Longitudinal assessment of intellectual achievement in patients with classical galactosemia.

OBJECTIVE: To conduct a longitudinal assessment of long-term cognitive outcome in patients with classical galactosemia.
METHODS: Inclusion criteria were (1) previous assessment of IQ dating back >10 years with tests being comparable with the recent German tests HAWIK-III and HAWIE-R, (2) absence of illnesses other than galactosemia, (3) absence of foreign language problems, (4) enzymatic-metabolic proof of classical galactosemia, (5) compliance with dietary therapy, and (6) written informed consent. Twenty-three patients who fulfilled these criteria were found. They underwent the first IQ test at a mean age of 11 +/- 5 years and the second 13.6 to 15.5 years later at a mean age of 26 +/- 5 years. Results were corrected for the obsolescence of test norms (Flynn effect).
RESULTS: Mean total IQ scores on the first and second tests were 78 +/- 14 and 73 +/- 15, respectively, and not significantly different. IQ scores in the average range were observed for 7 patients on the first test and for 5 patients on the second test. For 17 patients, the intraindividual IQ scores remained essentially unchanged. Five patients showed a decrease and 1 an increase of the IQ score over time. No consistent pattern of change was found with respect to performance or verbal IQ subscores or in achievements in the individual subtest.
CONCLUSIONS: The results confirm the presence of reduced cognitive ability in classical galactosemia and present evidence for an absence of substantial galactosemia-induced aggravation of this impairment with increasing age, at least in patients from 4 to 40 years of age. It remains to be clarified whether a reduction of cognitive function in galactosemia may be initiated by an in utero toxicity of endogenously formed galactose and which role such a process may play in the development of intellectual deficiencies that are later maintained throughout life.