[Reevaluation of indications for adjuvant hormone therapy in primary breast cancer with high metastatic risk].

This study concerns the correlation between ER and PR status, menopausal status and the effect of adjuvant hormonotherapy in high risk primary breast cancer patients. We have compared the results obtained in a randomized trial (Institut Paoli-Calmettes, Marseille) with those of a historic series (Centre René Huguenin, Saint-Cloud). The patients presented the same clinical and histological criteria and received identical therapeutic protocols (chemotherapy and/or hormonotherapy). Compared with patients receiving no adjuvant treatment, it appeared that: 1) in post-menopausal patients, a significant detrimental effect of tamoxifen was found in ER-negative patients, while in ER-positive patients hormonal treatment was well correlated with both the presence and level of steroid receptors; 2) in pre-menopausal patients, hormonal therapy (oophorectomy + tamoxifen) appeared to be mediated by a complex mechanism involving more than an ER-positive cell population. In the light of the published results, the present findings underline the importance of reevaluating the indications of hormonotherapy in terms of hormone receptors and menopausal status. They also indicate the importance of biological factors in the evaluation of response to therapy. They can identify, subsets of patients in whom a given therapeutic protocol is detrimental, even though it may be beneficial for the overall population. heterogeneity in response to therapy among patient subsets is one of the most important problems which confronts medical statisticians and clinical investigators.

RCT Entities:   Population Interventions Outcomes