BACKGROUND:Chronic obstructive pulmonary disease (COPD) is a leading cause of disability, hospital admission and premature mortality, but is often undiagnosed. This study assessed the effectiveness, feasibility and acceptability of COPD case finding by practice nurses performing spirometry on patients identified as being at risk of developing COPD. METHODS: Practice nurses were trained in spirometry. From four general practices, 1010 patients were identified who were aged 40-80 years and current or ex-smokers. Four hundred were randomised to receive a written invitation to attend a case finding appointment with the practice nurse, including spirometry. RESULTS:Seventy-nine patients attended, 16 (20.3% of attendees) had COPD diagnosed on spirometry; practice nurses correctly identified 10 of the 16, but also incorrectly identified a further six patients as having COPD. One patient in the usual care group was diagnosed with COPD, but this was not confirmed on spirometry. DISCUSSION: This study confirmed that COPD is underdiagnosed, with 20% of those at risk and attending for screening having COPD. The search strategy successfully identified patients at risk. Further training in spirometry would be required for practice nurses to increase the accuracy of the diagnoses. The opportunity cost would require consideration. The acceptability to patients is also an issue, this may be related to the recruitment method or the intervention. This study also does not answer whether earlier diagnosis in these patients leads to any change in outcomes.
RCT Entities:
BACKGROUND:Chronic obstructive pulmonary disease (COPD) is a leading cause of disability, hospital admission and premature mortality, but is often undiagnosed. This study assessed the effectiveness, feasibility and acceptability of COPD case finding by practice nurses performing spirometry on patients identified as being at risk of developing COPD. METHODS: Practice nurses were trained in spirometry. From four general practices, 1010 patients were identified who were aged 40-80 years and current or ex-smokers. Four hundred were randomised to receive a written invitation to attend a case finding appointment with the practice nurse, including spirometry. RESULTS: Seventy-nine patients attended, 16 (20.3% of attendees) had COPD diagnosed on spirometry; practice nurses correctly identified 10 of the 16, but also incorrectly identified a further six patients as having COPD. One patient in the usual care group was diagnosed with COPD, but this was not confirmed on spirometry. DISCUSSION: This study confirmed that COPD is underdiagnosed, with 20% of those at risk and attending for screening having COPD. The search strategy successfully identified patients at risk. Further training in spirometry would be required for practice nurses to increase the accuracy of the diagnoses. The opportunity cost would require consideration. The acceptability to patients is also an issue, this may be related to the recruitment method or the intervention. This study also does not answer whether earlier diagnosis in these patients leads to any change in outcomes.
Authors: Lisa Pagano; Zoe McKeough; Sally Wootton; Stephen Crone; Deborah Pallavicini; Andrew S L Chan; Sriram Mahadev; Nicholas Zwar; Sarah Dennis Journal: Pilot Feasibility Stud Date: 2020-09-23
Authors: Jeremy M Bunker; Helen K Reddel; Sarah M Dennis; Sandy Middleton; Cp Van Schayck; Alan J Crockett; Iqbal Hasan; Oshana Hermiz; Sanjyot Vagholkar; Guy B Marks; Nicholas A Zwar Journal: Implement Sci Date: 2012-09-07 Impact factor: 7.327
Authors: Shamil Mm Haroon; Rachel E Jordan; Joanne O'Beirne-Elliman; Peymane Adab Journal: NPJ Prim Care Respir Med Date: 2015-08-27 Impact factor: 2.871
Authors: Francis Nissen; Daniel R Morales; Hana Mullerova; Liam Smeeth; Ian J Douglas; Jennifer K Quint Journal: Br J Gen Pract Date: 2018-09-24 Impact factor: 5.386