James J Chen1, Paula K Roberson, Michael J Schell. 1. Division of Personalized Nutrition and Medicine, National Center for Toxicological Research, Food and Drug Administration, HFT-20, Jefferson, AR 72079, USA. JamesJ.Chen@fda.hhs.gov
Abstract
BACKGROUND: In experimental research, a statistical test is often used for making decisions on a null hypothesis such as that the means of gene expression in the normal and tumor groups are equal. Typically, a test statistic and its corresponding P value are calculated to measure the extent of the difference between the two groups. The null hypothesis is rejected and a discovery is declared when the P value is less than a prespecified significance level. When more than one test is conducted, use of a significance level intended for use by a single test typically leads to a large chance of false-positive findings. METHODS: This paper presents an overview of the multiple testing framework and describes the false discovery rate (FDR) approach to determining the significance cutoff when a large number of tests are conducted. RESULTS: The FDR is the expected proportion of the null hypotheses that are falsely rejected divided by the total number of rejections. An FDR-controlling procedure is described and illustrated with a numerical example. CONCLUSIONS: In multiple testing, a classical "family-wise error rate" (FWE) approach is commonly used when the number of tests is small. When a study involves a large number of tests, the FDR error measure is a more useful approach to determining a significance cutoff, as the FWE approach is too stringent. The FDR approach allows more claims of significant differences to be made, provided the investigator is willing to accept a small fraction of false-positive findings.
BACKGROUND: In experimental research, a statistical test is often used for making decisions on a null hypothesis such as that the means of gene expression in the normal and tumor groups are equal. Typically, a test statistic and its corresponding P value are calculated to measure the extent of the difference between the two groups. The null hypothesis is rejected and a discovery is declared when the P value is less than a prespecified significance level. When more than one test is conducted, use of a significance level intended for use by a single test typically leads to a large chance of false-positive findings. METHODS: This paper presents an overview of the multiple testing framework and describes the false discovery rate (FDR) approach to determining the significance cutoff when a large number of tests are conducted. RESULTS: The FDR is the expected proportion of the null hypotheses that are falsely rejected divided by the total number of rejections. An FDR-controlling procedure is described and illustrated with a numerical example. CONCLUSIONS: In multiple testing, a classical "family-wise error rate" (FWE) approach is commonly used when the number of tests is small. When a study involves a large number of tests, the FDR error measure is a more useful approach to determining a significance cutoff, as the FWE approach is too stringent. The FDR approach allows more claims of significant differences to be made, provided the investigator is willing to accept a small fraction of false-positive findings.
Authors: P M Bet; E C Verbeek; Y Milaneschi; D B M Straver; T Uithuisje; M R Bevova; J G Hugtenburg; P Heutink; B W J H Penninx; W J G Hoogendijk Journal: Pharmacogenomics J Date: 2015-05-19 Impact factor: 3.550
Authors: Margaret G Ehm; Jennifer L Aponte; Mathias N Chiano; Laura M Yerges-Armstrong; Toby Johnson; Jonathan N Barker; Suzanne F Cook; Akanksha Gupta; David A Hinds; Li Li; Matthew R Nelson; Michael A Simpson; Chao Tian; Linda C McCarthy; Deepak K Rajpal; Dawn M Waterworth Journal: PLoS One Date: 2017-11-01 Impact factor: 3.240
Authors: Pauline Bus; Christine Kestens; Fiebo Jan Willem Ten Kate; Wilbert Peters; Joost Paulus Hubertus Drenth; Jeanine Merel Leonoor Roodhart; Peter Derk Siersema; Jantine Wilhelmina Paula Maria van Baal Journal: J Gastroenterol Date: 2015-11-19 Impact factor: 7.527