Georgia D Tomaras1, Barton F Haynes. 1. Duke Human Vaccine Institute, Duke University Medical Center, Durham, North Carolina, USA. gdt@duke.edu
Abstract
PURPOSE OF REVIEW: Major roadblocks persist in the development of vaccines that elicit potent neutralizing antibodies targeting diverse HIV-1 strains, similar to known broadly neutralizing HIV-1 human monoclonal antibodies. Alternatively, other types of anti-HIV-1 envelope antibodies that may not neutralize HIV-1 in traditional neutralization assays but have other anti-HIV-1 activities (hereafter termed HIV-1 inhibitory antibodies) can be elicited by current vaccine strategies, and numerous studies are exploring their roles in preventing HIV-1 acquisition. We review examples of strategies for eliciting potentially protective HIV-1 inhibitory antibodies. RECENT FINDINGS: Heterologous prime-boost strategies can yield anti-HIV immune responses, although only one (canarypox prime, Env protein boost) has been tested and shown positive results in an efficacy trial (RV144). Although the immune correlates of protection are as yet undefined, the reduced rate of acquisition without a significant effect on initial viral loads or CD4 T-cell counts, have raised the hypothesis of an RV144 vaccine-elicited transient protective B-cell response. SUMMARY: In light of the RV144 trial, there is a critical need to define the entire functional spectrum of anti-HIV-1 antibodies, how easily each can be elicited, and how effective different types of antibody effector mechanisms can be in prevention of HIV-1 transmission.
PURPOSE OF REVIEW: Major roadblocks persist in the development of vaccines that elicit potent neutralizing antibodies targeting diverse HIV-1 strains, similar to known broadly neutralizing HIV-1human monoclonal antibodies. Alternatively, other types of anti-HIV-1 envelope antibodies that may not neutralize HIV-1 in traditional neutralization assays but have other anti-HIV-1 activities (hereafter termed HIV-1 inhibitory antibodies) can be elicited by current vaccine strategies, and numerous studies are exploring their roles in preventing HIV-1 acquisition. We review examples of strategies for eliciting potentially protective HIV-1 inhibitory antibodies. RECENT FINDINGS: Heterologous prime-boost strategies can yield anti-HIV immune responses, although only one (canarypox prime, Env protein boost) has been tested and shown positive results in an efficacy trial (RV144). Although the immune correlates of protection are as yet undefined, the reduced rate of acquisition without a significant effect on initial viral loads or CD4 T-cell counts, have raised the hypothesis of an RV144 vaccine-elicited transient protective B-cell response. SUMMARY: In light of the RV144 trial, there is a critical need to define the entire functional spectrum of anti-HIV-1 antibodies, how easily each can be elicited, and how effective different types of antibody effector mechanisms can be in prevention of HIV-1 transmission.
Authors: Paul A Goepfert; Georgia D Tomaras; Helen Horton; David Montefiori; Guido Ferrari; Mark Deers; Gerald Voss; Marguerite Koutsoukos; Louise Pedneault; Pierre Vandepapeliere; M Juliana McElrath; Paul Spearman; Jonathan D Fuchs; Beryl A Koblin; William A Blattner; Sharon Frey; Lindsey R Baden; Clayton Harro; Thomas Evans Journal: Vaccine Date: 2006-08-10 Impact factor: 3.641
Authors: Punnee Pitisuttithum; Peter Gilbert; Marc Gurwith; William Heyward; Michael Martin; Fritz van Griensven; Dale Hu; Jordan W Tappero; Kachit Choopanya Journal: J Infect Dis Date: 2006-11-03 Impact factor: 5.226
Authors: Lei Chen; Young Do Kwon; Tongqing Zhou; Xueling Wu; Sijy O'Dell; Lisa Cavacini; Ann J Hessell; Marie Pancera; Min Tang; Ling Xu; Zhi-Yong Yang; Mei-Yun Zhang; James Arthos; Dennis R Burton; Dimiter S Dimitrov; Gary J Nabel; Marshall R Posner; Joseph Sodroski; Richard Wyatt; John R Mascola; Peter D Kwong Journal: Science Date: 2009-11-20 Impact factor: 47.728
Authors: Sampa Santra; Hua-Xin Liao; Ruijin Zhang; Mark Muldoon; Sydeaka Watson; Will Fischer; James Theiler; James Szinger; Harikrishnan Balachandran; Adam Buzby; David Quinn; Robert J Parks; Chun-Yen Tsao; Angela Carville; Keith G Mansfield; George N Pavlakis; Barbara K Felber; Barton F Haynes; Bette T Korber; Norman L Letvin Journal: Nat Med Date: 2010-02-21 Impact factor: 53.440
Authors: Richard A Koup; Mario Roederer; Laurie Lamoreaux; Jennifer Fischer; Laura Novik; Martha C Nason; Brenda D Larkin; Mary E Enama; Julie E Ledgerwood; Robert T Bailer; John R Mascola; Gary J Nabel; Barney S Graham Journal: PLoS One Date: 2010-02-02 Impact factor: 3.240
Authors: Johannes F Scheid; Hugo Mouquet; Niklas Feldhahn; Michael S Seaman; Klara Velinzon; John Pietzsch; Rene G Ott; Robert M Anthony; Henry Zebroski; Arlene Hurley; Adhuna Phogat; Bimal Chakrabarti; Yuxing Li; Mark Connors; Florencia Pereyra; Bruce D Walker; Hedda Wardemann; David Ho; Richard T Wyatt; John R Mascola; Jeffrey V Ravetch; Michel C Nussenzweig Journal: Nature Date: 2009-03-15 Impact factor: 49.962
Authors: Miroslaw K Gorny; Ruimin Pan; Constance Williams; Xiao-Hong Wang; Barbara Volsky; Timothy O'Neal; Brett Spurrier; Jared M Sampson; Liuzhe Li; Michael S Seaman; Xiang-Peng Kong; Susan Zolla-Pazner Journal: Virology Date: 2012-03-07 Impact factor: 3.616
Authors: Dennis R Burton; Ann J Hessell; Brandon F Keele; Per Johan Klasse; Thomas A Ketas; Brian Moldt; D Cameron Dunlop; Pascal Poignard; Lara A Doyle; Lisa Cavacini; Ronald S Veazey; John P Moore Journal: Proc Natl Acad Sci U S A Date: 2011-06-20 Impact factor: 11.205
Authors: D Noah Sather; Sara Carbonetti; Delphine C Malherbe; Franco Pissani; Andrew B Stuart; Ann J Hessell; Mathew D Gray; Iliyana Mikell; Spyros A Kalams; Nancy L Haigwood; Leonidas Stamatatos Journal: J Virol Date: 2014-08-13 Impact factor: 5.103
Authors: Pinghuang Liu; Latonya D Williams; Xiaoying Shen; Mattia Bonsignori; Nathan A Vandergrift; R Glenn Overman; M Anthony Moody; Hua-Xin Liao; Daniel J Stieh; Kerrie L McCotter; Audrey L French; Thomas J Hope; Robin Shattock; Barton F Haynes; Georgia D Tomaras Journal: J Virol Date: 2014-02-19 Impact factor: 5.103
Authors: Pinghuang Liu; R Glenn Overman; Nicole L Yates; S Munir Alam; Nathan Vandergrift; Yue Chen; Frederik Graw; Stephanie A Freel; John C Kappes; Christina Ochsenbauer; David C Montefiori; Feng Gao; Alan S Perelson; Myron S Cohen; Barton F Haynes; Georgia D Tomaras Journal: J Virol Date: 2011-08-24 Impact factor: 5.103