Melissa H Kong1, Jonathan P Piccini, Tristram D Bahnson. 1. Duke University Medical Center, Clinical Cardiac Electrophysiology Section of the Division of Cardiovascular Diseases, DUMC Box 31294, Durham, NC 27710, USA. kong0017@mc.duke.edu
Abstract
AIMS: Although useful, percutaneous left atrial ablation for pulmonary vein isolation (PVI) does not eliminate atrial fibrillation (AF) in all patients. The ablation of complex fractionated atrial electrograms (CFAEs) has been proposed as an adjunctive strategy to improve the maintenance of sinus rhythm after PVI. Our objective was to analyse the efficacy of adjunctive CFAE ablation. METHODS AND RESULTS: We meta-analysed six randomized controlled trials (total, n=538) using random-effects modelling to compare PVI (n=291) with PVI plus CFAE ablation (PVI+CFAE) (n=237). The primary outcome was freedom from AF or other atrial tachyarrhythmias (ATs) after a single ablation with or without antiarrhythmic drugs. Following a single ablation, PVI+CFAE improved the odds of freedom from any AF/AT compared with PVI alone (odds ratio 2.0, 95% confidence interval 1.04-3.8, P=0.04) at ≥3-month follow-up. There was moderate heterogeneity among trials (I2=63.0%). Complex fractionated atrial electrogram ablation significantly increased mean procedural (178.5±66.9 vs. 331.5±92.6 min, P<0.001), mean fluoroscopy (59.5±22.2 vs. 115.5±35.3 min, P<0.001), and mean radiofrequency (RF) energy application times (46.9±36.6 vs. 74.4±43.0 min, P<0.001). CONCLUSIONS: Pulmonary vein isolation followed by adjunctive CFAE ablation is associated with increased freedom from AF after a single procedure. Adjunctive CFAE ablation increased procedural, fluoroscopy, and RF application times, and the risk/benefit profile of adjunctive CFAE ablation deserves further evaluation with additional studies and longer-term follow-up.
AIMS: Although useful, percutaneous left atrial ablation for pulmonary vein isolation (PVI) does not eliminate atrial fibrillation (AF) in all patients. The ablation of complex fractionated atrial electrograms (CFAEs) has been proposed as an adjunctive strategy to improve the maintenance of sinus rhythm after PVI. Our objective was to analyse the efficacy of adjunctive CFAE ablation. METHODS AND RESULTS: We meta-analysed six randomized controlled trials (total, n=538) using random-effects modelling to compare PVI (n=291) with PVI plus CFAE ablation (PVI+CFAE) (n=237). The primary outcome was freedom from AF or other atrial tachyarrhythmias (ATs) after a single ablation with or without antiarrhythmic drugs. Following a single ablation, PVI+CFAE improved the odds of freedom from any AF/AT compared with PVI alone (odds ratio 2.0, 95% confidence interval 1.04-3.8, P=0.04) at ≥3-month follow-up. There was moderate heterogeneity among trials (I2=63.0%). Complex fractionated atrial electrogram ablation significantly increased mean procedural (178.5±66.9 vs. 331.5±92.6 min, P<0.001), mean fluoroscopy (59.5±22.2 vs. 115.5±35.3 min, P<0.001), and mean radiofrequency (RF) energy application times (46.9±36.6 vs. 74.4±43.0 min, P<0.001). CONCLUSIONS:Pulmonary vein isolation followed by adjunctive CFAE ablation is associated with increased freedom from AF after a single procedure. Adjunctive CFAE ablation increased procedural, fluoroscopy, and RF application times, and the risk/benefit profile of adjunctive CFAE ablation deserves further evaluation with additional studies and longer-term follow-up.
Authors: Valentin Fuster; Lars E Rydén; David S Cannom; Harry J Crijns; Anne B Curtis; Kenneth A Ellenbogen; Jonathan L Halperin; Jean-Yves Le Heuzey; G Neal Kay; James E Lowe; S Bertil Olsson; Eric N Prystowsky; Juan Luis Tamargo; Samuel Wann; Sidney C Smith; Alice K Jacobs; Cynthia D Adams; Jeffery L Anderson; Elliott M Antman; Jonathan L Halperin; Sharon Ann Hunt; Rick Nishimura; Joseph P Ornato; Richard L Page; Barbara Riegel; Silvia G Priori; Jean-Jacques Blanc; Andrzej Budaj; A John Camm; Veronica Dean; Jaap W Deckers; Catherine Despres; Kenneth Dickstein; John Lekakis; Keith McGregor; Marco Metra; Joao Morais; Ady Osterspey; Juan Luis Tamargo; José Luis Zamorano Journal: Circulation Date: 2006-08-15 Impact factor: 29.690
Authors: Hakan Oral; Carlo Pappone; Aman Chugh; Eric Good; Frank Bogun; Frank Pelosi; Eric R Bates; Michael H Lehmann; Gabriele Vicedomini; Giuseppe Augello; Eustachio Agricola; Simone Sala; Vincenzo Santinelli; Fred Morady Journal: N Engl J Med Date: 2006-03-02 Impact factor: 91.245
Authors: Michel Haïssaguerre; Prashanthan Sanders; Mélèze Hocini; Yoshihide Takahashi; Martin Rotter; Frederic Sacher; Thomas Rostock; Li-Fern Hsu; Pierre Bordachar; Sylvain Reuter; Raymond Roudaut; Jacques Clémenty; Pierre Jaïs Journal: J Cardiovasc Electrophysiol Date: 2005-11
Authors: Oussama M Wazni; Nassir F Marrouche; David O Martin; Atul Verma; Mandeep Bhargava; Walid Saliba; Dianna Bash; Robert Schweikert; Johannes Brachmann; Jens Gunther; Klaus Gutleben; Ennio Pisano; Dominico Potenza; Raffaele Fanelli; Antonio Raviele; Sakis Themistoclakis; Antonio Rossillo; Aldo Bonso; Andrea Natale Journal: JAMA Date: 2005-06-01 Impact factor: 56.272
Authors: Hakan Oral; Aman Chugh; Eric Good; Alan Wimmer; Sujoya Dey; Nitesh Gadeela; Sundar Sankaran; Thomas Crawford; Jean F Sarrazin; Michael Kuhne; Nagib Chalfoun; Darryl Wells; Melissa Frederick; Jackie Fortino; Suzanne Benloucif-Moore; Krit Jongnarangsin; Frank Pelosi; Frank Bogun; Fred Morady Journal: Circulation Date: 2007-05-14 Impact factor: 29.690
Authors: Hugh Calkins; Karl Heinz Kuck; Riccardo Cappato; Josep Brugada; A John Camm; Shih-Ann Chen; Harry J G Crijns; Ralph J Damiano; D Wyn Davies; John DiMarco; James Edgerton; Kenneth Ellenbogen; Michael D Ezekowitz; David E Haines; Michel Haissaguerre; Gerhard Hindricks; Yoshito Iesaka; Warren Jackman; Jose Jalife; Pierre Jais; Jonathan Kalman; David Keane; Young-Hoon Kim; Paulus Kirchhof; George Klein; Hans Kottkamp; Koichiro Kumagai; Bruce D Lindsay; Moussa Mansour; Francis E Marchlinski; Patrick M McCarthy; J Lluis Mont; Fred Morady; Koonlawee Nademanee; Hiroshi Nakagawa; Andrea Natale; Stanley Nattel; Douglas L Packer; Carlo Pappone; Eric Prystowsky; Antonio Raviele; Vivek Reddy; Jeremy N Ruskin; Richard J Shemin; Hsuan-Ming Tsao; David Wilber Journal: J Interv Card Electrophysiol Date: 2012-03 Impact factor: 1.900
Authors: Amir S Jadidi; Edward Duncan; Shinsuke Miyazaki; Nicolas Lellouche; Ashok J Shah; Andrei Forclaz; Isabelle Nault; Matthew Wright; Lena Rivard; Xingpeng Liu; Daniel Scherr; Stephen B Wilton; Frédéric Sacher; Nicolas Derval; Sebastien Knecht; Steven J Kim; Mélèze Hocini; Sanjiv Narayan; Michel Haïssaguerre; Pierre Jaïs Journal: Circ Arrhythm Electrophysiol Date: 2012-01-03
Authors: Thomas Deneke; Anja Schade; Joachim Krug; Karsten Stahl; Geza Atilla Szollosi; Dong In Shin; Clemens Nino Schukro; Mohamed El Tarahony; Enrique Murillo; Semko Aram; Gabriele Robhirt; Thomas Lawo; Andreas Mugge; Peter H Grewe; Sebastian Kerber Journal: J Atr Fibrillation Date: 2012-02-02
Authors: Jason Ng; David Gordon; Rod S Passman; Bradley P Knight; Rishi Arora; Jeffrey J Goldberger Journal: Heart Rhythm Date: 2014-08-05 Impact factor: 6.343
Authors: Claire A Martin; James P Curtain; Parag R Gajendragadkar; David A Begley; Simon P Fynn; Andrew A Grace; Patrick M Heck; Munmohan S Virdee; Sharad Agarwal Journal: J Atr Fibrillation Date: 2018-02-28