OBJECTIVES: To determine inorganic nutrient and contaminant concentrations in subsistence foods consumed by Alaska Natives, concentration changes related to common preparation methods and provide a basic risk-benefit analysis for these foods. STUDY DESIGN: Eleven essential and six non-essential elements were measured in foods derived from spotted seals and sheefish. METHODS: Essential nutrients in foodstuffs were compared to Daily Recommended Intake (DRI) criteria. Non-essential elements were compared to Tolerable Daily Intake Limits (TDIL). These comparisons serve as a risk-benefit analysis, not as consumption advice. RESULTS: Cooking altered nutrient and contaminant concentrations. Spotted seal muscle and kidney are rich in Fe and Se; liver in Cu, Fe, Mo and Se; and sheefish muscle in Se. TDIL was exceeded in a 100 g serving of seal for THg in raw and fried liver and boiled kidney; MeHg in dried muscle and raw and fried liver; Cd in raw and boiled kidney; and As in raw and rendered blubber. Arsenic exceeded TDIL in sheefish muscle. However, toxicity potential is likely reduced by the element form (i.e., organic As, inorganic Hg) and the presence of protective nutrients such as Se. CONCLUSIONS: Preparation methods alter wildlife tissues from their raw state, significantly affecting element concentrations. Direct evaluation of actual food items is warranted to determine risk-benefit ratios of traditional diets. Traditional foods provide many essential nutrients with a very limited risk from contaminants. We encourage continued consumption of traditional foods, and urge public health agencies to develop applicable models for providing consumption advice, incorporating food processing considerations.
OBJECTIVES: To determine inorganic nutrient and contaminant concentrations in subsistence foods consumed by Alaska Natives, concentration changes related to common preparation methods and provide a basic risk-benefit analysis for these foods. STUDY DESIGN: Eleven essential and six non-essential elements were measured in foods derived from spotted seals and sheefish. METHODS: Essential nutrients in foodstuffs were compared to Daily Recommended Intake (DRI) criteria. Non-essential elements were compared to Tolerable Daily Intake Limits (TDIL). These comparisons serve as a risk-benefit analysis, not as consumption advice. RESULTS: Cooking altered nutrient and contaminant concentrations. Spotted seal muscle and kidney are rich in Fe and Se; liver in Cu, Fe, Mo and Se; and sheefish muscle in Se. TDIL was exceeded in a 100 g serving of seal for THg in raw and fried liver and boiled kidney; MeHg in dried muscle and raw and fried liver; Cd in raw and boiled kidney; and As in raw and rendered blubber. Arsenic exceeded TDIL in sheefish muscle. However, toxicity potential is likely reduced by the element form (i.e., organic As, inorganic Hg) and the presence of protective nutrients such asSe. CONCLUSIONS: Preparation methods alter wildlife tissues from their raw state, significantly affecting element concentrations. Direct evaluation of actual food items is warranted to determine risk-benefit ratios of traditional diets. Traditional foods provide many essential nutrients with a very limited risk from contaminants. We encourage continued consumption of traditional foods, and urge public health agencies to develop applicable models for providing consumption advice, incorporating food processing considerations.
Authors: Joseph B McLaughlin; John P Middaugh; Charles J Utermohle; Elvin D Asay; Andrea M Fenaughty; Jason E Eberhart-Phillips Journal: JAMA Date: 2004-06-02 Impact factor: 56.272
Authors: Sven O E Ebbesson; Lars O E Ebbesson; Michael Swenson; John M Kennish; David C Robbins Journal: Int J Circumpolar Health Date: 2005-09 Impact factor: 1.228
Authors: Sven O E Ebbesson; Patricia M Risica; Lars O E Ebbesson; John M Kennish; M Elizabeth Tejero Journal: Int J Circumpolar Health Date: 2005-09 Impact factor: 1.228
Authors: R Zeisler; R Demiralp; B J Koster; P R Becker; M Burow; P Ostapczuk; S A Wise Journal: Sci Total Environ Date: 1993-11-01 Impact factor: 7.963
Authors: Michael A Schillaci; Benjamin P Y-H Lee; J Margaret Castellini; Michael J C Reid; Todd M O'Hara Journal: Primates Date: 2011-02-16 Impact factor: 2.163
Authors: Marie K Fialkowski; Megan A McCrory; Sparkle M Roberts; J Kathleen Tracy; Lynn M Grattan; Carol J Boushey Journal: J Am Diet Assoc Date: 2010-01
Authors: Lena Maria Nilsson; James Berner; Alexey A Dudarev; Gert Mulvad; Jon Øyvind Odland; Alan Parkinson; Arja Rautio; Constantine Tikhonov; Birgitta Evengård Journal: Int J Circumpolar Health Date: 2013-08-07 Impact factor: 1.228
Authors: Matthew O Gribble; Roxanne Karimi; Beth J Feingold; Jennifer F Nyland; Todd M O'Hara; Michail I Gladyshev; Celia Y Chen Journal: J Mar Biol Assoc U K Date: 2015-09-08 Impact factor: 1.394