pathophysiology of the disease is non-cell-autonomous: neurotoxicity is derived not only from mutant motor neurons but also from mutant neighbouring non-neuronal cells. In vivo imaging by two-photon laser-scanning microscopy was used to compare the role of microglia/macrophage-related neuroinflammation in the CNS and PNS using ALS-linked transgenicSOD1(G93A) mice. These mice contained labeled projection neurons and labeled microglia/macrophages. In the affected lateral spinal cord (in contrast to non-affected dorsal columns), different phases of microglia-mediated inflammation were observed: highly reactive microglial cells in preclinical stages (in 60-day-old mice the reaction to axonal transection was ∼180% of control) and morphologically transformed microglia that have lost their function of tissue surveillance and injury-directed response in clinical stages (reaction to axonal transection was lower than 50% of control). Furthermore, unlike CNS microglia, macrophages of the PNS lack any substantial morphological reaction while preclinical degeneration of peripheral motor axons and neuromuscular junctions was observed. We present in vivo evidence for a different inflammatory activity of microglia and macrophages: an aberrant neuroinflammatory response of microglia in the CNS and an apparently mainly neurodegenerative process in the PNS.
Amyotrophic lateral sclerosis (ALS) is an adult-onset neurological disorder
characterized by progressive loss of upper and lower motor neurons and degeneration
of pyramidal tracts. Transgenic mice expressing various humanALS-linked mutations
in the gene encoding the enzyme superoxide dismutase-1 (mSOD1) mimic to some extent
the fatal paralysis seen in patients [1], [2], [3], [4], [5], [6]. Dominant mutations in SOD1 are, so far known, the most
frequent cause of familial ALS (fALS). In addition, the best-studied animal model of
fALS is that caused by mutations in SOD1 [7]. Also in sporadic ALS
(sALS), the analysis of the structure of amyloid fibrils [8] and the presence of
misfolded SOD1 in the spinal cord of sALSpatients [9] suggest an involvement of SOD1
in the pathophysiology of the disease. In addition, recent clinical and
electrophysiological data show that the humanSOD1-G93A phenotype closely resembles
sALS suggesting comparable disease pathology [10].The mSOD1-mediated toxicity is non-cell-autonomous deriving not only from motor
neurons but also from neighbouring glia. In particular, microglia and astrocytes
substantially contribute to motor neuron death and disease progression [4], [5], [6], [11], [12], [13], [14], [15]. In the case
of microglia, selective silencing of the mutant gene in the innate immune cells of
the CNS and in macrophages in a SOD1-model has substantially slowed disease
progression [4],
[5]. In
addition, replacement of mSOD1-expressing cells of the myeloid lineage including
microglia by non-mutated cells via bone marrow transplantation equally slowed
disease progression [11]. These studies strongly emphasize a microglial
contribution to the propagation of motor neuron death. Despite this evidence the
impact of neuroinflammation to disease progression is still a matter of debate and
little is known about the functional state of mSOD1-expressing microglia during
disease progression.In addition, recent evidence suggests that loss of peripheral axons and neuromuscular
synapses is a primary event in motor neuron degeneration, even before the respective
lower motor neuron cell bodies show signs of degeneration [16], [17]. The impact of
neuroinflammation on axonal degeneration in the peripheral nervous system is,
however, still elusive.Microglia as the monocyte-lineage immune effector cells of the CNS play central roles
in CNS neuroinflammation. In the resting state, microglia display highly dynamic
process movements to constantly survey their microenvironment in brain [18], [19] and spinal
cord [20], [21], [22]. This
spontaneous activity enables microglia to rapidly respond to injuries within nervous
tissue [18],
[19],
[20], [21]. Following acute
tissue injury, surrounding microglia extend processes towards the injured site
within minutes while retracting opposite processes: a phenomenon called
polarization. Within a few hours following subsequent ameboid transformation,
responding microglia begin migrating and commence phagocytosis. This injury-induced
transformation of microglia to reactive states is known as microglial activation
[23].Here, we used time-lapse 2-photon laser-scanning microscopy (2P-LSM) and transgenicmouse technology to investigate microglia and macrophage reaction during disease
course in the SOD1-G93A (SOD1G93A) mouse model for ALS. The use of
transgenic mice containing both fluorescent microglia/macrophages [24] and neurons [25] enables us to
correlate mutation-induced changes of microglia/macrophage function with the
progressive axonal degeneration in the CNS or PNS, respectively. Since the stages of
microglial activation are in part defined by their response to injury, including
polarization, migration and phagocytosis [23], we also investigated the
reaction of microglia to axonal transection in different stages of
SOD1G93Amice. In a second approach, the microglia-related
macrophages of the PNS were investigated using the same paradigms. The in
vivo imaging approach allows us to combine morphological changes with
cellular behavior in an intact environment under baseline conditions as well as in
response to focal lesions. Since the maintenance and local expansion of
mSOD1-microglia is dependent on self-renewal within the CNS, we refer to microglia
as the resident monocyte-lineage cells of the CNS [26].CNS microglia showed substantial inflammatory activity. In preclinical stages,
microglial cells that highly reacted towards focal lesions acquired over the course
of the disease an ameboid shape indicating morphological transformation and
consequent cellular activation. In clinical stages activated microglia lost their
injury-directed response. In contrast to microglia-mediated neuroinflammation in the
CNS, morphologically pro-inflammatory reactions of macrophages were negligible in
the PNS suggesting primarily passive roles of macrophages in axonal
degeneration.
Materials and Methods
Ethics statement
The experiments were performed according to the ethical guidelines of the
national animal protection law and were authorized by the ethical committee of
the State of Lower Saxony (review board institution: Niedersächsisches
Landesamt für Verbraucherschutz und Lebensmittelsicherheit, Dezernat 33,
Oldenburg, Germany; approval-ID: 509.42502/01-39.03).
Mouse strains
Transgenic TgN(SOD1-G93A)G1H mice (The Jackson Laboratory, Bar Harbor, USA) were
maintained as hemizygotes by mating transgenic males with B6SJL hybrid females.
Hemizygote male TgN(SOD1-G93A)G1H mice were crossbred with female
TgH(CX3CR1-EGFP)xTgN(THY1-EYFP) mice to obtain SOD1G93Amice with
fluorescently labeled macrophages/microglia and projection neurons.
TgH(CX3CR1-EGFP)xTgN(THY1-EYFP) mice were previously obtained by crossbreeding
homozygous CX3CR1-EGFP mice, in which the expression of the green fluorescent
protein EGFP in monocytes, macrophages and microglia is achieved by placement of
the EGFP reporter gene into the Cx3cr1 locus encoding the
chemokine receptor CX3CR1 [24], with transgenicTHY1-EYFP mice expressing the yellow
fluorescent protein EYFP in projection neurons and their respective axons [27].
TgH(CX3CR1-EGFP) mice and TgN(THY1-EYFP) mice were of B6SJL background for more
than 10 generations. The corresponding littermates (hemizygotes with respect to
all three genetic alterations) were used to study microglia-axon interactions
in vivo during the disease course of SOD1G93A by
discerning their cell-type specific fluorescent protein expression
simultaneously.The experiments were carried out on adult mutant mice (preclinical: 60 and
75-day-old; onset of disease: 90-day-old; clinical: 105 and advanced clinical:
120-day-old). Non-transgenic littermates were used as controls. In control mice,
no age-related changes in microglial behavior were observed. Even though female
SOD1G93A expressing mice survive a few days longer than male
mutant mice, gender-dependent differences in microglial morphology and reactions
were not observed. Similarly, there were no gender-dependent differences in the
behavior of macrophages in the PNS. Mice were kept in the mouse facility of the
institute according to national and European guidelines for the welfare of
experimental animals.
Immunohistochemistry
The animals were anesthetized (80 mg pentobarbital sodium per kg body weight i.
p.) and perfused transcardially with PBS followed by 4% paraformaldehyde.
After tissue processing, 20 µm-thick cryosections were cut from the lumbar
spinal cord. After thawing and rehydration, the sections were incubated with
blocking buffer (10% normal goat serum and 0.1% Triton X-100)
followed by primary antibody (SMI32, 1:1000; purchased from Sternberger
Monoclonal Incorporated, Lutherville, USA). Samples were incubated with a
fluorescent Cy-3 conjugated secondary antibody (1:500; Jackson Immunoresearch,
West Grove, PA, USA). Confocal images were obtained using a Zeiss Axiovert
200M/LSM 510 Meta confocal laser-scanning microscope (Zeiss, Jena, Germany)
equipped with argon (488 nm) and HeNe (543 nm) laser.
Anesthesia and surgery
The experiments were carried out on mice of different clinical stages of
SOD1G93A and on control mice of corresponding age (60 to 140 days
of age) under general anesthesia initiated by 80 mg pentobarbital sodium i. p.
(dissolved in 0.9% NaCl) per kg body weight. After cannulation of the
jugular vein, anesthesia was continued with 40-60 mg per kg and h methohexital
sodium (Brevimytal, Hikma, London, UK). A tracheotomy was performed and a
tracheal tube was inserted for artificial ventilation. Spinal cord segments L4
and L5 were exposed by laminectomy of the spines L1 to L3 for image recording of
the dorsal column. Recording of the lateral column was achieved by turning the
mice by 80 degrees. To avoid movement caused by active respiration during
imaging, the animal was paralyzed with pancuronium bromide (Pancuronium Organon,
Essex Pharma GmbH, Munich, Germany; 800 µg per kg and h by i. p. injection
every hour) and artificially ventilated with a gas mixture of CO2
(2.5%), O2 (47.5%), and N2 (50%) at
120 strokes/min (100-160 µl/stroke depending on the body weight). In
addition, spinal column was rigidly fixed with two custom-made clamps, each
having two joints for keeping the mouse in the turned position.For exposing proximal peripheral nervous tissue including spinal roots and dorsal
ganglia, the dura was carefully removed without setting a lesion to the spinal
cord. In all experiments, the exposed spinal cord was continuously superfused
with ACSF (artificial cerebro-spinal fluid: 125 mM NaCl, 25 mM
NaHCO3, 2.5 mM KCl, 1.25 KH2PO4, 1 mM
MgCl2, 2 mM CaCl2*H2O and 10 mM
glucose). For recordings of peripheral nerves and NMJs of the hind limbs,
sciatic nerve and musculus tenuissimus were exposed, respectively. For this
purpose, spinal column and the respective foot, each, were fixed with a clamp.
For labeling of blood vessels, we injected Texas Red-Dextran (70 kDa,
1.25% w/v, Invitrogen) through a second central venous catheter after
cannulation of the other jugular vein. After an initial injection of 50 µl
bolus (5 min. before the start of the experiment), application of Texas Red was
continued with 50 µl per hour. Rectal body temperature was measured and
kept between 36 and 38°C by a heated plate. Electrocardiograms were
monitored throughout the experiment. A heart rate below 420 per min was taken as
sign for sufficient anesthesia [20], [21]. Furthermore, the dose of methohexital used in
pancuronium-paralyzedmice was the same dose we previously used in non-paralyzedmice with corresponding weight. The depth of anesthesia was tested by provoking
the corneal reflex and reactions to noxious stimuli.
2-Photon laser-scanning microscopy and image acquisition
Photographic and epifluorescence overviews of the spinal cord were acquired using
a 5× (NA 0.15) objective (Carl Zeiss GmbH, Jena, Germany) and a CCD
camera. High resolution in vivo imaging was performed using a
commercial two-photon laser-scanning microscope (2P-LSM, Zeiss Axiocope 2 with
LSM510 NLO scanhead) equipped with a fs-pulsed, mode-locked titanium-sapphire
infrared laser (Mira 900/10 W Verdi; Coherent, Glasgow, UK) or a custom-made
2P-LSM equipped with a fs-pulsed titanium-sapphire laser (Chameleon Ultra II;
Coherent). For 2P-recordings, a Zeiss W N-Achroplan 40× (NA 0.75) or a
Zeiss W Plan Apochromat 20× (NA 1.0) water immersion objective was used.
For excitation, the laser was set at 895±5 nm for the simultaneous
excitation of EGFP and EYFP. Emitted light was split by a 520 nm longpass
dichroic mirror (Semrock, Rochester, USA) and collected by photo-multiplier
tubes (Hamamatsu, Japan) through two bandpass filters: a 494±20.5 nm
(FF01-494/41-25) and a 542±25 nm (FF01-542/50-25 (Semrock). The
fluorescence of Texas Red was separated from the EGFP or EYFP signal by a 560 nm
long pass filter (Carl Zeiss) and a HQ575 emission filter (AHF Analysentechnik,
Tübingen, Germany). The relations of the measured fluorescence intensities
were comparable between the two microscopes. Parallel, uniformly spaced (1.5 to
2.4 µm) planes of 100*100 to 600*600 µm2 regions
were recorded, digitized and processed to obtain z-stacks of images
(256×256 to 1024×1024 pixels in size). Voxel sizes ranged from
0.2×0.2×1.5 to 1.17×1.17×2.4 µm for the xyz-axes.
The total acquisition time for a stack of 15 to 30 images was approximately 1-2
min. Recordings of, at most, 100 µm stack depth were obtained. Several
stacks were taken continuously to get time-lapse series of microglial action.
Standardized lesions were applied by the titanium-sapphire laser focused for 2
seconds to a plane of an axon diameter until the fluorescence signal began
increasing. Only morphologically intact axons were chosen for the
experiments.
Image processing and morphometric analysis
Image processing and morphometric analysis were performed using the Zeiss LSM
software, ImageJ (http://rsbweb.nih.gov/ij)
and Matlab (version 7, MathWorks, Ismaning, Germany). Statistical analysis was
performed using Origin 7 software (Northampton, USA). Prior to any analysis, the
time series of image stacks were corrected for the shifts in the horizontal and
vertical directions by using an autocorrelation based on custom-made software
written in Matlab (v.7). In the majority of images, detector noise was removed
by the median filter of ImageJ. The recorded stacks are shown in maximum
intensity projections (MIPs). Although EGFP and EYFP signals cannot be separated
without spectral unmixing, the filter sets were chosen in a way that permitted
an unambiguous distinction of EGFP expressing microglia from EYFP expressing
neurons. The cellular differentiation was facilitated by the different
morphologies of axons and microglia and the large predominance of EGFP signal in
one channel. Decrease and increase of axonal and microglial fluorescence
signals, respectively, was measured by area fraction analysis (ImageJ) of
particles in comparable regions using the corresponding channels. Prior to that,
proper precautions were taken to ensure that respective fluorescence signals
were similar in different control mice or in different SOD1G93Amice
of the same stage. The number of axons in comparable regions was measured by
plot profile analysis (ImageJ). Ramification analysis referred to the main
processes directly originating from the microglial cell body [20]. To
determine the motility of microglial processes, changes of the length of
microglial processes were determined in relation to the control situation before
lesion and after laser-induced injury. The outermost processes comprising
protrusions at their end were quantified. Measurements of the intracellular area
of single macrophages in MIPs were performed using Zeiss LSM software. Care was
taken to avoid measurements of multiple cells, e. g. no measurements were
performed in macrophage cell clusters. With regard to ramification analysis and
to measurements of the intracellular area, at least three exemplary cells were
analyzed per mouse. For quantification purposes, we defined increases in
fluorescence located directly around the injured site as the microglial response
[18],
[20].
Increases in fluorescence attributed to process ingrowth or soma migration were
not distinguished. We used the function
R(t) = (R
x(t)
− R
x(0))/R
y(0) as
described [18]. For this purpose, we used the Analyze Particle
function of ImageJ to measure the microglial density around an injury. Diameters
for outer (y) and inner (x) area were 70 µm and 35 µm, respectively.
We included only comparable lesions in the analysis, indicated by the average
size of the autofluorescence signal. The rate of engulfments was equally
measured in comparable regions (MIPs; xy-size about 250x250
µm2) in four preclinical, four clinical mice and four
controls.
Statistical analysis
For statistical analysis Origin 7 software (Northampton, USA) was used. Mean
values were given ± standard of the mean (SEM). Statistical significance
(p<0.05) was determined using ANOVA followed by Tukey test.
Results
In vivo 2P-LSM was applied to simultaneously record central axons of
projection neurons and microglia in the spinal cord [20], [21]. In a second approach, lower
motor axons and macrophages in spinal roots, peripheral nerves as well as
neuromuscular junctions were investigated.
Axon degeneration and microglia activation in lateral spinal cord of
SOD1G93A
Under general anesthesia and after exposure of the spinal cord segments L4 and L5
by laminectomy of the spines L1 to L3, a laser-induced lesion was set to the
lateral column of the spinal cord (Fig. 1). Using this approach, we were able to
record a part of the spinal cord under in vivo conditions which
largely carries out efferent, i. e. motor functions.
Figure 1
Axonal degeneration and microglial activation in the lateral column
of the spinal cord.
Spinal cord microglia cells were recorded, shown in part with
neighbouring axons, within the lateral column during the disease course
of SOD1G93A. The experiments were performed in double
transgenic mice expressing EGFP in microglia and EYFP in projection
neurons. For better visualization, EYFP fluorescence is depicted with a
red color table in all images. All two-photon images are arranged such
that rostral is to the left side. ,
confocal image of a SMI32-stained cross section of spinal cord. Motor
neurons were stained in the ventral part of the lumbar spinal cord. The
autofluorescence of a lesion (arrow) induced by a two-photon laser pulse
before perfusion of the mouse indicates the area of in
vivo imaging in the lateral column of the spinal cord.
, Time course of axonal
degeneration in SOD1G93A mice. Recordings were obtained in
preclinical (75-day-old) and advanced clinical (120-day-old) stages in
comparable regions of the lateral spinal cord. In 120-day-old mutant
mice axons were mostly swollen and interrupted (some exemplary axons are
marked by arrows). Note the green fluorescence of monocytes inside the
vessels (vessel boundaries marked by arrowheads).
,,
Quantification of axonal and microglial signal density, respectively, in
comparable regions of the lateral spinal cord during the course of
disease from preclinical stage (60-day-old), onset of disease
(90-day-old) to advanced clinical stage (120-day-old).
, Continuous change of microglial
morphology towards a more ovoid and a less ramified shape from
preclinical stages (60-day-old and 75-day-old), onset of disease
(90-day-old) to clinical and advanced clinical stages (105-day-old and
120-day-old).
,,
Quantification of microglial ramification and process motility during
the same stages of disease as shown in .
, An exemplary microglia cell
cluster is depicted in a clinical stage (105-day-old). Values are
presented as mean ± SEM; statistical significance determined by
using ANOVA followed by Tukey test (*p<0.05, **p<0.01,
***p<0.001). GM, grey matter; WM, white matter; DC,
dorsal column; LC, lateral column; DR, dorsal root; VR, ventral
root.
Axonal degeneration and microglial activation in the lateral column
of the spinal cord.
Spinal cord microglia cells were recorded, shown in part with
neighbouring axons, within the lateral column during the disease course
of SOD1G93A. The experiments were performed in double
transgenic mice expressing EGFP in microglia and EYFP in projection
neurons. For better visualization, EYFP fluorescence is depicted with a
red color table in all images. All two-photon images are arranged such
that rostral is to the left side. ,
confocal image of a SMI32-stained cross section of spinal cord. Motor
neurons were stained in the ventral part of the lumbar spinal cord. The
autofluorescence of a lesion (arrow) induced by a two-photon laser pulse
before perfusion of the mouse indicates the area of in
vivo imaging in the lateral column of the spinal cord.
, Time course of axonal
degeneration in SOD1G93Amice. Recordings were obtained in
preclinical (75-day-old) and advanced clinical (120-day-old) stages in
comparable regions of the lateral spinal cord. In 120-day-old mutant
mice axons were mostly swollen and interrupted (some exemplary axons are
marked by arrows). Note the green fluorescence of monocytes inside the
vessels (vessel boundaries marked by arrowheads).
,,
Quantification of axonal and microglial signal density, respectively, in
comparable regions of the lateral spinal cord during the course of
disease from preclinical stage (60-day-old), onset of disease
(90-day-old) to advanced clinical stage (120-day-old).
, Continuous change of microglial
morphology towards a more ovoid and a less ramified shape from
preclinical stages (60-day-old and 75-day-old), onset of disease
(90-day-old) to clinical and advanced clinical stages (105-day-old and
120-day-old).
,,
Quantification of microglial ramification and process motility during
the same stages of disease as shown in .
, An exemplary microglia cell
cluster is depicted in a clinical stage (105-day-old). Values are
presented as mean ± SEM; statistical significance determined by
using ANOVA followed by Tukey test (*p<0.05, **p<0.01,
***p<0.001). GM, grey matter; WM, white matter; DC,
dorsal column; LC, lateral column; DR, dorsal root; VR, ventral
root.In rodents, different from the human anatomy, axons of the corticospinal tract
(CST) are located in both the deep part of the dorsal column as well as the
lateral column of the spinal cord. Affected upper motor axons are predominantly
observed in the lateral column of mSOD1mice [28]. Here, mainly descending
axons including approximately 20% of all CST axons are located.
Additionally, early vascular changes leading to neurotoxic microhemorrhages,
indicated by hemosiderin deposits, exist to a greater extent in the lateral
white matter of the spinal cord than in the dorsal or ventral white matter [29]. A high
number of degenerated, interrupted and swollen axons were found in the lateral
column of the lumbar spinal cord in clinically affected SOD1G93A
compared to preclinical animals (Fig. 1). Accordingly, signal density of
EYFP-labeled axons in comparable regions was reduced during disease course from
preclinical 60-day-old mice (set as 100±6.6%,
n = 6 mice) to 90-day-old (onset of disease,
68.9±8.6%, n = 6, p<0.05) and to
120-day-old animals (advanced clinical stage, 41.2±5.9%,
n = 6, p<0.001) (Fig. 1). The signal density
in 60-day-old mice was comparable to that in control mice
(101±2.6%, n = 8) (Fig. 1). The number of
axons in comparable regions was also reduced during the disease course from
60-day-old mice (set as 100±11.9%, n = 5
mice) to 90-day-old (44.3±5.5%, n = 4,
p<0.01) and to 120-day-old mice (25.9±2%,
n = 5, p<0.001). The number of axons in 60-day-old mice
was comparable to that in control mice (102.5±7%,
n = 6).Coinciding with axonal degeneration, signal density of EGFP-labeled microglia in
the respective areas significantly increased with the age of the mouse from
60-day-old (set as 100±10.8%, n = 6 mice) to
90-day-old (102.5±11.6%, n = 6) to
120-day-old animals (141.7±15.5%, n = 6,
p<0.05) (Fig.
1). The signal density in 60-day-old mice was
comparable to that in control mice (100.2±9.6%,
n = 8; Fig.
1). As shown previously in Iba1- and
CD11b-stained lumbar tissue, the number of activated microglia increases during
disease progression [4]. Furthermore, a substantial increase in the number of
activated microglia is observed in the ventral horn of the lumbar spinal cord in
clinical stages indicated by MHCII-staining [30]. In support with these
earlier studies, the number of EGFP-labeled microglia in the respective areas
significantly increased with the age of transgenic mice from 60-day-old (set as
100±9.4%, n = 5 mice) to 90-day-old
(118.3±7.6%, n = 4) and to 120-day-old
animals (173.3±24.7%, n = 5, p<0.05). The
number of microglia in 60-day-old mice was comparable to that in control mice
(97.7±12.5%, n = 6).During the course of the SOD1G93A disease, microglial cells in the
spinal cord lateral column underwent a continuous change of their morphology
towards an ameboid-like shape, indicating ongoing inflammatory activity (Fig. 1). The
number of microglial processes extending from the cell soma (so-called first
order processes) continuously decreased from preclinical stages (60-day-old:
4.55±0.3, n = 15 cells in 5 mice; 75-day-old:
4.22±0.22, n = 12 in 4 mice) and onset of disease
(90-day-old: 4.23±0.35, n = 18 in 6 mice) to
clinical stages (105-day-old: 3.18±0.19, n = 23 in 6
mice, p<0.01; 120-day-old: 2.78±0.21, n = 32
cells in 8 mice, p<0.001) (Fig.
1). The number of first order processes of
preclinical microglia was comparable to that of control microglia
(4.71±0.46, n = 16 in 6 mice) (Fig. 1).In addition, baseline motility of microglial processes slowed by nearly
50% in the same time course (60-day-old mice: 1.83±0.19
µm/min, n = 36 microglial processes in 5 mice;
75-day-old: 1.63±0.25 µm/min, n = 26 in 4
mice; 90-day-old: 1.86±0.23 µm/min, n = 41 in
6 mice; 105-day-old: 1.29±0.19 µm/min, n = 41
in 6 mice, p<0.05; 120-day-old: 0.9±0.11 µm/min,
n = 45 in 8 mice, p<0.01) (Fig. 1). Microglial
processes of 60-day-old to 90-day-old mice displayed comparable baseline
motility to processes of control microglia (2.26±0.44,
n = 33 in 6 mice). Process retractions similarly slowed
during the disease course (control: −2.25±0.39,
n = 33 in 6 mice; 60-day-old mice: −1.88±0.14
µm/min, n = 36 in 5 mice; 75-day-old:
−1.71±0.25 µm/min, n = 26 in 4 mice;
90-day-old: −1.82±0.2 µm/min, n = 41 in
6 mice; 105-day-old: −1.33±0.16 µm/min,
n = 41 in 6 mice, p<0.05; 120-day-old:
−1±0.08 µm/min, n = 45 in 8 mice,
p<0.001).Unlike WT-microglia, which mutually repel each other when neighbouring cells
encounter one another [19], mutant microglia formed cell clusters in clinical
stages of SOD1G93A (Fig.
1).
Highly reactive preclinical SOD1G93A microglia lose their
target-directed response in clinical stages
In the next set of experiments, we analyzed the microglial response towards
laser-mediated axonal injury during disease course. In Fig. 2, the microglial
reaction towards a single axon transection in the spinal lateral column is
demonstrated in controls (Videos S1 and S2)
compared to SOD1G93Amice in different disease stages (preclinical
stage at 60-day-old, onset of disease at 90-day-old and advanced clinical stage
at 120-day-old mice; Videos S3, S4, S5).
Coinciding with a slowed baseline motility of microglial processes in clinical
stages (Fig.
1), the velocity of process extensions towards the
lesion site was also significantly decreased in these stages (105-day-old:
2.44±0.18 µm/min, n = 42 microglial processes
in 5 mice, p<0.001; 120-day-old: 2.13±0.1 µm/min,
n = 61 in 7 mice, p<0.001) compared to controls
(3.03±0.13 µm/min, n = 63 in 7 mice) (Fig. 2). The
latter was comparable with lesion-induced process movements in preclinical
stages and at disease onset of SOD1G93A (60-day-old: 3.09±0.07
µm/min, n = 46 in 5 mice; 75-day-old:
2.99±0.09 µm/min, n = 35 in 4 mice;
90-day-old: 2.83±0.17 µm/min, n = 36 in 4
mice) (Fig.
2).
Figure 2
Microglial response in the lateral column of the spinal cord during
SOD1G93A disease course.
Microglial reaction towards laser-induced single axon transections within
the lateral column of the spinal cord during SOD1G93A disease
course. , Left images were taken 3 min
after axonal transection (autofluorescence and arrow) in control and
mutant [preclinical 60-day-old, 90-day-old (onset of disease) and
advanced clinical 120-day-old] mice. Images on the right were taken
60 min post lesion. See also Videos S1, S2,
S3, S4, S5.
,,
Quantification of the velocity of microglial process movements and of
microglial lesion response (increase of EGFP fluorescence in a defined
area around the injury) to the injured site from preclinical stages
(60-day-old and 75-day-old), onset of disease (90-day-old) to clinical
and advanced clinical stages (105-day-old and 120-day-old). Control mice
were of corresponding age (60 to 140 days of age). Values are presented
as mean ± SEM; ANOVA followed by Tukey test (*p<0.05,
**p<0.01, ***p<0.001).
Microglial response in the lateral column of the spinal cord during
SOD1G93A disease course.
Microglial reaction towards laser-induced single axon transections within
the lateral column of the spinal cord during SOD1G93A disease
course. , Left images were taken 3 min
after axonal transection (autofluorescence and arrow) in control and
mutant [preclinical 60-day-old, 90-day-old (onset of disease) and
advanced clinical 120-day-old] mice. Images on the right were taken
60 min post lesion. See also Videos S1, S2,
S3, S4, S5.
,,
Quantification of the velocity of microglial process movements and of
microglial lesion response (increase of EGFP fluorescence in a defined
area around the injury) to the injured site from preclinical stages
(60-day-old and 75-day-old), onset of disease (90-day-old) to clinical
and advanced clinical stages (105-day-old and 120-day-old). Control mice
were of corresponding age (60 to 140 days of age). Values are presented
as mean ± SEM; ANOVA followed by Tukey test (*p<0.05,
**p<0.01, ***p<0.001).Furthermore, single axon transections led to a reduced response (increase in
fluorescence located directly around the injured site) of microglia towards the
lesion site in clinical stages (105-day-old: 47.2±7.8%,
n = 5 mice, p<0.05; 120-day-old:
44.4±6.1%, n = 6, p<0.01) compared to
control mice (set as 100±14.2%, n = 7) (Fig. 2;
Videos
S1, S2 and S5). At disease onset (90-day-old:
103.8±16.9%, n = 4), microglial response was
similar to controls (Fig.
2). Coinciding with ameboid transformation in
clinically affected mice, SOD1G93A microglia partly lose their
directed response towards lesioned tissue. Ameboid microglia, however, often
displayed permanent spontaneous activity with phagocytosis of morphologically
unaffected tissue (Video S6). This included permanent ameboid
migration and phagocytic activity. The rate of spontaneous engulfments by
microglial processes (13.3±3.9 engulfments in 250 µm×250
µm in 30 minutes, n = 4 mice, p<0.05) was
significantly higher than in control mice (1.75±0.25,
n = 4) or preclinical SOD1G93Amice
(2±0.6, n = 4).Microglial reaction towards the lesion site, however, was distinctly increased in
preclinical mice (60-day-old: 179.1±16.6%,
n = 5 mice, p<0.01; 75-day-old:
125.5±3.2%, n = 4; compared to controls, set
as 100±14.2%, n = 7) (Fig. 2; Videos S1,
S2,
S3,
S4).
This increased response of microglia comprised a rapid movement of cell somata
towards the lesion site (in some cases even within a few minutes after the
lesion) combined with early phagocytic activity (Fig. 2; Videos S3
and S4).
The response of preclinical microglia included engulfments within and around the
site of the laser-induced axonal transection.To analyze microglial behavior at different disease stages in clinically
non-affected spinal cord tissue, another set of experiments was performed within
superficial layers of the dorsal columns. These anatomic structures carry
primarily ascending fibers. Microglial response towards single axon transections
within spinal cord dorsal columns was independent of the stage of the
SOD1G93A disease (Fig. 3; Video S7, S8, S9).
Laser-induced lesions led to similar microglial reactions in mutant and control
mice (preclinical: 89.72±8.13%, n = 5 mice;
clinical: 97.83±8.71%, n = 6; compared to
controls [20],
set as 100±14%, n = 8). The comparison of
control reactions in dorsal and lateral spinal cord revealed no significant
differences of microglial reactivity within the two regions.
Figure 3
Microglial response in the dorsal column of the spinal cord during
SOD1G93A disease course.
Microglial reaction towards laser-induced single axon transections within
the spinal cord dorsal column (superficial layers as a sensory part,
carrying primarily ascending fibers). ,
Left images were taken 3 min after axonal transection (autofluorescence
and arrow) in control and mutant (preclinical 60-day-old and advanced
clinical 120-day-old) mice. Respective images (right) were taken 60 min
post lesion. See also Video S7, S8,
S9. , Quantification of
microglial response to the injured site. No significant differences were
observed between control and mSOD1 mice. Control mice were of
corresponding age (60 to 140 days of age). Values are presented as mean
± SEM; ANOVA followed by Tukey test.
Microglial response in the dorsal column of the spinal cord during
SOD1G93A disease course.
Microglial reaction towards laser-induced single axon transections within
the spinal cord dorsal column (superficial layers as a sensory part,
carrying primarily ascending fibers). ,
Left images were taken 3 min after axonal transection (autofluorescence
and arrow) in control and mutant (preclinical 60-day-old and advanced
clinical 120-day-old) mice. Respective images (right) were taken 60 min
post lesion. See also Video S7, S8,
S9. , Quantification of
microglial response to the injured site. No significant differences were
observed between control and mSOD1mice. Control mice were of
corresponding age (60 to 140 days of age). Values are presented as mean
± SEM; ANOVA followed by Tukey test.
Neurodegeneration and neuroinflammation in the peripheral nervous system of
SOD1G93A
Early dysfunction of lower motor neurons in SOD1G93Amice includes
axonal deficits (e. g. accumulation of neurofilaments), slowing of axonal
transport as well as retraction and loss of peripheral synapses at neuromuscular
junctions (NMJs) long before first clinical symptoms appear (from 40-day-old
animals onwards) [16]. This suggests an important and possibly even primary
role of the distal peripheral nervous system (PNS) in promoting motor neuron
degeneration, by e. g. retracting its nervous terminals [16], [17]. By exposing spinal roots
and respective dorsal root ganglia, time-lapse 2P-LSM imaging was applied to
analyze the role of macrophage-related neuroinflammation in peripheral axons.
Pseudounipolar neurons in dorsal root ganglia, axons in spinal roots and
surrounding macrophages were recorded simultaneously under above mentioned
in vivo conditions. Fig. 4 depicts an overview
of the exposed area of the central and peripheral nervous system in control and
in an advanced clinical stage mouse (120-day-old). The latter contains
degenerated central descending axons and degenerated lower motor axons in the
spinal lateral column and ventral root, respectively.
Figure 4
Degeneration of motor axons in spinal ventral roots during
SOD1G93A disease course.
, Reflected light overview (left side) of
the surgically exposed anatomic region. Central nervous system and
proximal peripheral nervous tissue is depicted. A corresponding area,
marked by the black box, was then recorded by 2P-LSM. The vessels in the
lateral column (LC) of the spinal cord could also be recognized on the
2P-LSM image (marked by arrows). The image shows central axons and
microglia of the lateral spinal cord as well as spinal root axons and
spinal root macrophages. In an advanced clinical stage (120-day-old),
axonal degeneration in the LC and in the recorded ventral root (VR),
indicated by interruptions and swellings (some exemplary marked by
arrows), were observed while dorsal root axons remain unaffected.
, Increase of motor axon
degeneration in the lumbar ventral roots from preclinical stages
(60-day-old and 75-day-old), onset of disease (90-day-old) to clinical
stages (105-day-old and 120-day-old). During this time course,
macrophages changed their morphology forming foamy cytoplasm (some
exemplary cells are marked by arrows).
,,
Quantification of axonal signal density and cellular area of macrophages
during the same disease stages that were shown in
. Control mice were of
corresponding age (60 to 140 days of age).
, No morphological reaction of
adjacent macrophages towards a laser-induced single axon transection
(autofluorescence in green and arrow) was observed in the ventral root
of preclinical (75-day-old) mice. The transection led to an acute axonal
degeneration at both sides of the injury. Values are presented as mean
± SEM; ANOVA followed by Tukey test (*p<0.05,
**p<0.01, ***p<0.001). LC, lateral column;
DRL2-L4, dorsal root of the spinal segments L2-L4; VRL2-L3, ventral root
of the spinal segments L2-L3; DRGL2, dorsal root ganglion of the spinal
segment L2.
Degeneration of motor axons in spinal ventral roots during
SOD1G93A disease course.
, Reflected light overview (left side) of
the surgically exposed anatomic region. Central nervous system and
proximal peripheral nervous tissue is depicted. A corresponding area,
marked by the black box, was then recorded by 2P-LSM. The vessels in the
lateral column (LC) of the spinal cord could also be recognized on the
2P-LSM image (marked by arrows). The image shows central axons and
microglia of the lateral spinal cord as well as spinal root axons and
spinal root macrophages. In an advanced clinical stage (120-day-old),
axonal degeneration in the LC and in the recorded ventral root (VR),
indicated by interruptions and swellings (some exemplary marked by
arrows), were observed while dorsal root axons remain unaffected.
, Increase of motor axon
degeneration in the lumbar ventral roots from preclinical stages
(60-day-old and 75-day-old), onset of disease (90-day-old) to clinical
stages (105-day-old and 120-day-old). During this time course,
macrophages changed their morphology forming foamy cytoplasm (some
exemplary cells are marked by arrows).
,,
Quantification of axonal signal density and cellular area of macrophages
during the same disease stages that were shown in
. Control mice were of
corresponding age (60 to 140 days of age).
, No morphological reaction of
adjacent macrophages towards a laser-induced single axon transection
(autofluorescence in green and arrow) was observed in the ventral root
of preclinical (75-day-old) mice. The transection led to an acute axonal
degeneration at both sides of the injury. Values are presented as mean
± SEM; ANOVA followed by Tukey test (*p<0.05,
**p<0.01, ***p<0.001). LC, lateral column;
DRL2-L4, dorsal root of the spinal segments L2-L4; VRL2-L3, ventral root
of the spinal segments L2-L3; DRGL2, dorsal root ganglion of the spinal
segment L2.During the course of the disease, lower motor axons in the lumbar ventral roots
continuously degenerated (Fig.
4). This was quantified by measuring signal
density of EYFP-labeled axonal structures in comparable anatomic regions as
mentioned previously. Even in preclinical stages (60-day-old and 75-day-old),
signal density was significantly lower than in control mice suggesting an early
axonal degeneration in the PNS. Signal density decreased with age from
60-day-old to 120-day-old animals (control set as 100±9.6%,
n = 10 mice; 60-day-old: 69.3±4.9%,
n = 9, p<0.05; 75-day-old: 55.6±8.8%,
n = 5, p<0.05; 90-day-old: 50.5±11%,
n = 6, p<0.001; 105-day-old: 37.9±2.6%,
n = 6, p<0.001; 120-day-old: 29.7±3.4%,
n = 9, p<0.001) (Fig. 4).During the same time course, macrophages changed their morphology forming foamy
cytoplasm indicating an intracellular accumulation of abundant lipid: a sign of
phagocytosis of degenerated myelinated tissue (Fig. 4). Accordingly, the
cellular volume of macrophages increased indicated by an increase of the
cellular 2-dimensional area in maximum intensity projections (MIPs) (control:
37.02±2.78 µm2, n = 38 single cells
in 10 mice; 60-day-old: 104.63±14.46 µm2,
n = 41 cells in 9 mice, p<0.05; 75-day-old:
103.58±23.45 µm2, n = 20 cells in 5
mice, p<0.05; 90-day-old: 171.24±24.71 µm2,
n = 26 cells in 6 mice, p<0.001; 105-day-old:
212.48±18.37 µm2, n = 36 cells in 6
mice, p<0.001; 120-day-old: 175.97±11.98 µm2,
n = 65 cells in 9 mice, p<0.001) (Fig. 4).In contrast to microglia in the CNS, macrophages of control and
SOD1G93Amice did not react towards laser-induced single axon
transections that led to acute symmetrical disintegration of ventral root axons
(Fig.
4). Also in peripheral nerves, macrophages did not
react towards similar axon transections (data not shown). Simultaneous
time-lapse recordings of adjacent areas of the central and peripheral nervous
system, involved in the pathophysiology of mSOD1, show the difference in
cellular activity between microglia and macrophages (clinical stage, Video
S10).Subtle involvement of sensory axons has been described in ALS [31], [32]. To test
whether neurodegeneration also takes place in sensory roots of
SOD1G93Amice, simultaneous 2P-LSM recordings of ventral and
dorsal lumbar roots were performed (Fig. 5). Interestingly, foamy transformed
macrophages could also be observed in dorsal roots of advanced clinical mice
(120-day-old). However, direct proof of axonal degeneration, e. g. axonal
interruptions, irregularities and swellings, was not found indicating only
subtle degenerative changes (Fig.
5).
Figure 5
Degeneration of peripheral nerves during the disease course in
SOD1G93A mice.
, Exemplary simultaneous 2P-LSM recordings
of axons and macrophages in ventral and dorsal lumbar roots in wild-type
and advanced clinical (120-day-old) mice. Degeneration of motor axons in
the ventral root and increase of the cellular volume of macrophages in
the ventral and dorsal roots were observed in the mutant mouse.
, Distinct degeneration of
peripheral axons in a 120-day-old SOD1G93A mouse (clinical
stage), shown by simultaneous recording of the 3 major nerves
originating from the sciatic nerve. The tibial nerve was more affected
than the common peroneal nerve or the sural nerve. Degenerated axons
were abundantly surrounded by foamy macrophages. The imaged region is
indicated in the insert (CCD camera image). Note that EYFP fluorescence
is depicted with a red color table. DRL2, dorsal root of the spinal
segment L2; VRL3, ventral root of the spinal segment L3.
Degeneration of peripheral nerves during the disease course in
SOD1G93A mice.
, Exemplary simultaneous 2P-LSM recordings
of axons and macrophages in ventral and dorsal lumbar roots in wild-type
and advanced clinical (120-day-old) mice. Degeneration of motor axons in
the ventral root and increase of the cellular volume of macrophages in
the ventral and dorsal roots were observed in the mutant mouse.
, Distinct degeneration of
peripheral axons in a 120-day-old SOD1G93Amouse (clinical
stage), shown by simultaneous recording of the 3 major nerves
originating from the sciatic nerve. The tibial nerve was more affected
than the common peroneal nerve or the sural nerve. Degenerated axons
were abundantly surrounded by foamy macrophages. The imaged region is
indicated in the insert (CCD camera image). Note that EYFP fluorescence
is depicted with a red color table. DRL2, dorsal root of the spinal
segment L2; VRL3, ventral root of the spinal segment L3.Retrograde axonal degeneration, initiated by abrupt distal pruning of selective
motor neuron axons, is assumed to be critical in the development of motor neuron
degeneration [16]. To study distal neurodegenerative processes in
SOD1G93Amice, we performed 2P-LSM recordings of more distal PNS
regions (Fig.
5 and 6). Simultaneous recordings of the 3 major nerves originating from
the sciatic nerve revealed different axonal vulnerabilities (Fig. 5).
Depending on the efferent fraction, the tibial nerve was more affected than the
common peroneal nerve or the sural nerve in clinical stages of the disease.
Similar to the neurodegeneration in ventral roots, degenerated axons were
surrounded by a high number of foamy macrophages, consistent with previous data
[33]. This
observation again indicates phagocytosis of myelinated tissue. In control
nerves, only a few macrophages, relatively small in size, were observed (Fig. 5).
Figure 6
Degeneration of neuromuscular junctions (NMJs) during
SOD1G93A disease course in a muscle innervated by
slow-motor neurons.
Exemplary motor axons and NMJs of musculus tenuissimus (containing mainly
slow twitch fibers) were imaged in control and SOD1G93A
(mSOD1) mice. EYFP fluorescence is depicted with a green color table.
The vascular network, labeled by central venous application of the
dextran Texas Red, is depicted with a red color table.
, Control NMJs
and the adjacent vascular network are shown in 3 dimensions (in
the same region from 4 different
perspectives is depicted). The inserts in
are a maximum intensity projection
(MIP, upper insert) and an epifluorescence image (lower insert) of the
two NMJs.
, Respective
motor axons of a complex of NMJs in a control mouse. Two adjacent NMJs
of different morphology are shown in the insert.
, Degeneration
of NMJs and their respective motor axons during the course of
SOD1G93A disease in musculus tenuissimus. 60-day-old:
morphologically unchanged NMJs when compared to controls; two intact
synapses are shown in the inserts. 80-day-old: degenerated (arrowhead)
or missing synapses (arrow) at the end of some motor axons; interrupted
axon terminals (arrowheads) are shown in the insert. 100-day-old:
advanced degeneration of the recorded axon complexes (including the
inserts), indicated by missing synapses (arrowhead on the right side of
the overview and arrowheads in the right insert), structures of
broad-spectrum fluorescence (arrowhead on the left side of the overview
and arrowheads in the left insert) and aberrant growth of axons.
120-day-old: interruption of a motor axon (arrowheads) and structures of
broad-spectrum fluorescence (arrow, arrowhead in the insert). Note that
musculus tenuissimus is innervated mainly by slow-motor neurons. These
motor neurons show signs of NMJ denervation in SOD1G93A mice
at approximately onset of disease. Scale bars, 20 µm; inserts, 10
µm.
Degeneration of neuromuscular junctions (NMJs) during
SOD1G93A disease course in a muscle innervated by
slow-motor neurons.
Exemplary motor axons and NMJs of musculus tenuissimus (containing mainly
slow twitch fibers) were imaged in control and SOD1G93A
(mSOD1) mice. EYFP fluorescence is depicted with a green color table.
The vascular network, labeled by central venous application of the
dextran Texas Red, is depicted with a red color table.
, Control NMJs
and the adjacent vascular network are shown in 3 dimensions (in
the same region from 4 different
perspectives is depicted). The inserts in
are a maximum intensity projection
(MIP, upper insert) and an epifluorescence image (lower insert) of the
two NMJs.
, Respective
motor axons of a complex of NMJs in a control mouse. Two adjacent NMJs
of different morphology are shown in the insert.
, Degeneration
of NMJs and their respective motor axons during the course of
SOD1G93A disease in musculus tenuissimus. 60-day-old:
morphologically unchanged NMJs when compared to controls; two intact
synapses are shown in the inserts. 80-day-old: degenerated (arrowhead)
or missing synapses (arrow) at the end of some motor axons; interrupted
axon terminals (arrowheads) are shown in the insert. 100-day-old:
advanced degeneration of the recorded axon complexes (including the
inserts), indicated by missing synapses (arrowhead on the right side of
the overview and arrowheads in the right insert), structures of
broad-spectrum fluorescence (arrowhead on the left side of the overview
and arrowheads in the left insert) and aberrant growth of axons.
120-day-old: interruption of a motor axon (arrowheads) and structures of
broad-spectrum fluorescence (arrow, arrowhead in the insert). Note that
musculus tenuissimus is innervated mainly by slow-motor neurons. These
motor neurons show signs of NMJ denervation in SOD1G93Amice
at approximately onset of disease. Scale bars, 20 µm; inserts, 10
µm.Early axonal vulnerability in motor neuron diseases is linked to axonal transport
impairment [16],
[34],
[35].
This “dying back” mechanism is associated with a selective
vulnerability of axonal transport leading to synaptic vesicle stalling and
subsequent synapse loss [16]. Fast-fatiguable (FF) motor axons are affected very
early (first detectable in nearly 40-day-old SOD1G93Amice), whereas
weakening, followed by loss of fast fatigue-resistant (FR) axons and weakening
of slow (S) axons coincide with the onset of the clinical phase and progression
during advanced clinical stages of the disease, respectively [16]. To determine
clinically associated degeneration of motor axons and their respective NMJs,
musculus tenuissimus consisting of slow twitch fibers, mainly innervated by FR
and S axons, was recorded in vivo. This muscle, provided with
retaining functions, is located proximal to the biceps femoris muscle (therefore
also known as the short head of the biceps) [36]. Fig. 6 show control
NMJs and the adjacent vascular network, labeled by central venous application of
the dextran conjugate Texas Red, within the muscle in 3 dimensions. Some
synapses were surrounded by thin vessels (an example is shown in Fig. 6).
Respective motor axons of a complex of NMJs are shown in Fig. 6. During the course
of the disease, the NMJs and their respective motor axons progressively
degenerated (Fig.
6). NMJs began to degenerate shortly before the
onset of the disease (80-day-old) indicated by missing synapses at motor axon
terminals and by interrupted axon terminals. Around onset of disease, a complete
degeneration of some NMJ complexes was observed (Fig. 6). In addition,
structures of broad-spectrum autofluorescence replaced degenerated synapses. In
addition, aberrant growth of axonal structures could be observed suggesting
compensatory attempts of motor axons to reinnervate muscle. Distinct
accumulations of similar autofluorescence were also observed in advanced
clinical stages (Fig.
6). In these stages, already numerous NMJs were
degenerated.
Discussion
Microglia substantially contribute to motor neuron death and disease progression in
mSOD1mouse models for ALS [4], [5], [6], [11], [14], [15]. Our study using the SOD1G93A-model provides
substantial in vivo evidence that microglia-mediated inflammation
in the CNS comprises two different phases with fluent transition: i) in preclinical
stages, microglia is highly reactive as indicated by an enhanced injury-induced
response including rapid soma migration and early phagocytic activity; ii) in
clinical stages, activated ameboid microglia lose their target-directed response,
but instead show spontaneous activity as a gain of function and a loss of its role
as highly dynamic surveillants of the CNS [19]. The increase of microglia
presence, the ameboid transformation, the loss of tissue surveillance and the
decrease of injury-directed process movements, all of them mainly occurring during
the clinical course, emphasize the contribution of microglia to disease progression
in mSOD1 animals in the late phase of disease. This is consistent with previous data
[4], [11].The enhanced microglial reactivity towards focal lesions in preclinical stages,
however, supports the role of microglia as a ‘double-edged sword’.
Erroneous (overactive) response to tissue injuries may represent early harmful
microglial activity that promotes axonal and neuronal degeneration. On the other
hand, rapid response to local damage leading to early clearing from debris and
neurotoxic molecules may also be beneficial and may even attenuate ongoing focal
neurodegeneration. Previous findings by selective gene silencing [4] support the
second interpretation of our observations.Several factors may contribute to the compromised function of mSOD1-microglia in
clinical stages such as cytoskeletal transformation towards an activated phenotype,
accompanied by alterations of transcriptional and non-transcriptional factors and
their functional consequences [23], [37]. These alterations may particularly include changes of
the expression profile of receptors and enzymes which bind signal molecules,
involved in sensing tissue abnormalities by microglia, such as ATP [18], [21], [38] and Nitric
oxide (NO) [20],
[39]. A
purinergic contribution to and an important role of NO in microglia-mediated motor
neuron degeneration has already been demonstrated [40], [41], [42], [43]. In particular, increase of
purinergic receptors on microglia [40] and enhanced inducible NO-synthase activity in microglia
of the spinal cord [42], [43] are correlated with an increased activity of microglia.
Interestingly, earlier studies provided evidence that microglial response to local
injuries depends on ATP and NO gradients rather than on overall ATP or NO
concentration [18], [20], [21], [38]. In the context of chronic neurodegenerative diseases, e.
g. ALS, constantly increased ATP/NO tissue levels as a consequence of ongoing tissue
destruction would impede the rapid development of local ATP/NO gradients. This may
explain, on a molecular level, the reduced microglial response to axonal injuries in
clinical stages. In addition, constantly high tissue levels of signal molecules may
lead to a decreased expression of respective receptors [38], which by themselves would
down-regulate the response of microglia.Even though the reported abnormalities in microglial behavior could be due to an
abnormally high level of mutated SOD1 per se in the
SOD1G93Amouse, previous data analyzing mice which overexpress the
human wild-type SOD1 demonstrate that at least the up-regulation of pro-inflammatory
cytokines in microglia is specifically due to the presence of the mutated gene [44]. Whether the
observed morphological and behavioral changes of microglia is due to the
mSOD1-protein overexpression within microglia cells or a response to local
environmental changes during the disease course, or both is a longstanding matter of
debate. Our data analyzing SOD1G93A microglia reaction in the
non-affected part of the spinal dorsal columns carrying primarily ascending fibers,
strongly suggest that environmental changes are at least a prerequisite for
microglia-mediated neuroinflammation. The unaltered microglial morphology and
reaction to axonal injury throughout the course of the disease in a sensory part of
the spinal cord emphasizes a secondary role of microglia-mediated neuroinflammation
in the pathophysiology of mSOD1. Furthermore, the finding that mutant microglia show
no aberrant inflammatory behavior in non-affected spinal tissue supports the
non-cell-autonomous pathophysiology of mSOD1.The process of microglial transformation is accompanied by changes of the cellular
expression profile. This leads to an increase of cytokine and radical release [23] which, by
itself, promotes further neuroinflammatory activity also in other cell types, e. g.
astrocytes. In this context, even extracellularly located mSOD1 proteins sustain or
trigger the ongoing neuroinflammation [45], [46]. However, our data do not
distinguish between an aberrant behavior of microglia due to the mutant SOD1
expression or to an activated state of microglia as response to chronic
environmental changes.Furthermore, we observed spontaneous formation of cell clusters in mSOD1mice. This
has not been described in WT or control animals in a number of recent studies
including in vivo imaging approaches [18], [19], [20], [21], [23]. This observation indicates
that a crucial role of microglia which is permanent tissue surveillance, is impaired
in mSOD1 animals. In support of this, a recent study shows formation of
multinucleated giant cells through fusion of microglial cells in the spinal cord of
clinically affected mSOD1mice [47]. On a cellular level microglia undergo, at least in part,
structural abnormalities during the course of mSOD1 disease which are indicative of
cellular degeneration [47].Recent data show that only a low number of CST fibers are found in the lateral white
matter (lateral CST fibers are mostly found in the dorsal portion of the lateral
column) [48]. In
addition, the diameter of CST fibers is relatively small (even if a population of
larger fibers was found in the lateral CST, more than 90% of the CST fibers
were less than 1.5 µm in diameter) [48]. Therefore, the high rate of
the observed degeneration of apparently relatively large axons in lateral spinal
cord suggests ongoing neurodegeneration within this part of the spinal cord white
matter that includes more fiber tracts than the pyramidal tracts. Whether additional
degeneration of the extrapyramidal system plays a role in the pathophysiology of
mSOD1 needs further investigation. Interestingly, extrapyramidal involvement seems
to play a role in stiffness and balance impairment in a subset of ALSpatients [49].Different to microglia-mediated neuroinflammation in the CNS, macrophages do not
respond to focal injuries in the PNS. Early involvement of macrophages includes
transformation to ‘foamy’ macrophages which indicates a passive role of
clearing debris, particularly lipid-rich myelin. This is in line with previous
findings showing changes in the expression profile of myelin-laden macrophages
towards a dominance of anti-inflammatory proteins [50]. Nonetheless, the functional
consequence of the apparently contradictory up-regulation of the activity marker
CD11b in peripheral macrophages during mSOD1 disease course, recently shown by
immunohistochemical analysis [51], has to be elucidated. An active role of macrophages in
chronic axonal neurodegeneration by, for instance, the release of toxic radicals or
cytokines can not be excluded and remains to be clarified. However, other data,
obtained by characterization of macrophage activation during disease progression,
also suggest phagocytic removal of debris as the primary role of macrophages in the
PNS emphasizing their non-detrimental function [33]. These findings are indications
of a primarily neurodegenerative process in the PNS without substantial inflammatory
contributions. They even suggest a rather pro-regenerative role of activated
macrophages. The data strengthen the idea of distinct inflammatory activities in the
CNS versus PNS, one with a dominant neuroinflammatory response in the CNS and
another with primarily degenerative processes in the PNS.Several studies suggested that axonal degeneration in the PNS including early loss of
NMJs is a primary pathophysiological event in fALS mice [16], [17], [52], [53], [54]. Immunohistochemical
investigations have revealed that axonal loss in lumbar ventral roots in preclinical
stages occurs earlier than cell body loss in the ventral horn of the spinal cord
[55].
Dysfunction of distal parts of the motor neuron apparently precedes the onset of
disease. Our data analyzing axonal degeneration in the PNS supports this hypothesis
by showing axonal loss in ventral roots of the lumbar spine as early as from day 60
onwards. However, neither can we, based on the presented in vivo
data, strictly confirm a ‘dying back’ mechanism nor a ‘distal
axonopathy’. Loss of neuromuscular junctions appears strongly dependent on the
type of muscle [16],
[52]. In
muscles mainly innervated by fast-fatigue-resistant and slow-motor neurons, such as
the musculus tenuissimus, pruning of motor axons and the respective NMJs begins at
symptom onset. In muscles mainly innervated by fast-fatigable motor neurons, loss of
NMJs is already observed in presymptomatic stages.Selective motor neuron degeneration arises from the convergence of a series of
pathophysiological factors [5], [56], [57], [58]. Neuroinflammation apparently goes along with
neurodegenerative processes. Using an in vivo imaging approach that
allows us to visualize cell-cell interaction over a time course of hours, we present
evidence for distinct mSOD1-induced inflammatory activities in the CNS versus the
PNS. We suggest that microglia-mediated neuroinflammation in the CNS promotes
neurodegeneration in clinical stages of the disease while cellular changes of
macrophages in the PNS support a passive role. Neurodegeneration with axonal
degeneration and loss of NMJs, considered a primary event in ALS pathogenesis, may
underlay the hitherto limited response of animal models or human trials to
anti-inflammatory therapies.Microglial reaction towards single axon transection in the spinal cord
lateral column of control mice. The experiments were performed in
double transgenic mice expressing EGFP in microglia and EYFP in projection
neurons. Microglia are depicted in green while, for better visualization and
distinction, axons are shown in red. All videos are arranged such that
rostral is to the left side. This video sequence (105 minutes length) lasts
from 45 minutes before to 60 minutes after a laser-induced axonal
transection (the injury was set at 0 min). It shows microglial reaction
towards the site of the injury (note the autofluorescence as speckles in the
image center; marked by arrow). Surrounding microglia immediately extended
their processes forming a shielding ring around the injury. The transection
led to an acute axonal degeneration at both sides of the injury, indicated
by interruptions and bulb-like swellings. Within the recorded time-lapse
sequence of 60 minutes after injury, reacting microglial cells polarized and
began to migrate in an ameboid manner towards the injured axon. No
phagocytic activity of microglia was observed within the first hour after
the injury. Note the monocytes within the blood vessels. The control mouse
was 90 days of age. The video sequence corresponds to a time-lapse series of
53 stacks of images. Each of these stacks is shown as a maximum intensity
projection (MIP). The frame rate of the video is about 2 minutes per MIP.
Scale bar, 20 µm.(MOV)Click here for additional data file.Detailed microglial reaction towards single axon transection in the
spinal cord lateral column of control mice. This video sequence
(75-minute) lasts from 15 minutes before to 60 minutes after a laser-induced
axonal transection. It shows microglial reaction towards the injured site
(note the autofluorescence; arrow) and the acute axonal degeneration in more
detail when compared with video S1. The control mouse was 120 days
of age. The frame rate of the video is 65 seconds per MIP. Scale bar, 20
µm.(MOV)Click here for additional data file.Enhanced response and early migration of microglia towards a single
axon transection in the lateral column of a preclinical
SOD1 This video sequence (195-minute)
lasts from 15 minutes before to 180 minutes after a laser-induced axonal
transection in a 60-day-old mutant mouse. It shows an increased response of
microglia towards the injured site (note the autofluorescence; arrow). The
response comprised a rapid movement of cell soma starting within a few
minutes after the injury. An enhanced and early (starting within the first
hour after the injury) phagocytic activity of microglia, indicated by
numerous engulfments within and around the injured site, could also be
observed. The frame rate of the video is about 90 seconds per MIP. Scale
bar, 20 µm.(MOV)Click here for additional data file.Early phagocytosis after a single axon transection in the lateral
column of a preclinical SOD1 This video
sequence (90-minute) lasts from 15 minutes before to 75 minutes after an
axonal transection in a 75-day-old mutant mouse. It shows, similar to the
Video
S3, an increased response of microglia towards the injured site
(note the autofluorescence in the image center; arrow). The response
comprised an early phagocytic activity of microglia at both sides of the
injury. Note the engulfment and the subsequent phagocytosis of an
EYFP-containing bulb-like swelling of the transected degenerating axon about
30 µm to the right to the injured site (arrow). The frame rate of the
video is 85 seconds per MIP. Scale bar, 20 µm.(MOV)Click here for additional data file.Lack of microglial reaction after single axon transection in the
lateral column of a clinical SOD1 This
video sequence (145-minute) lasts from 25 minutes before to 120 minutes
after an axonal transection in a 120-day-old mutant mouse. It shows a highly
reduced microglial reaction towards the tissue lesion (note the
autofluorescence in the image center; arrow). The axonal transection led to
degeneration of the axon at both sides of the injury without any apparent
contribution of microglia. Note the increased microglial activity including
numerous engulfments and continuous ameboid migration independent of the
injury setting. The frame rate of the video is 115 seconds per MIP. Scale
bar, 20 µm.(MOV)Click here for additional data file.Spontaneous activity of microglia in the lateral column of a clinical
SOD1 This video sequence (60-minute)
shows enhanced spontaneous activity of ameboid microglia in a 120-day-old
mutant mouse. This activity included permanent ameboid migration (arrows)
and permanent phagocytic processes. The frame rate of the video is 128
seconds per MIP. Scale bar, 20 µm.(MOV)Click here for additional data file.Microglial reaction towards a single axon transection in the spinal
dorsal column of a control mouse. This video sequence (80-minute)
lasts from 7 minutes before to 73 minutes after an axonal transection (set
at 0 min). It shows microglial reaction towards the site of the injury (note
the autofluorescence; arrow). Surrounding microglia immediately extended
their processes forming a shielding ring around the injury. The transection
led to an acute axonal degeneration at both sides of the injury. Note the
monocytes within the blood vessels. The control mouse was 90 days of age.
The frame rate of the video is 80 seconds per MIP. Scale bar, 20
µm.(MOV)Click here for additional data file.Microglial reaction towards a single axon transection in the spinal
cord dorsal column of a preclinical SOD1
This video sequence (80-minute) lasts from 20 minutes before to 60 minutes
after an axonal transection in a 60-day-old mutant mouse. It shows, similar
to the control mouse (Video S7), microglial reaction towards
the site of the injury (note the autofluorescence; arrow). The frame rate of
the video is about 1 minute per MIP. Scale bar, 20 µm.(MOV)Click here for additional data file.Microglial reaction towards a single axon transection in the spinal
cord dorsal column of a clinical SOD1 This
video sequence (64-minute) lasts from 4 minutes before to 60 minutes after
an axonal transection in a 120-day-old mutant mouse. It shows, similar to
the Video
S7 and S8, microglial reactions towards the site
of the injury (note the autofluorescence; arrow). Note the monocytes within
the blood vessel on the left side. The frame rate of the video is 116
seconds per MIP. Scale bar, 20 µm.(MOV)Click here for additional data file.Simultaneous recording of microglia and macrophages in a clinical
SOD1 This video sequence (45-minute)
shows spontaneous microglial activity and cluster formation in the lateral
column of the spinal cord (upper part) compared to minimal morphological
movements of macrophages in an adjacent ventral root (lower part) in a
105-day-old mutant mouse. The frame rate of the video is about 73 seconds
per MIP. Scale bar, 20 µm.(MOV)Click here for additional data file.
Authors: Bahareh Ajami; Jami L Bennett; Charles Krieger; Wolfram Tetzlaff; Fabio M V Rossi Journal: Nat Neurosci Date: 2007-11-18 Impact factor: 24.884
Authors: Arie Gruzman; William L Wood; Evgenia Alpert; M Dharma Prasad; Robert G Miller; Jeffery D Rothstein; Robert Bowser; Ronald Hamilton; Troy D Wood; Don W Cleveland; Vishwanath R Lingappa; Jian Liu Journal: Proc Natl Acad Sci U S A Date: 2007-07-16 Impact factor: 11.205
Authors: Katrin I Andreasson; Adam D Bachstetter; Marco Colonna; Florent Ginhoux; Clive Holmes; Bruce Lamb; Gary Landreth; Daniel C Lee; Donovan Low; Marina A Lynch; Alon Monsonego; M Kerry O'Banion; Milos Pekny; Till Puschmann; Niva Russek-Blum; Leslie A Sandusky; Maj-Linda B Selenica; Kazuyuki Takata; Jessica Teeling; Terrence Town; Linda J Van Eldik Journal: J Neurochem Date: 2016-09 Impact factor: 5.372
Authors: Isaac M Chiu; Emiko T A Morimoto; Hani Goodarzi; Jennifer T Liao; Sean O'Keeffe; Hemali P Phatnani; Michael Muratet; Michael C Carroll; Shawn Levy; Saeed Tavazoie; Richard M Myers; Tom Maniatis Journal: Cell Rep Date: 2013-07-11 Impact factor: 9.423
Authors: Jonathan M Van Dyke; Ivy M Smit-Oistad; Corey Macrander; Dan Krakora; Michael G Meyer; Masatoshi Suzuki Journal: Exp Neurol Date: 2016-01-13 Impact factor: 5.330