Thomas A LaVeist1, Lydia A Isaac, Karen Patricia Williams. 1. Hopkins Center for Health Disparities Solutions, Johns Hopkins Bloomberg School of Public Health, 624 N. Broadway, Baltimore, MD 21205, USA. tlaveist@jhsph.edu
Abstract
PURPOSE: We report the validation of an instrument to measure mistrust of health care organizations and examine the relationship between mistrust and health care service underutilization. METHODS: We conducted a telephone survey of a random sample of households in Baltimore City, MD. We surveyed 401 persons and followed up with 327 persons (81.5 percent) 3 weeks after the baseline interview. We conducted tests of the validity and reliability of the Medical Mistrust Index (MMI) and then conducted multivariate modeling to examine the relationship between mistrust and five measures of underutilization of health services. RESULTS: Using principle components analysis, we reduced the 17-item MMI to 7 items with a single dimension. Test-retest reliability was moderately strong, ranging from Pearson correlation of 0.346-0.697. In multivariate modeling, the MMI was predictive of four of five measures of underutilization of health services: failure to take medical advice (b=1.56, p<.01), failure to keep a follow-up appointment (b=1.11, p=.01), postponing receiving needed care (b=0.939, p=.01), and failure to fill a prescription (b=1.48, p=.002). MMI was not significantly associated with failure to get needed medical care (b=0.815, p=.06). CONCLUSIONS: The MMI is a robust predictor of underutilization of health services. Greater attention should be devoted to building greater trust among patients.
PURPOSE: We report the validation of an instrument to measure mistrust of health care organizations and examine the relationship between mistrust and health care service underutilization. METHODS: We conducted a telephone survey of a random sample of households in Baltimore City, MD. We surveyed 401 persons and followed up with 327 persons (81.5 percent) 3 weeks after the baseline interview. We conducted tests of the validity and reliability of the Medical Mistrust Index (MMI) and then conducted multivariate modeling to examine the relationship between mistrust and five measures of underutilization of health services. RESULTS: Using principle components analysis, we reduced the 17-item MMI to 7 items with a single dimension. Test-retest reliability was moderately strong, ranging from Pearson correlation of 0.346-0.697. In multivariate modeling, the MMI was predictive of four of five measures of underutilization of health services: failure to take medical advice (b=1.56, p<.01), failure to keep a follow-up appointment (b=1.11, p=.01), postponing receiving needed care (b=0.939, p=.01), and failure to fill a prescription (b=1.48, p=.002). MMI was not significantly associated with failure to get needed medical care (b=0.815, p=.06). CONCLUSIONS: The MMI is a robust predictor of underutilization of health services. Greater attention should be devoted to building greater trust among patients.
Authors: Joel B Braunstein; Noëlle S Sherber; Steven P Schulman; Eric L Ding; Neil R Powe Journal: Medicine (Baltimore) Date: 2008-01 Impact factor: 1.889
Authors: Claire Selsky; Barbara Kreling; Gheorghe Luta; Solomon B Makgoeng; Jessika Gomez-Duarte; Andrea Gabriela A Barbo; Jeanne S Mandelblatt Journal: J Palliat Med Date: 2012-06-25 Impact factor: 2.947
Authors: Skai W Schwartz; Yuri Sebastião; Julie Rosas; Michelle R Iannacone; Philip R Foulis; W McDowell Anderson Journal: Sleep Breath Date: 2016-01-25 Impact factor: 2.816
Authors: Karriem S Watson; Vida Henderson; Marcus Murray; Adam B Murphy; Josef Ben Levi; Tiffany McDowell; Alfreda Holloway-Beth; Pooja Gogana; Michael A Dixon; LeAndre Moore; Ivanhoe Hall; Alexander Kimbrough; Yamilé Molina; Robert A Winn Journal: Prog Community Health Partnersh Date: 2019
Authors: Richard O White; Rosette J Chakkalakal; Caroline A Presley; Aihua Bian; Jonathan S Schildcrout; Kenneth A Wallston; Shari Barto; Sunil Kripalani; Russell Rothman Journal: J Health Commun Date: 2016-09-23
Authors: Louis A Penner; John F Dovidio; Nao Hagiwara; Tanina Foster; Terrance L Albrecht; Robert A Chapman; Susan Eggly Journal: J Health Care Poor Underserved Date: 2016
Authors: Katrina Armstrong; Mary Putt; Chanita H Halbert; David Grande; Jerome Sanford Schwartz; Kaijun Liao; Noora Marcus; Mirar B Demeter; Judy A Shea Journal: Med Care Date: 2013-02 Impact factor: 2.983