BACKGROUND: With the intensive scale-up of care and treatment for HIV/AIDS in developing countries, some fear that intensified attention to HIV programs may overwhelm health care systems and lead to declines in delivery of other primary health care. Few data exist that confirm negative or positive synergies on health care provision generally resulting from HIV-dedicated programs. METHODS: Using a retrospective observational design we compare aggregate service data in Rwandan health facilities before and after the introduction of HIV care on selected measures of primary health care. The study tests the hypothesis that non-HIV care does not decrease after the introduction of basic HIV care. FINDINGS: Overall, no declines were observed in reproductive health services, services for children, laboratory tests, and curative care. Statistically significant increases were found in utilization and provision of some preventive services. Multivariate regression, including introduction of HIV care and two important health care financing initiatives in Rwanda, revealed positive associations of all with observed increases. Introduction of HIV services was especially associated with increases in reproductive health. While hospitalization rates increased for the whole sample, declines were observed at health facilities that offered basic HIV care plus highly active antiretroviral therapy. INTERPRETATION: Our results partially counter fears that HIV programs are producing adverse effects in non-HIV service delivery. Rather than leading to declines in other primary health care delivery, our findings suggest that the integration of HIV clinical services may contribute to increases.
BACKGROUND: With the intensive scale-up of care and treatment for HIV/AIDS in developing countries, some fear that intensified attention to HIV programs may overwhelm health care systems and lead to declines in delivery of other primary health care. Few data exist that confirm negative or positive synergies on health care provision generally resulting from HIV-dedicated programs. METHODS: Using a retrospective observational design we compare aggregate service data in Rwandan health facilities before and after the introduction of HIV care on selected measures of primary health care. The study tests the hypothesis that non-HIV care does not decrease after the introduction of basic HIV care. FINDINGS: Overall, no declines were observed in reproductive health services, services for children, laboratory tests, and curative care. Statistically significant increases were found in utilization and provision of some preventive services. Multivariate regression, including introduction of HIV care and two important health care financing initiatives in Rwanda, revealed positive associations of all with observed increases. Introduction of HIV services was especially associated with increases in reproductive health. While hospitalization rates increased for the whole sample, declines were observed at health facilities that offered basic HIV care plus highly active antiretroviral therapy. INTERPRETATION: Our results partially counter fears that HIV programs are producing adverse effects in non-HIV service delivery. Rather than leading to declines in other primary health care delivery, our findings suggest that the integration of HIV clinical services may contribute to increases.
Authors: Samuel Abimerech Luboga; Bert Stover; Travis W Lim; Frederick Makumbi; Noah Kiwanuka; Flavia Lubega; Assay Ndizihiwe; Eddie Mukooyo; Erin K Hurley; Nagesh Borse; Angela Wood; James Bernhardt; Nathaniel Lohman; Lianne Sheppard; Scott Barnhart; Amy Hagopian Journal: Health Policy Plan Date: 2016-03-27 Impact factor: 3.344
Authors: Margaret E Kruk; Peter C Rockers; Elizabeth H Williams; S Tornorlah Varpilah; Rose Macauley; Geetor Saydee; Sandro Galea Journal: Bull World Health Organ Date: 2010-07-01 Impact factor: 9.408
Authors: Agnes Binagwaho; Claire M Wagner; Maurice Gatera; Corine Karema; Cameron T Nutt; Fidele Ngabo Journal: Bull World Health Organ Date: 2012-05-23 Impact factor: 9.408
Authors: Agnes Binagwaho; Paul E Farmer; Sabin Nsanzimana; Corine Karema; Michel Gasana; Jean de Dieu Ngirabega; Fidele Ngabo; Claire M Wagner; Cameron T Nutt; Thierry Nyatanyi; Maurice Gatera; Yvonne Kayiteshonga; Cathy Mugeni; Placidie Mugwaneza; Joseph Shema; Parfait Uwaliraye; Erick Gaju; Marie Aimee Muhimpundu; Theophile Dushime; Florent Senyana; Jean Baptiste Mazarati; Celsa Muzayire Gaju; Lisine Tuyisenge; Vincent Mutabazi; Patrick Kyamanywa; Vincent Rusanganwa; Jean Pierre Nyemazi; Agathe Umutoni; Ida Kankindi; Christian Ntizimira; Hinda Ruton; Nathan Mugume; Denis Nkunda; Espérance Ndenga; Joel M Mubiligi; Jean Baptiste Kakoma; Etienne Karita; Claude Sekabaraga; Emmanuel Rusingiza; Michael L Rich; Joia S Mukherjee; Joseph Rhatigan; Corrado Cancedda; Didi Bertrand-Farmer; Gene Bukhman; Sara N Stulac; Neo M Tapela; Cassia van der Hoof Holstein; Lawrence N Shulman; Antoinette Habinshuti; Matthew H Bonds; Michael S Wilkes; Chunling Lu; Mary C Smith-Fawzi; JaBaris D Swain; Michael P Murphy; Alan Ricks; Vanessa B Kerry; Barbara P Bush; Richard W Siegler; Cori S Stern; Anne Sliney; Tej Nuthulaganti; Injonge Karangwa; Elisabetta Pegurri; Ophelia Dahl; Peter C Drobac Journal: Lancet Date: 2014-04-04 Impact factor: 79.321
Authors: Thomas A Odeny; Jeremy Penner; Jayne Lewis-Kulzer; Hannah H Leslie; Starley B Shade; Walter Adero; Jackson Kioko; Craig R Cohen; Elizabeth A Bukusi Journal: AIDS Res Treat Date: 2013-05-07
Authors: Paul E Farmer; Cameron T Nutt; Claire M Wagner; Claude Sekabaraga; Tej Nuthulaganti; Jonathan L Weigel; Didi Bertrand Farmer; Antoinette Habinshuti; Soline Dusabeyesu Mugeni; Jean-Claude Karasi; Peter C Drobac Journal: BMJ Date: 2013-01-18
Authors: Stephanie M Topp; Julien M Chipukuma; Matimba M Chiko; Evelyn Matongo; Carolyn Bolton-Moore; Stewart E Reid Journal: Health Policy Plan Date: 2012-07-11 Impact factor: 3.344