Umair Ansari1, S Adie, I A Harris, J M Naylor. 1. Orthopaedic Department, Liverpool Hospital, Locked Bag 7103, Liverpool, BC, NSW 1871, Australia. uhussaina@gmail.com
Abstract
BACKGROUND: Practice variation may indicate a lack of clear evidence to guide treatment. This study aims to quantify practice variation for common orthopaedic fractures, and to explore possible predictors of the variation. MATERIALS AND METHODS: A nationwide electronic survey of Australian orthopaedic surgeons was performed. Five common fractures (ankle, scaphoid, distal radius, neck of humerus, and clavicle) were presented. Data on management preferences and surgeon background were gathered. Potential predictors of operative (vs. non-operative) treatment were explored. RESULTS: 358 of 760 (47%) surgeons responded. For the ankle, undisplaced scaphoid, distal radius, neck of humerus and clavicle fractures, operative treatment was chosen in 40%, 44%, 77%, 26% and 38%, respectively. Operative treatment was significantly more likely to be chosen by more junior surgeons, and by surgeons specialising in the affected area (i.e., shoulder surgeons for clavicle and neck of humerus fractures, and hand surgeons for scaphoid and distal radius fractures). CONCLUSIONS: Variations exist in the management of common fractures. Variation may represent legitimate improvisation for varying clinical scenarios, but it may reflect clinician bias, which in turn, may contribute to varying standards of care for the management of common conditions.
BACKGROUND: Practice variation may indicate a lack of clear evidence to guide treatment. This study aims to quantify practice variation for common orthopaedic fractures, and to explore possible predictors of the variation. MATERIALS AND METHODS: A nationwide electronic survey of Australian orthopaedic surgeons was performed. Five common fractures (ankle, scaphoid, distal radius, neck of humerus, and clavicle) were presented. Data on management preferences and surgeon background were gathered. Potential predictors of operative (vs. non-operative) treatment were explored. RESULTS: 358 of 760 (47%) surgeons responded. For the ankle, undisplaced scaphoid, distal radius, neck of humerus and clavicle fractures, operative treatment was chosen in 40%, 44%, 77%, 26% and 38%, respectively. Operative treatment was significantly more likely to be chosen by more junior surgeons, and by surgeons specialising in the affected area (i.e., shoulder surgeons for clavicle and neck of humerus fractures, and hand surgeons for scaphoid and distal radius fractures). CONCLUSIONS: Variations exist in the management of common fractures. Variation may represent legitimate improvisation for varying clinical scenarios, but it may reflect clinician bias, which in turn, may contribute to varying standards of care for the management of common conditions.
Authors: David W G Langerhuizen; Stein J Janssen; Joost T P Kortlever; David Ring; Gino M M J Kerkhoffs; Ruurd L Jaarsma; Job N Doornberg Journal: J Wrist Surg Date: 2021-03-11
Authors: Andrew Lawson; Justine Naylor; Rachelle Buchbinder; Rebecca Ivers; Zsolt J Balogh; Paul Smith; Wei Xuan; Kirsten Howard; Arezoo Vafa; Diana Perriman; Rajat Mittal; Piers Yates; Bertram Rieger; Geoff Smith; Sam Adie; Ilia Elkinson; Woosung Kim; Jai Sungaran; Kim Latendresse; James Wong; Sameer Viswanathan; Keith Landale; Herwig Drobetz; Phong Tran; Richard Page; Sally Beattie; Jonathan Mulford; Ian Incoll; Michael Kale; Bernard Schick; Trent Li; Andrew Higgs; Andrew Oppy; Ian A Harris Journal: JAMA Surg Date: 2022-07-01 Impact factor: 16.681
Authors: Adilson Sanches de Oliveira; Bruno Braga Roberto; Mario Lenza; Guilherme Figueiredo Pintan; Benno Ejnisman; Breno Schor; Eduardo da Frota Carrera; Joel Murachovsky Journal: Einstein (Sao Paulo) Date: 2017 Jul-Sep
Authors: Ian A Harris; Justine M Naylor; Andrew Lawson; Rachelle Buchbinder; Rebecca Ivers; Zsolt Balogh; Paul Smith; Rajat Mittal; Wei Xuan; Kirsten Howard; Arezoo Vafa; Piers Yates; Bertram Rieger; Geoff Smith; Ilia Elkinson; Woosung Kim; Mellick Chehade; Jai Sungaran; Kim Latendresse; James Wong; Sameer Viswanathan; Martin Richardson; Kush Shrestha; Herwig Drobetz; Phong Tran; Jeremy Loveridge; Richard Page; Raphael Hau; Roger Bingham; Jonathan Mulford; Ian Incoll Journal: BMJ Open Date: 2017-06-23 Impact factor: 2.692