BACKGROUND: New criteria for the neurophysiological diagnosis of amyotrophic lateral sclerosis/motor neuron disease (ALS/MND) were recently proposed at an international symposium in Awaji-shima, Japan. They differ from the accepted revised El-Escorial criteria by considering fasciculation potentials to be evidence of acute denervation. In addition, when assessing diagnostic certainty, the Awaji-shima criteria equate electrodiagnostic evidence of lower motor neuron dysfunction with clinical examination findings. METHODS: A retrospective review of 205 consecutive sets of notes was performed, from patients who underwent neurophysiological assessment for suspected MND. The clinical signs and neurophysiological findings were combined according to the two sets of criteria (revised El-Escorial and Awaji-shima), and the diagnoses reached were compared with the interval diagnosis, to establish the sensitivities and specificities of each protocol. RESULTS: An interval diagnosis of MND was recorded in 107 patients. The sensitivity of the Awaji-shima criteria in reaching a diagnosis of MND was 60.7% and the revised El-Escorial 28%, with a specificity of 95.9% for both criteria. The Awaji-shima criteria increased the sensitivity of diagnosis without affecting the specificity. CONCLUSION: Accepting EMG evidence of fasciculations as evidence of acute denervation increases the diagnostic certainty of MND, and the new criteria allow earlier diagnosis of MND without increasing the false-positive rate.
BACKGROUND: New criteria for the neurophysiological diagnosis of amyotrophic lateral sclerosis/motor neuron disease (ALS/MND) were recently proposed at an international symposium in Awaji-shima, Japan. They differ from the accepted revised El-Escorial criteria by considering fasciculation potentials to be evidence of acute denervation. In addition, when assessing diagnostic certainty, the Awaji-shima criteria equate electrodiagnostic evidence of lower motor neuron dysfunction with clinical examination findings. METHODS: A retrospective review of 205 consecutive sets of notes was performed, from patients who underwent neurophysiological assessment for suspected MND. The clinical signs and neurophysiological findings were combined according to the two sets of criteria (revised El-Escorial and Awaji-shima), and the diagnoses reached were compared with the interval diagnosis, to establish the sensitivities and specificities of each protocol. RESULTS: An interval diagnosis of MND was recorded in 107 patients. The sensitivity of the Awaji-shima criteria in reaching a diagnosis of MND was 60.7% and the revised El-Escorial 28%, with a specificity of 95.9% for both criteria. The Awaji-shima criteria increased the sensitivity of diagnosis without affecting the specificity. CONCLUSION: Accepting EMG evidence of fasciculations as evidence of acute denervation increases the diagnostic certainty of MND, and the new criteria allow earlier diagnosis of MND without increasing the false-positive rate.
Authors: Santosh A Helekar; Jason Thonhoff; Blessy S John; Lisa Nguyen; David B Rosenfield; Stanley H Appel Journal: J Neurol Date: 2022-06-15 Impact factor: 6.682
Authors: Bradley R Foerster; Ben A Dwamena; Myria Petrou; Ruth C Carlos; Brian C Callaghan; Martin G Pomper Journal: Acad Radiol Date: 2012-06-28 Impact factor: 3.173
Authors: Ana C Calvo; Raquel Manzano; Gabriela Atencia-Cibreiro; Sara Oliván; María J Muñoz; Pilar Zaragoza; Pilar Cordero-Vázquez; Jesús Esteban-Pérez; Alberto García-Redondo; Rosario Osta Journal: PLoS One Date: 2012-03-07 Impact factor: 3.240
Authors: Martin R Turner; Robert Bowser; Lucie Bruijn; Luc Dupuis; Albert Ludolph; Michael McGrath; Giovanni Manfredi; Nicholas Maragakis; Robert G Miller; Seth L Pullman; Seward B Rutkove; Pamela J Shaw; Jeremy Shefner; Kenneth H Fischbeck Journal: Amyotroph Lateral Scler Frontotemporal Degener Date: 2013-05 Impact factor: 4.092