OBJECTIVE: To determine the comparability between cause of death (COD) by a single physician coder and a two-physician panel, using verbal autopsy. METHODS: The study was conducted between May 2007 and June 2008. Within a week of a perinatal death in 38 rural remote communities in Guatemala, the Democratic Republic of Congo, Zambia and Pakistan, VA questionnaires were completed. Two independent physicians, unaware of the others decisions, assigned an underlying COD, in accordance with the causes listed in the chapter headings of the International classification diseases and related health problems, 10th revision (ICD-10). Cohen's kappa statistic was used to assess level of agreement between physician coders. RESULTS: There were 9461 births during the study period; 252 deaths met study enrolment criteria and underwent verbal autopsy. Physicians assigned the same COD for 75% of stillbirths (SB) (K = 0.69; 95% confidence interval: 0.61-0.78) and 82% early neonatal deaths (END) (K = 0.75; 95% confidence interval: 0.65-0.84). The patterns and proportion of SBs and ENDs determined by the physician coders were very similar compared to causes individually assigned by each physician. Similarly, rank order of the top five causes of SB and END was identical for each physician. CONCLUSION: This study raises important questions about the utility of a system of multiple coders that is currently widely accepted and speculates that a single physician coder may be an effective and economical alternative to VA programmes that use traditional two-physician panels to assign COD.
OBJECTIVE: To determine the comparability between cause of death (COD) by a single physician coder and a two-physician panel, using verbal autopsy. METHODS: The study was conducted between May 2007 and June 2008. Within a week of a perinatal death in 38 rural remote communities in Guatemala, the Democratic Republic of Congo, Zambia and Pakistan, VA questionnaires were completed. Two independent physicians, unaware of the others decisions, assigned an underlying COD, in accordance with the causes listed in the chapter headings of the International classification diseases and related health problems, 10th revision (ICD-10). Cohen's kappa statistic was used to assess level of agreement between physician coders. RESULTS: There were 9461 births during the study period; 252 deaths met study enrolment criteria and underwent verbal autopsy. Physicians assigned the same COD for 75% of stillbirths (SB) (K = 0.69; 95% confidence interval: 0.61-0.78) and 82% early neonatal deaths (END) (K = 0.75; 95% confidence interval: 0.65-0.84). The patterns and proportion of SBs and ENDs determined by the physician coders were very similar compared to causes individually assigned by each physician. Similarly, rank order of the top five causes of SB and END was identical for each physician. CONCLUSION: This study raises important questions about the utility of a system of multiple coders that is currently widely accepted and speculates that a single physician coder may be an effective and economical alternative to VA programmes that use traditional two-physician panels to assign COD.
Authors: Philip W Setel; Osman Sankoh; Chalapati Rao; Victoria A Velkoff; Colin Mathers; Yang Gonghuan; Yusuf Hemed; Prabhat Jha; Alan D Lopez Journal: Bull World Health Organ Date: 2005-09-22 Impact factor: 9.408
Authors: Philip W Setel; Sarah B Macfarlane; Simon Szreter; Lene Mikkelsen; Prabhat Jha; Susan Stout; Carla AbouZahr Journal: Lancet Date: 2007-11-03 Impact factor: 79.321
Authors: Elizabeth M McClure; Linda L Wright; Robert L Goldenberg; Shivaprasad S Goudar; Sailajanandan N Parida; Imtiaz Jehan; Antoinette Tshefu; Elwyn Chomba; Fernando Althabe; Ana Garces; Hillary Harris; Richard J Derman; Pinaki Panigrahi; Cyril Engmann; Pierre Buekens; Michael Hambidge; Waldemar A Carlo Journal: Am J Obstet Gynecol Date: 2007-09 Impact factor: 8.661
Authors: Robert M Silver; Michael W Varner; Uma Reddy; Robert Goldenberg; Halit Pinar; Deborah Conway; Radek Bukowski; Marshall Carpenter; Carol Hogue; Marian Willinger; Donald Dudley; George Saade; Barbara Stoll Journal: Am J Obstet Gynecol Date: 2007-05 Impact factor: 8.661
Authors: Cyril Engmann; John Ditekemena; Imtiaz Jehan; Ana Garces; Mutinta Phiri; Vanessa Thorsten; Manolo Mazariegos; Elwyn Chomba; Omrana Pasha; Antoinette Tshefu; Elizabeth M McClure; Dennis Wallace; Robert L Goldenberg; Waldemar A Carlo; Linda L Wright; Carl Bose Journal: Popul Health Metr Date: 2011-08-05
Authors: Rafael Lozano; Alan D Lopez; Charles Atkinson; Mohsen Naghavi; Abraham D Flaxman; Christopher Jl Murray Journal: Popul Health Metr Date: 2011-08-04
Authors: Ana L Garces; Elizabeth M McClure; Wilton Pérez; K Michael Hambidge; Nancy F Krebs; Lester Figueroa; Carl L Bose; Waldemar A Carlo; Constance Tenge; Fabian Esamai; Shivaprasad S Goudar; Sarah Saleem; Archana B Patel; Melody Chiwila; Elwyn Chomba; Antoinette Tshefu; Richard J Derman; Patricia L Hibberd; Sherri Bucher; Edward A Liechty; Melissa Bauserman; Janet L Moore; Marion Koso-Thomas; Menachem Miodovnik; Robert L Goldenberg Journal: Acta Paediatr Date: 2017-04-05 Impact factor: 2.299
Authors: Elizabeth M McClure; Carl L Bose; Ana Garces; Fabian Esamai; Shivaprasad S Goudar; Archana Patel; Elwyn Chomba; Omrana Pasha; Antoinette Tshefu; Bhalchandra S Kodkany; Sarah Saleem; Waldemar A Carlo; Richard J Derman; Patricia L Hibberd; Edward A Liechty; K Michael Hambidge; Nancy F Krebs; Melissa Bauserman; Marion Koso-Thomas; Janet Moore; Dennis D Wallace; Alan H Jobe; Robert L Goldenberg Journal: Matern Health Neonatol Perinatol Date: 2015-05-04