Lisa Cole1, Sharon Mount, Erica Nuzzo, Cheung Wong. 1. Department of Pathology, Fletcher Allen Health Care, Vermont Cancer Center, University of Vermont, Burlington, VT 05401, USA.
Abstract
OBJECTIVE: To determine the diagnostic accuracy of cytologic evaluation of ovarian cystic masses. STUDY DESIGN: Sixty-seven ovarian cystic masses with fine needle aspiration cytology and concurrent or subsequent cystectomy/oophorectomy with histology were examined. Correlations with malignancy were made with 4 parameters: serum CA-125, radiographic size and architecture, and cytology. RESULTS: Histologic examination of the 67 cases revealed 10 malignancies including 3 primary ovarian carcinomas, 2 metastatic neoplasms, and 5 borderline tumors. In the 10 malignant cases, the cytologic diagnoses were that of benign (n=2), benign but non-diagnostic/paucicellular (n=3), and atypical/malignant (n=5), giving an overall sensitivity for cytology of 50%. However, there were no false positives (specificity of 100%). Reasons for the low sensitivity of cytology were the paucicellular nature of aspirate (n=3), focality of ovarian borderline tumors (n=5), and surface involvement by metastatic cancer (n=2). The 4 parameters were independent of one another and none proved to have significant correlation with malignancy (p>0.05). Thirty-nine percent of the aspirates had low cellularity (6% non-diagnostic/33% paucicellular). CONCLUSIONS: Cytology was the only parameter with 100% specificity and 100% positive predictive value. However, paucicellular specimens are a common problem in aspiration from this site.
OBJECTIVE: To determine the diagnostic accuracy of cytologic evaluation of ovarian cystic masses. STUDY DESIGN: Sixty-seven ovarian cystic masses with fine needle aspiration cytology and concurrent or subsequent cystectomy/oophorectomy with histology were examined. Correlations with malignancy were made with 4 parameters: serum CA-125, radiographic size and architecture, and cytology. RESULTS: Histologic examination of the 67 cases revealed 10 malignancies including 3 primary ovarian carcinomas, 2 metastatic neoplasms, and 5 borderline tumors. In the 10 malignant cases, the cytologic diagnoses were that of benign (n=2), benign but non-diagnostic/paucicellular (n=3), and atypical/malignant (n=5), giving an overall sensitivity for cytology of 50%. However, there were no false positives (specificity of 100%). Reasons for the low sensitivity of cytology were the paucicellular nature of aspirate (n=3), focality of ovarian borderline tumors (n=5), and surface involvement by metastatic cancer (n=2). The 4 parameters were independent of one another and none proved to have significant correlation with malignancy (p>0.05). Thirty-nine percent of the aspirates had low cellularity (6% non-diagnostic/33% paucicellular). CONCLUSIONS: Cytology was the only parameter with 100% specificity and 100% positive predictive value. However, paucicellular specimens are a common problem in aspiration from this site.