Kelly Allott1, Ping Liu, Tina-Marie Proffitt, Eoin Killackey. 1. Orygen Youth Health Research Centre, Centre for Youth Mental Health, Department of Psychology, The University of Melbourne, Victoria, Australia. kallott@unimelb.edu.au
Abstract
BACKGROUND: Cognitive deficits occur early in the course of psychosis, are mostly stable, and have been identified as potential functional prognostic markers. Previous reviews of chronic schizophrenia have concluded that specific cognitive deficits are strongly associated with poorer functional outcomes. However, results of schizophrenia studies may be influenced by the effects of long-term illness or treatment or be biased toward individuals with poorer outcomes and may not be relevant to early psychosis (EP). This review aimed to systematically examine the evidence regarding general and social cognitive predictors of later functional outcome in EP and critique the methodology of the studies reviewed. A final aim was to conduct a meta-analysis of the studies reviewed, but methodological reasons precluded this. METHOD: A comprehensive search of PsycINFO and MEDLINE databases identified 15 relevant articles and 7 further articles following a reference list search, totaling 22 included articles. RESULTS: Most studies found at least one cognitive domain predicted functional outcome, but examination of separate cognitive domains revealed there were more null than significant associations between cognition and functional outcome across every cognitive domain. No study examined social cognition as a predictor of outcome. The frequency with which different cognitive domains predicted outcome varied depending on study methodology and this was most noticeable when studies with short-term follow-up were compared with longer-term follow-up studies. CONCLUSIONS: Due to the methodological variability and limitations of the studies reviewed, firm conclusions regarding the relationship between cognition and functional outcomes in EP cannot be made. Tentatively, cognition may be prognostic in EP, especially for longer-term outcomes. However, further research that addresses the methodological issues identified, including examination of social cognition and other non-cognitive predictors, is needed.
BACKGROUND:Cognitive deficits occur early in the course of psychosis, are mostly stable, and have been identified as potential functional prognostic markers. Previous reviews of chronic schizophrenia have concluded that specific cognitive deficits are strongly associated with poorer functional outcomes. However, results of schizophrenia studies may be influenced by the effects of long-term illness or treatment or be biased toward individuals with poorer outcomes and may not be relevant to early psychosis (EP). This review aimed to systematically examine the evidence regarding general and social cognitive predictors of later functional outcome in EP and critique the methodology of the studies reviewed. A final aim was to conduct a meta-analysis of the studies reviewed, but methodological reasons precluded this. METHOD: A comprehensive search of PsycINFO and MEDLINE databases identified 15 relevant articles and 7 further articles following a reference list search, totaling 22 included articles. RESULTS: Most studies found at least one cognitive domain predicted functional outcome, but examination of separate cognitive domains revealed there were more null than significant associations between cognition and functional outcome across every cognitive domain. No study examined social cognition as a predictor of outcome. The frequency with which different cognitive domains predicted outcome varied depending on study methodology and this was most noticeable when studies with short-term follow-up were compared with longer-term follow-up studies. CONCLUSIONS: Due to the methodological variability and limitations of the studies reviewed, firm conclusions regarding the relationship between cognition and functional outcomes in EP cannot be made. Tentatively, cognition may be prognostic in EP, especially for longer-term outcomes. However, further research that addresses the methodological issues identified, including examination of social cognition and other non-cognitive predictors, is needed.
Authors: Joseph Ventura; Kenneth L Subotnik; Arielle Ered; Denise Gretchen-Doorly; Gerhard S Hellemann; Anja Vaskinn; Keith H Nuechterlein Journal: Schizophr Bull Date: 2014-02-21 Impact factor: 9.306
Authors: Mariapaola Barbato; Lu Liu; David L Penn; Richard S E Keefe; Diana O Perkins; Scott W Woods; Jean Addington Journal: Schizophr Res Date: 2013-09-05 Impact factor: 4.939
Authors: Eric C Meyer; Ricardo E Carrión; Barbara A Cornblatt; Jean Addington; Kristin S Cadenhead; Tyrone D Cannon; Thomas H McGlashan; Diana O Perkins; Ming T Tsuang; Elaine F Walker; Scott W Woods; Robert Heinssen; Larry J Seidman Journal: Schizophr Bull Date: 2014-02-18 Impact factor: 9.306
Authors: Gabriëlla A M Blokland; Raquelle I Mesholam-Gately; Timothea Toulopoulou; Elisabetta C Del Re; Max Lam; Lynn E DeLisi; Gary Donohoe; James T R Walters; Larry J Seidman; Tracey L Petryshen Journal: Schizophr Bull Date: 2017-07-01 Impact factor: 9.306
Authors: Keith H Nuechterlein; Kenneth L Subotnik; Michael F Green; Joseph Ventura; Robert F Asarnow; Michael J Gitlin; Cindy M Yee; Denise Gretchen-Doorly; Jim Mintz Journal: Schizophr Bull Date: 2011-09 Impact factor: 9.306
Authors: Ricardo E Carrión; Danielle McLaughlin; Terry E Goldberg; Andrea M Auther; Ruth H Olsen; Doreen M Olvet; Christoph U Correll; Barbara A Cornblatt Journal: JAMA Psychiatry Date: 2013-11 Impact factor: 21.596