Elective neck dissection in clinical stage I squamous cell carcinoma of the tongue: Does it improve regional control or survival time?

The objective of this study was to evaluate whether elective neck dissection could improve regional control or survival time in clinical stage I squamous cell carcinoma of the oral tongue (OTSCC). This was a retrospective study of patients with surgical treatment between January 1991 and December 2003. A total of 131 patients were included in the study, and all of them received operation of the primary site, while 88 cases underwent selective neck dissection simultaneously including level I-III neck dissection in 49 patients and level I-V neck dissection in 39 patients. In all these cases, the rate of occult neck metastases was 23.7%. The 4-year local control rates in patients with only primary site treatment, patients with level I-III neck dissection and patients with level I-V neck dissection were 81.0%, 83.6% and 89.1%, respectively. By univariate analyse, neck dissection did not increase regional control rate, disease free survival (DFS) or overall survival (OS). Multivariate analyses showed that neck dissection was not an independent factor for DFS or OS. This study showed that the occult neck metastases rate was 23.7% in clinical stage I OTSCC. Elective neck dissection did not significantly improve regional control, DFS and OS in clinical stage I patients. There is a need for accurate and valid methods to select the patients who would benefit from elective neck treatment.