OBJECTIVE: To compare levator ani muscle injury rates in primiparous women who had a forceps delivery owing to fetal distress with women delivered by forceps for second stage arrest; and to compare these injury rates with a historical control group of women who delivered spontaneously. METHODS: Primiparous women who delivered by forceps were recruited retrospectively into 2 groups: forceps for fetal distress with short second stage (25±11 minutes; n=19); and forceps delivery for second stage arrest (137±26 minutes; n=19). MR images of the levator ani muscles were compared with a historical control group of women from a previous study who had delivered spontaneously (n=129). RESULTS: Major defect rates were: 42% for forceps and short second stage; 63% for forceps and second stage arrest; and 6% for spontaneous delivery. The odds ratios for major injury were: 11.0 for forceps and short second stage compared with spontaneous delivery; 25.9 for forceps and second stage arrest compared with spontaneous delivery; and 2.3 for forceps and second stage arrest compared with short second stage (P=0.07). CONCLUSION: Women delivered by forceps have a higher rate of levator ani injury compared with spontaneous delivery controls; the difference between the forceps groups did not reach significance.
OBJECTIVE: To compare levator ani muscle injury rates in primiparous women who had a forceps delivery owing to fetal distress with women delivered by forceps for second stage arrest; and to compare these injury rates with a historical control group of women who delivered spontaneously. METHODS: Primiparous women who delivered by forceps were recruited retrospectively into 2 groups: forceps for fetal distress with short second stage (25±11 minutes; n=19); and forceps delivery for second stage arrest (137±26 minutes; n=19). MR images of the levator ani muscles were compared with a historical control group of women from a previous study who had delivered spontaneously (n=129). RESULTS: Major defect rates were: 42% for forceps and short second stage; 63% for forceps and second stage arrest; and 6% for spontaneous delivery. The odds ratios for major injury were: 11.0 for forceps and short second stage compared with spontaneous delivery; 25.9 for forceps and second stage arrest compared with spontaneous delivery; and 2.3 for forceps and second stage arrest compared with short second stage (P=0.07). CONCLUSION:Women delivered by forceps have a higher rate of levator ani injury compared with spontaneous delivery controls; the difference between the forceps groups did not reach significance.
Authors: Daniel M Morgan; Wolfgang Umek; Tamara Stein; Yvonne Hsu; Kenneth Guire; John O L DeLancey Journal: Int Urogynecol J Pelvic Floor Dysfunct Date: 2006-10-17
Authors: Brian M Casey; Joseph I Schaffer; Steven L Bloom; Stephen F Heartwell; Donald D McIntire; Kenneth J Leveno Journal: Am J Obstet Gynecol Date: 2005-05 Impact factor: 8.661
Authors: Lori J Tuttle; Olivia T Nguyen; Mark S Cook; Marianna Alperin; Sameer B Shah; Samuel R Ward; Richard L Lieber Journal: Int Urogynecol J Date: 2013-08-01 Impact factor: 2.894
Authors: Marianna Alperin; Lori J Tuttle; Blair R Conner; Danielle M Dixon; Margie A Mathewson; Samuel R Ward; Richard L Lieber Journal: Int Urogynecol J Date: 2014-06-11 Impact factor: 2.894
Authors: Karin Lammers; Jurgen J Fütterer; Mathias Prokop; Mark E Vierhout; Kirsten B Kluivers Journal: Int Urogynecol J Date: 2012-05-12 Impact factor: 2.894