OBJECTIVE: To assess the inappropriate use of causal language in studies on obesity and nutrition. METHODS: Titles and abstracts of 525 peer-reviewed papers in the 4 leading journals in the fields of obesity and nutrition were scrutinized for language implying causality in observational studies published in 2006. RESULTS: Such misleading language appeared in 161 papers (31%) independent of funding source. Remarkably 49% of studies lacking statistically significant primary outcomes used misleading language compared to 29% of those with p values ≤0.05 (chi square p < 0.001). Exculpatory language was present in the body of the text in 19%; of the 161 studies. CONCLUSION: We suggest that editors and reviewers evaluate submissions for misleading reporting.
OBJECTIVE: To assess the inappropriate use of causal language in studies on obesity and nutrition. METHODS: Titles and abstracts of 525 peer-reviewed papers in the 4 leading journals in the fields of obesity and nutrition were scrutinized for language implying causality in observational studies published in 2006. RESULTS: Such misleading language appeared in 161 papers (31%) independent of funding source. Remarkably 49% of studies lacking statistically significant primary outcomes used misleading language compared to 29% of those with p values ≤0.05 (chi square p < 0.001). Exculpatory language was present in the body of the text in 19%; of the 161 studies. CONCLUSION: We suggest that editors and reviewers evaluate submissions for misleading reporting.
Authors: Erik von Elm; Douglas G Altman; Matthias Egger; Stuart J Pocock; Peter C Gøtzsche; Jan P Vandenbroucke Journal: PLoS Med Date: 2007-10-16 Impact factor: 11.069
Authors: Jameson D Voss; Roger A Erich; Pauline M Lucas; Danny C Dacey; Carol C Walters; James R Poel Journal: Hawaii J Med Public Health Date: 2016-09
Authors: Keisuke Ejima; Peng Li; Daniel L Smith; Tim R Nagy; Inga Kadish; Thomas van Groen; John A Dawson; Yongbin Yang; Amit Patki; David B Allison Journal: Eur J Clin Invest Date: 2016-10-28 Impact factor: 4.686
Authors: Andrew W Brown; Stella Aslibekyan; Dennis Bier; Rafael Ferreira da Silva; Adam Hoover; David M Klurfeld; Eric Loken; Evan Mayo-Wilson; Nir Menachemi; Greg Pavela; Dale Schoeller; Colby J Vorland; Leah D Whigham; David B Allison Journal: Crit Rev Food Sci Nutr Date: 2021-10-22 Impact factor: 11.208
Authors: David B Allison; Josep Bassaganya-Riera; Barbara Burlingame; Andrew W Brown; Johannes le Coutre; Suzanne L Dickson; Willem van Eden; Johan Garssen; Raquel Hontecillas; Chor San H Khoo; Dietrich Knorr; Martin Kussmann; Pierre J Magistretti; Tapan Mehta; Adrian Meule; Michael Rychlik; Claus Vögele Journal: Front Nutr Date: 2015-09-08