Imad Al-Dakkak1. 1. Centre for Evidence-based Dentistry, Oxford, UK.
Abstract
DATA SOURCES: MEDLINE/PubMed and EMBASE. STUDY SELECTION: The review included papers published between January 1, 1990 and December 31, 2008. The primary outcome was to retrieve all literature containing original data on dental caries, periodontal disease and pre-cancer dental clearance protocols in cancer patients undergoing head and neck radiotherapy, chemotherapy or combined treatment modalities. Excluded studies included systematic and non-systematic reviews, microbiology studies, growth and development studies, organ transplant studies, studies eliciting dental complications through questionnaires, studies reporting data from previous publications, phase I and II trials, opinion papers, case reports, articles published before 1990, and publications from the 1990 National Cancer Institute Monographs, which were based on the 1989 National Institutes of Health Development Consensus Conference on the Oral Complications of Cancer Therapies. DATA EXTRACTION AND SYNTHESIS: Each article was independently evaluated by two reviewers with pilot-tested collection forms customised for reviewing dental disease data. Dental caries was assessed by the presence (Y/N), DMFT/dmft (decayed, missing, and filled teeth: DMFT for permanent adult teeth and dmft signifying deciduous teeth), and DMFS/dmfs indexes (decayed, missing, and filled surfaces: DMFS for permanent adult teeth and dmfs signifying deciduous teeth), if available. In addition, periodontal health was assessed using the plaque and gingival indexes. Further data collected for each article such as type of study, blinding, presence of control group, scale validity, and sample size were used to determine quality outcomes utilised to determine the weighted prevalence of caries and dental infection. RESULTS: Sixty-four published papers between 1990 and 2008 were reviewed. The weighted overall prevalence of dental caries was 28.1%. The overall DMFT for patients who were post-antineoplastic therapy was 9.19 (n=457). The overall plaque index for patients who were post-antineoplastic therapy was 1.38 (n=189). The gingival index for patients who were post-chemotherapy was 1.02 (n=162). The weighted prevalence of dental infection/abscess during chemotherapy was reported in three studies and was 5.8%. CONCLUSIONS: Patients who were post-radiotherapy had the highest DMFT. The use of fluoride products and chlorhexidine rinses is beneficial in patients who are post-radiotherapy. There continues to be a lack of clinical studies on the extent and severity of dental disease that are associated with infectious complications during cancer therapy.
DATA SOURCES: MEDLINE/PubMed and EMBASE. STUDY SELECTION: The review included papers published between January 1, 1990 and December 31, 2008. The primary outcome was to retrieve all literature containing original data on dental caries, periodontal disease and pre-cancer dental clearance protocols in cancerpatients undergoing head and neck radiotherapy, chemotherapy or combined treatment modalities. Excluded studies included systematic and non-systematic reviews, microbiology studies, growth and development studies, organ transplant studies, studies eliciting dental complications through questionnaires, studies reporting data from previous publications, phase I and II trials, opinion papers, case reports, articles published before 1990, and publications from the 1990 National Cancer Institute Monographs, which were based on the 1989 National Institutes of Health Development Consensus Conference on the Oral Complications of Cancer Therapies. DATA EXTRACTION AND SYNTHESIS: Each article was independently evaluated by two reviewers with pilot-tested collection forms customised for reviewing dental disease data. Dental caries was assessed by the presence (Y/N), DMFT/dmft (decayed, missing, and filled teeth: DMFT for permanent adult teeth and dmft signifying deciduous teeth), and DMFS/dmfs indexes (decayed, missing, and filled surfaces: DMFS for permanent adult teeth and dmfs signifying deciduous teeth), if available. In addition, periodontal health was assessed using the plaque and gingival indexes. Further data collected for each article such as type of study, blinding, presence of control group, scale validity, and sample size were used to determine quality outcomes utilised to determine the weighted prevalence of caries and dental infection. RESULTS: Sixty-four published papers between 1990 and 2008 were reviewed. The weighted overall prevalence of dental caries was 28.1%. The overall DMFT for patients who were post-antineoplastic therapy was 9.19 (n=457). The overall plaque index for patients who were post-antineoplastic therapy was 1.38 (n=189). The gingival index for patients who were post-chemotherapy was 1.02 (n=162). The weighted prevalence of dental infection/abscess during chemotherapy was reported in three studies and was 5.8%. CONCLUSIONS:Patients who were post-radiotherapy had the highest DMFT. The use of fluoride products and chlorhexidine rinses is beneficial in patients who are post-radiotherapy. There continues to be a lack of clinical studies on the extent and severity of dental disease that are associated with infectious complications during cancer therapy.