BACKGROUND: This review assessed whether conference abstracts yield useful information on the types and effectiveness of community-based physical activity (PA) interventions in Latin America, beyond that from interventions included in a recent systematic review of peer-reviewed literature. METHODS: Abstracts from 9 conferences were searched for community-based interventions to promote PA in Latin America and summarized. Three reviewers classified and screened abstracts. Evaluated interventions that were not included in the previous review were assessed. RESULTS: Search of abstracts from 31 proceedings of 9 conferences identified 87 abstracts of studies on community-based interventions focused on increasing PA. Only 31 abstracts reported on studies with a control group and an outcome related to PA. Ten of these abstracts represented interventions that had not been included in the previous review of peer-reviewed literature, but the abstracts were insufficient in number or detail to make a practice recommendation for any single intervention. CONCLUSIONS: This review highlighted the challenges and low added value of including conference abstracts in a systematic review of community PA interventions in Latin America. Stronger evaluation design and execution and more published reports of evaluated interventions are needed to build an evidence base supporting interventions to increase PA in Latin America.
BACKGROUND: This review assessed whether conference abstracts yield useful information on the types and effectiveness of community-based physical activity (PA) interventions in Latin America, beyond that from interventions included in a recent systematic review of peer-reviewed literature. METHODS: Abstracts from 9 conferences were searched for community-based interventions to promote PA in Latin America and summarized. Three reviewers classified and screened abstracts. Evaluated interventions that were not included in the previous review were assessed. RESULTS: Search of abstracts from 31 proceedings of 9 conferences identified 87 abstracts of studies on community-based interventions focused on increasing PA. Only 31 abstracts reported on studies with a control group and an outcome related to PA. Ten of these abstracts represented interventions that had not been included in the previous review of peer-reviewed literature, but the abstracts were insufficient in number or detail to make a practice recommendation for any single intervention. CONCLUSIONS: This review highlighted the challenges and low added value of including conference abstracts in a systematic review of community PA interventions in Latin America. Stronger evaluation design and execution and more published reports of evaluated interventions are needed to build an evidence base supporting interventions to increase PA in Latin America.
Authors: Diana C Paez; Rodrigo S Reis; Diana C Parra; Christine M Hoehner; Olga L Sarmiento; Mauro Barros; Ross C Brownson Journal: Transl Behav Med Date: 2015-03 Impact factor: 3.046
Authors: Christine M Hoehner; Isabela C Ribeiro; Diana C Parra; Rodrigo S Reis; Mario R Azevedo; Adriano A Hino; Jesus Soares; Pedro C Hallal; Eduardo J Simões; Ross C Brownson Journal: Am J Prev Med Date: 2013-03 Impact factor: 5.043
Authors: Roberta W Scherer; Lynn Huynh; Ann-Margret Ervin; Jakeisha Taylor; Kay Dickersin Journal: BMC Med Res Methodol Date: 2013-06-18 Impact factor: 4.615
Authors: Diana C Parra; Christine M Hoehner; Pedro C Hallal; Rodrigo S Reis; Eduardo J Simoes; Deborah C Malta; Michael Pratt; Ross C Brownson Journal: Glob Health Promot Date: 2013-12-09