| Literature DB >> 21244655 |
Laila J Salomonsen1, Lasse Skovgaard, Søren la Cour, Lisbeth Nyborg, Laila Launsø, Vinjar Fønnebø.
Abstract
BACKGROUND: Several studies have found that a high proportion of the population in western countries use complementary and alternative medicine (CAM). However, little is known about whether CAM is offered in hospitals. The aim of this study was to describe to what extent CAM is offered in Norwegian and Danish hospitals and investigate possible changes in Norway since 2001.Entities:
Mesh:
Year: 2011 PMID: 21244655 PMCID: PMC3033860 DOI: 10.1186/1472-6882-11-4
Source DB: PubMed Journal: BMC Complement Altern Med ISSN: 1472-6882 Impact factor: 3.659
CAM on offer in Norwegian and Danish hospitals in number and percentage
| Type of Hospital | ||||||||||||
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| Somatic*1 | Psychiatric*2 | Public | Private | Less than | 100 or more | |||||||
| n | % | n | % | n | % | n | % | n | % | n | % | |
| Norway | 46/88 | 52,3 | 4/11 | 28,6 | 41/68 | 60,3 | 9/31 | 29 | 18/57 | 31,6 | 32/42 | 76,2 |
| Denmark | 33/100 | 33 | 6/26 | 23,1 | 33/98 | 33,7 | 6/28 | 21,4 | 13/60 | 21,7 | 26/66 | 39,4 |
*1: Some of the Norwegian and Danish somatic hospitals also include psychiatric units.
*2: The Norwegian psychiatric hospitals cover only private institutions and for Denmark only public.
Therapies offered at Norwegian and Danish hospitals
| Acupuncture | Other CAM | More than one CAM | ||||
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| Number | % | Number | % | Number | % | |
| Norway | 40/50 | 80,0 | 19/50 | 38,0 | 9/50 | 18,0 |
| Denmark | 38/39 | 97,4 | 1/39 | 2,6 | None | 0,0 |
Norway: Other CAM therapies include: TENS-trancutan electric nerve stimulation, Biofeedback, hypnosis, cupping, ear-acupuncture, herbal medicine, massage, musical therapy, art- and expression therapy, art therapy, reflexology, thought field therapy, alternative food, gestalt therapy, psychodrama, aromatherapy, tai chi, acupressure, sound- and music therapy, yoga, pilates and foot-massage.
Denmark: Other CAM therapies include: EMDR - Eye Movement Desensitisation and Reprocessing light therapy.
CAM offered in different fields of medicine
| Departments | ||
|---|---|---|
| Norway | Denmark | |
| Acupuncture | Maternity ward, emergency medicine dept, dept pain therapy/pain clinic, dept for blood disease, dept of physical/occupational therapy, Psychiatric dept, oncology dept, surgical/anaesthetic dept, gynaecological dept, out-patients' pain clinic, substance abuse-related care, palliative care | Maternity ward, dept pain therapy/pain clinic, dept for blood disease, Psychiatric dept, oncology dept, surgical/anaesthetic dept, gynaecological dept, out-patients' pain clinic, substance abuse-related care, palliative care |
| Other CAM therapies | Psychiatric dept, patients at different departments, cancer rehabilitation, dept physical/occupational therapy, substance abuse-related care, palliative care, maternity ward, dept reumathology, center for patients education, palliative care | Information not given |
Figure 1% of hospitals reporting use of CAM. Year of start-up for the Norwegian (N) and Danish (DK) hospitals that reportedly offered CAM in 2008. The blue line shows the number of hospitals in Norway that either offer acupuncture or in addition also other treatments. The green line shows the number of hospitals that only give other kind of treatments than acupuncture. Other therapy forms are listed below Table 2. The red line shows the number of hospitals in Denmark that offer acupuncture. Norway, total respondents = 99, Denmark, total respondents = 126.
Selected data from interviews with contact persons
| Norway %/n | Denmark %/n | ||
|---|---|---|---|
| Before 2000 | 45,3%/29 | 26%/10 | |
| After 2000 | 46,9%/30 | 74%/28 | |
| Not given | 7,8%/5 | 0 | |
| Pain relief: | 17%/11 | 0 *** | |
| Treatment without side effects: | 6%/4 | 21%/8 | |
| Scientific evidence: | 5%/3* | 32%/12 | |
| Interest from the employees: | 25%/16 | 21%/8 | |
| Interest from patients: | 9%/6 | 8%/3 | |
| Other: | 38%/24** | 18%/7** | |
| 9%/6 | 42%/15 | ||
| 23%/15 | 59%/23 | ||
| 84%/54 | 74%/28 | ||
| Yes | 36%/23 | 43%/16 | |
| No | 53%/34 | 57%/22 | |
| Do not know | 11%/7 |
* The argument of scientific evidence was often used as a reason for why the treatment was not considered as CAM and not as much as a motive for starting up.
** Examples of other motives: "in fashion", extra offer, successful attempt against weight loss/nausea, heard the treatment worked, when nothing else work, good impact on health according to bad sleep/anxiety/immune system/energy, holistic approach.
*** The reason why "pain relief" is not reported as a motive for starting up use of CAM in Danish hospitals might be that it is included in the other four motives. As seen in table 5 pain relief is an important indication for use of acupuncture in Danish hospitals.
Indications for offering CAM.
| Indication | ||
|---|---|---|
| Norway | Denmark | |
| Acupuncture | ||
| Other CAM therapies | Pelvic tension, colic, anxiety, ADHD, behaviour problems, nausea, substance abuse and allergy | Not answered |