RPE65, visual cycle retinol isomerase, is not inherently 11-cis-specific: support for a carbocation mechanism of retinol isomerization.

The mechanism of retinol isomerization in the vertebrate retina visual cycle remains controversial. Does the isomerase enzyme RPE65 operate via nucleophilic addition at C(11) of the all-trans substrate, or via a carbocation mechanism? To determine this, we modeled the RPE65 substrate cleft to identify residues interacting with substrate and/or intermediate. We find that wild-type RPE65 in vitro produces 13-cis and 11-cis isomers equally robustly. All Tyr-239 mutations abolish activity. Trp-331 mutations reduce activity (W331Y to approximately 75% of wild type, W331F to approximately 50%, and W331L and W331Q to 0%) establishing a requirement for aromaticity, consistent with cation-pi carbocation stabilization. Two cleft residues modulate isomerization specificity: Thr-147 is important, because replacement by Ser increases 11-cis relative to 13-cis by 40% compared with wild type. Phe-103 mutations are opposite in action: F103L and F103I dramatically reduce 11-cis synthesis relative to 13-cis synthesis compared with wild type. Thr-147 and Phe-103 thus may be pivotal in controlling RPE65 specificity. Also, mutations affecting RPE65 activity coordinately depress 11-cis and 13-cis isomer production but diverge as 11-cis decreases to zero, whereas 13-cis reaches a plateau consistent with thermal isomerization. Lastly, experiments using labeled retinol showed exchange at 13-cis-retinol C(15) oxygen, thus confirming enzymatic isomerization for both isomers. Thus, RPE65 is not inherently 11-cis-specific and can produce both 11- and 13-cis isomers, supporting a carbocation (or radical cation) mechanism for isomerization. Specific visual cycle selectivity for 11-cis isomers instead resides downstream, attributable to mass action by CRALBP, retinol dehydrogenase 5, and high affinity of opsin apoproteins for 11-cis-retinal.