| Literature DB >> 21152188 |
Carolyn A McCarty1, Heather D Violette, Elizabeth McCauley.
Abstract
Despite the importance of adolescent depression, few school-based prevention programs have been developed and tested in the United States with middle school populations. This study examined the acceptability and changes in targeted outcomes for a new preventative program, Positive Thoughts and Actions (PTA). Sixty-seven 7th grade students with elevated depressive symptoms were recruited from public schools and randomized to the 12-week PTA program with a parent-component or to a school-as-usual control group. The PTA prevention program was well received by students and parents, yielding high rates of participation and satisfaction among those randomized to receive the intervention. However, analyses of the efficacy of the program in changing depressive symptoms were not significant. In terms of our proximal program targets, most differences were not statistically significant, though effect sizes suggested advantage of PTA over control group in coping, cognitive style, and parent-child communication. This preliminary research highlights a need for further testing of programs for school-based prevention of depression and promotion of positive emotional health.Entities:
Year: 2010 PMID: 21152188 PMCID: PMC2989707 DOI: 10.1155/2011/241386
Source DB: PubMed Journal: Depress Res Treat ISSN: 2090-1321
Demographic characteristics of participants.
| Characteristics | PTA group | Control group | ||
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Mean Age (SD) | 12.97 | (0.36) | 13 | (.40) |
| Sex, | ||||
| Female | 20 | (55.6) | 14 | (45.2) |
| Male | 16 | (44.4) | 17 | (54.8) |
| Race, | ||||
| White | 24 | (66.7) | 19 | (61.3) |
| African American | 1 | (2.8) | 3 | (9.7) |
| Asian | 2 | (5.6) | 3 | (9.7) |
| Native American | 2 | (5.6) | — | — |
| Other | 7 | (19.4) | 6 | (19.4) |
| Ethnicity, | ||||
| Hispanic | 1 | (2.8) | 6 | (19.4) |
| Non-Hispanic | 35 | (97.2) | 25 | (80.6) |
| Parental Education, | ||||
| HS Diploma/GED/Some College | 13 | (36) | 12 | (39) |
| Associates/Bachelor's Degree | 18 | (50) | 15 | (48) |
| Masters/Professional/Doctoral Degree | 5 | (14) | 4 | (13) |
| Family Constellation, | ||||
| Single (1 parent family) | 15 | (42) | 9 | (29) |
| Married (or 2 cohabitating parent) | 21 | (58) | 22 | (71) |
Effect sizes (Cohen's D) for outcomes across time.
| Construct | Coping | Cognition | Parent-child communication | Depressive symptoms | |||||
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| Measure | PCEC | SCEC | PC | CATS | PCCC | PCCP | MFQ-C | MFQ-P | CDRS |
| Postintervention | |||||||||
| .67 | .51 | .64 | .17 | .35 | .39 | −.16 | −.12 | −.02 | |
| 6-month followup | |||||||||
| .52 | −.05 | −.32 | .2 | −.04 | .15 | .09 | .03 | −.44 | |
| 18-month followup | |||||||||
| .5 | .16 | .2 | .24 | .04 | −.01 | .18 | −.47 | −.08 | |
Effect sizes were calculated using adjusted means from GLM (reported in Table 3).
(+) = Treatment > Control (better than); (−) = Treatment < Control (worse than).
Adjusted mean scores on proximal outcome measures by group and time.
| Construct | Coping | Cognition | Parent-Child Communication | |||
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| Measure | PCEC | SCEC | PC | CATS | PCCC | PCCP |
| PTA | ||||||
| Baseline | 25.88 (4.37) | 30.93 (4.97) | 20.78 (5.65) | 25.06 (18.75) | 19.93 (3.15) | 25.56 (3.28) |
| Postintervention | 26.15 (5.74) | 32.42 (7.54) | 21.79 (5.39) | 19.92 (14.84) | 19.29 (4.61) | 25.64 (2.86) |
| 6-month followup | 26.04 (5.14) | 21.61 (6.03) | 21.61 (6.03) | 19.61 (19.55) | 19.60 (2.77) | 25.24 (2.90) |
| 18-month followup | 26.10 (6.17) | 22.93 (5.22) | 22.93 (5.22) | 19.67 (19.84) | 19.31 (3.93) | 24.58 (3.73) |
| Controls | ||||||
| Baseline | 22.81 (5.17) | 30.06 (6.43) | 19.63 (6.13) | 26.15 (20.68) | 19.76 (4.07) | 24.93 (3.61) |
| Post-intervention | 22.48 (5.23) | 28.85 (6.33) | 18.27 (5.59) | 22.55 (15.92) | 17.83 (3.56) | 24.51 (2.88) |
| 6-month followup | 23.42 (5.03) | 23.31 (4.48) | 23.31 (4.48) | 23.77 (22.06) | 19.72 (3.35) | 24.80 (3.04) |
| 18-month followup | 23.61 (3.28) | 21.89 (5.08) | 21.89 (5.08) | 24.48 (19.06) | 19.15 (4.24) | 24.62 (3.75) |
Standard deviations are in parentheses. PCEC: Primary Control Engagement Coping; SCEC: Secondary Control Engagement Coping; PC: Personal Control; CATS: Children's Automatic Thoughts Questionnaire; PCCC: Parent Child Communication—Child; PCCP: Parent Child Communication—Parent.
Adjusted mean scores on depressive measures by group and time.
| Construct | Depressive Symptoms | ||
|---|---|---|---|
| Measure | MFQ-C | MFQ-P | CDRS |
| PTA | |||
| Baseline | 14.42 (9.85) | 10.51 (10.17) | 26.17 (7.50) |
| Post-intervention | 15.91 (10.24) | 9.11 (11.27) | 27.45 (7.43) |
| 6-month followup | 10.86 (10.59) | 7.37 (7.64) | 25.67 (7.77) |
| 18-month followup | 16.17 (10.83) | 9.28 (8.42) | 27.75 (9.04) |
| Controls | |||
| Baseline | 14.87 (10.41) | 10.67 (7.22) | 23.95 (6.17) |
| Post-intervention | 14.50 (7.41) | 8.05 (6.44) | 27.30 (6.78) |
| 6-month followup | 11.67 (6.83) | 7.57 (5.65) | 22.96 (4.01) |
| 18-month followup | 18.10 (10.96) | 6.01 (5.26) | 27.01 (9.61) |
Standard deviations are in parentheses. MFQ-C: Mood and Feelings Questionnaire-Child; MFQ-P: Mood and Feelings Questionnaire-Parent; CDRS: Children's Depression Rating Scale.
(a)
| Student content | ||
|---|---|---|
|
| ||
| Session no. | Title | Content |
| Week 1 | Introduction and Purpose | To convey the purpose of the program, build a positive peer group, and to practice being positive with others |
| Week 2 | Setting Goals | To motivate students to identify areas of their lives they would like to change and to select targeted goals and specific steps to take within each program area |
| Week 3 | Start with Action | To teach the importance of getting active to improve mood and persist in goals |
| Week 4 | Positive Thoughts, Positive Feelings | To understand the link between thoughts and actions and to increase positive thinking |
| Week 5 | Changing the Way We Think and Feel | To identify negative and irrational thoughts and change them to be more positive and realistic |
| Week 6 | STOP before Responding | To help students recognize when they are having an emotional reaction and to regulate their affect |
| Week 7 | Making Decisions & Problem-Solving | To teach a 5-step approach to making decisions and solving problems |
| Week 8 | Managing Conflict & Anger | To help students manage moods by controlling anger and resolving conflicts more productively |
| Week 9 | Learning | To apply the skills learned to identified school goals |
| Week 10 | Relationships | To practice applying Positive Thoughts and Actions to relationships |
| Week 11 | Making Healthy Decisions | To adopt more healthy behaviors |
| Week 12 | Staying on Track & Celebration | To recognize progress and identify areas of continued effort |
(b)
| Parent content | ||
|---|---|---|
|
| ||
| Session type/no. | Title | Content |
| Home Visit no. 1 | Getting to Know Each Other | To build rapport, to assess strengths and needs, and to help clarify the parents' supportive role |
| Parent Workshop no. 1 | Positive Thoughts & Actions for Parents | To teach parents perspective-taking, and to provide an overview to the parent of emotion regulation strategies |
| Parent Workshop no. 2 | Communicating with Your Teen | To give parents an opportunity to learn and practice different ways to communicate about feelings and/or problems |
| Home Visit no. 2 | Staying Successful | To provide an opportunity for the student to summarize key concepts and identify how the parent can support them |