BACKGROUND: Conservative treatment was long recommended for midclavicular fractures because of the excellent results that were reported in the 1960's and 70's. Recently, however, the rucksack bandage has received competition from surgical treatment. The spectrum of operations ranges from classic plate osteosynthesis to intramedullary techniques and angle-stable implants. METHODS: We present and evaluate the current treatment options on the basis of a selective review of the literature. RESULTS: Recent studies have confirmed some long-held concepts and refuted others. The risk of non-union after conservative treatment was previously reported as 1% to 2% but has turned out to be much higher in selected subgroups such as in patients with severe displacement, female patients, and patients of advanced age. Furthermore, new implants and techniques have made surgery safer and more likely to result in bony union. CONCLUSION: In any case of midclavicular fracture, the type of fracture should be precisely analyzed and an individual treatment strategy should be developed in view of the patient's particular situation. Current studies show with a high level of evidence (level 1) that patients with dislocated fractures benefit from surgery.
BACKGROUND: Conservative treatment was long recommended for midclavicular fractures because of the excellent results that were reported in the 1960's and 70's. Recently, however, the rucksack bandage has received competition from surgical treatment. The spectrum of operations ranges from classic plate osteosynthesis to intramedullary techniques and angle-stable implants. METHODS: We present and evaluate the current treatment options on the basis of a selective review of the literature. RESULTS: Recent studies have confirmed some long-held concepts and refuted others. The risk of non-union after conservative treatment was previously reported as 1% to 2% but has turned out to be much higher in selected subgroups such as in patients with severe displacement, female patients, and patients of advanced age. Furthermore, new implants and techniques have made surgery safer and more likely to result in bony union. CONCLUSION: In any case of midclavicular fracture, the type of fracture should be precisely analyzed and an individual treatment strategy should be developed in view of the patient's particular situation. Current studies show with a high level of evidence (level 1) that patients with dislocated fractures benefit from surgery.
Authors: C Michael Robinson; Charles M Court-Brown; Margaret M McQueen; Alison E Wakefield Journal: J Bone Joint Surg Am Date: 2004-07 Impact factor: 5.284
Authors: Mustafa Sinan Bakir; Andreas Langenbach; Melina Pinther; Rolf Lefering; Sebastian Krinner; Marco Grosso; Axel Ekkernkamp; Stefan Schulz-Drost Journal: Eur J Trauma Emerg Surg Date: 2021-11-05 Impact factor: 2.374