Kathleen A Smyth1. 1. Department of Epidemiology and Biostatistics, School of Medicine, Case Western Reserve University, Cleveland, OH 44106-4945, USA. kathleen.smyth@case.edu
Abstract
OBJECTIVES: To explore the nature of breast cancer screening and treatment decisions in older women with dementia. DESIGN: Thematic analysis of semistructured telephone interviews. SETTING: Alzheimer's Disease Research Center Registry. PARTICIPANTS: Twenty-three family caregivers (CGs) of women with dementia (WWD). MEASUREMENTS: Semistructured questions regarding CGs' perceptions of current and predementia beliefs held by the WWD about the importance of regular screening mammograms, CGs' views about the importance of obtaining regular screening mammograms for the WWD and whether dementia stage of the WWD influenced these views, and CGs' view of what level of treatment would be appropriate if WWD they were caring for were to be diagnosed with breast cancer. RESULTS: In CGs of women with mild to moderate (but not severe) dementia, mammogram importance ratings reflected perceived predementia importance levels (generally high). Most CGs of women with mild to moderate dementia planned to continue screening regardless of dementia severity of the WWD, but CGs of women with severe dementia at the time of the interview did not generally consider screening important. Physician recommendations were frequently found to influence screening practices. CGs' views on appropriate treatment if the WWD developed breast cancer varied widely except in the case of severe dementia, in which case comfort care was consistently preferred. CONCLUSION: Breast cancer screening and treatment in dementia are active areas for healthcare decision-making, and supportive interventions involving physicians, CGs, and WWD are needed.
OBJECTIVES: To explore the nature of breast cancer screening and treatment decisions in older women with dementia. DESIGN: Thematic analysis of semistructured telephone interviews. SETTING:Alzheimer's Disease Research Center Registry. PARTICIPANTS: Twenty-three family caregivers (CGs) of women with dementia (WWD). MEASUREMENTS: Semistructured questions regarding CGs' perceptions of current and predementia beliefs held by the WWD about the importance of regular screening mammograms, CGs' views about the importance of obtaining regular screening mammograms for the WWD and whether dementia stage of the WWD influenced these views, and CGs' view of what level of treatment would be appropriate if WWD they were caring for were to be diagnosed with breast cancer. RESULTS: In CGs of women with mild to moderate (but not severe) dementia, mammogram importance ratings reflected perceived predementia importance levels (generally high). Most CGs of women with mild to moderate dementia planned to continue screening regardless of dementia severity of the WWD, but CGs of women with severe dementia at the time of the interview did not generally consider screening important. Physician recommendations were frequently found to influence screening practices. CGs' views on appropriate treatment if the WWD developed breast cancer varied widely except in the case of severe dementia, in which case comfort care was consistently preferred. CONCLUSION:Breast cancer screening and treatment in dementia are active areas for healthcare decision-making, and supportive interventions involving physicians, CGs, and WWD are needed.
Authors: Mara A Schonberg; Edward R Marcantonio; Long Ngo; Rebecca A Silliman; Ellen P McCarthy Journal: J Geriatr Oncol Date: 2012-01-01 Impact factor: 3.599
Authors: Elizabeth Eckstrom; David H Feeny; Louise C Walter; Leslie A Perdue; Evelyn P Whitlock Journal: J Gen Intern Med Date: 2012-09-28 Impact factor: 5.128
Authors: Marcus Law; Sandeep Dhillon; Nathan Herrmann; Farah Friesen; Ayan K Dey; Abby Li; A Patricia Ayala; Erica Lenton; Jodi D Edwards; Walter Swardfager Journal: Gerontol Geriatr Med Date: 2018-09-18