PURPOSE: Several small patient studies and case reports raise concerns that the reliability of functional magnetic resonance imaging (fMRI) may be impaired in the vicinity of cerebral lesions. This could affect the clinical validity of fMRI for presurgical language lateralization. The current study sets out to identify if a systematic effect of lesion type and localization on fMRI exists. METHODS: We classify lesions typically occurring in epilepsy patients according to (1) their potential to disturb blood oxygenation level dependent (BOLD)-effect generation or detection or to disturb spatial brain normalization, and (2) the proximity of lesions to protocol-specific volumes of interest (VOIs). The effect of lesions is evaluated through the examination of 238 epilepsy patients and a subgroup of 37 patients with suspected unilateral left-language dominance according to the Wada test. RESULTS: Patients with fMRI-critical lesions such as cavernomas, gliomas, and mass defects close to VOIs, or with severe atrophy, show lower lateralization indices (LIs) and more often discordant language lateralization with the Wada test than do patients without such lesions. DISCUSSION: This study points seriously toward fMRI-language lateralization being sensitive to cerebral lesions. Some lesion types and locations are more critical than others. Our results question the noncritical application of fMRI in patients with cerebral lesions.
PURPOSE: Several small patient studies and case reports raise concerns that the reliability of functional magnetic resonance imaging (fMRI) may be impaired in the vicinity of cerebral lesions. This could affect the clinical validity of fMRI for presurgical language lateralization. The current study sets out to identify if a systematic effect of lesion type and localization on fMRI exists. METHODS: We classify lesions typically occurring in epilepsypatients according to (1) their potential to disturb blood oxygenation level dependent (BOLD)-effect generation or detection or to disturb spatial brain normalization, and (2) the proximity of lesions to protocol-specific volumes of interest (VOIs). The effect of lesions is evaluated through the examination of 238 epilepsypatients and a subgroup of 37 patients with suspected unilateral left-language dominance according to the Wada test. RESULTS:Patients with fMRI-critical lesions such as cavernomas, gliomas, and mass defects close to VOIs, or with severe atrophy, show lower lateralization indices (LIs) and more often discordant language lateralization with the Wada test than do patients without such lesions. DISCUSSION: This study points seriously toward fMRI-language lateralization being sensitive to cerebral lesions. Some lesion types and locations are more critical than others. Our results question the noncritical application of fMRI in patients with cerebral lesions.
Authors: Asim F Choudhri; Shalini Narayana; Roozbeh Rezaie; Matthew T Whitehead; Samuel S McAfee; James W Wheless; Frederick A Boop; Andrew C Papanicolaou Journal: Neuroradiol J Date: 2013-11-07
Authors: W D Gaillard; M M Berl; E S Duke; E Ritzl; S Miranda; C Liew; A Finegersh; A Martinez; I Dustin; S Sato; W H Theodore Journal: Neurology Date: 2011-03-02 Impact factor: 9.910
Authors: Anne M Findlay; Josiah B Ambrose; Deborah A Cahn-Weiner; John F Houde; Susanne Honma; Leighton B N Hinkley; Mitchel S Berger; Srikantan S Nagarajan; Heidi E Kirsch Journal: Ann Neurol Date: 2012-05 Impact factor: 10.422
Authors: Jin Wang; Xiaozhen You; Wensong Wu; Magno R Guillen; Mercedes Cabrerizo; Joseph Sullivan; Elizabeth Donner; Bruce Bjornson; William D Gaillard; Malek Adjouadi Journal: Hum Brain Mapp Date: 2013-03-01 Impact factor: 5.038
Authors: Shmuel Appel; Elizabeth S Duke; Ashley R Martinez; Omar I Khan; Irene M Dustin; Patricia Reeves-Tyer; Madison B Berl; Susumu Sato; William D Gaillard; William H Theodore Journal: Epilepsia Date: 2012-02-14 Impact factor: 5.864
Authors: Mohammad Fakhri; Mohammad Ali Oghabian; Faeze Vedaei; Ali Zandieh; Nina Masoom; Guive Sharifi; Mohammad Ghodsi; Kavous Firouznia Journal: Funct Neurol Date: 2013 Jan-Mar
Authors: E J Williams; J Stretton; M Centeno; P Bartlett; J Burdett; M Symms; J S Duncan; C Micallef Journal: Epilepsy Behav Date: 2012-07-27 Impact factor: 2.937