Parabens as agents for improving crocetin esters' shelf-life in aqueous saffron extracts.

The effect of parabens on the shelf-life of crocetin esters and picrocrocin in aqueous saffron solutions was studied. Degradation of saffron crocetin esters fits a first-order kinetics model, and the results indicated that the crocetin (beta-D-glucosyl)-(beta-D-gentiobiosyl) esters were more stable than the crocetin di-(beta-D-gentiobiosyl) esters regardless of whether trans and cis isomers were considered. Under all tested conditions both parabens gave good results, especially propyl paraben that showed a greater influence on the degradation rate constant, except for cis-crocetin di-(beta-D-gentiobiosyl) ester and cis-crocetin (beta-D-glucosyl)-(beta-D-gentiobiosyl) ester. In presence of propyl paraben (200 mg/L), the half-life periods of trans-crocetin di-(beta-D-gentiobiosyl) esterimproved considerably, up to four-fold. Special attention has been paid to the effect of propyl paraben on 46 saffrons with different crocetin ester contents. No differences were observed in terms of picrocrocin. By analysis of variance, it is noteworthy that there were differences between the mean content of crocetin esters for all analysed saffron, except for trans-crocetin (beta-D-glucosyl)-(beta-D-gentiobiosyl) ester.

1. Introduction

When the carotenoids reduce their size, eliminating terminal groups from the molecule, they are known as apocarotenoids, the group to which the saffron pigments belong to. Derivatives of an apocarotenoid, called crocetin (C44H64O24, 8,8´-diapo-Ψ,Ψ´-carotenedioic acid), in which it is esterified with one or two glucose, gentibiose or neapolitanose sugar moieties, are present in Crocus sativus L. stigmas and Gardenia jasminoides Ellis fruit and are commonly known as crocetin esters [1]. These compounds are known for their colouring properties, owing to their peculiar water soluble behaviour, in contrast to most families of carotenoids. It has been demonstrated that the colouring strength as well as the visual colour of saffron, depends on the dehydration process used to produce saffron spice [2]. The crocetin esters deteriorate quickly in aqueous extracts and several kinetic studies have shown that colour degradation follows first-order kinetics; it is sensitive to exposure to light, thermal treatment, and acidic environments, as well as to the presence of additives [3,4,5,6,7,8,9]. It would be very interesting to lengthen the life of saffron aqueous extracts to avoid the fast oxidation of crocetin esters.

Picrocrocin (C16H26O7,4-(β-D-glucopyranosyloxy)-2,6,6-trimethyl-1-cyclohexene-1-carboxaldehyde) is considered as being mainly responsible for the bitter taste of saffron, together with other related compounds and kaempferols [10]. Picrocrocin is converted to safranal, the main contributor to saffron aroma, either by an enzymatic/dehydration process or directly by thermal degradation. Unlike crocetin esters, only a few studies have dealt with picrocrocin degradation, and these have emphasized its high stability [3,11].

Compounds belonging to the paraben family, specifically methyl paraben (MP) and propyl paraben (PP), are commonly added to foods, drinks, medicines and cosmetics as antimicrobial preservatives due to their relatively non-irritating, non-sensitizing and low toxicity characteristics [12,13]. Moreover, parabens occur naturally in foods. Methyl paraben has been reported as a constituent of cloudberry, yellow passion fruit juice, white wine, botrytised wine, and Bourbon vanilla, and recently, propyl paraben has been detected in the aerial part of the plant Stocksia brahuica (Family: Sapindaceae) [14]. Several authors reported methods for determination of parabens in cosmetics, food products and pharmaceuticals [14,15,16,17,18,19]. For example, degradation kinetics of methyl and propyl paraben in aqueous solution are well described in literature, being in both cases first-order degradation kinetics [20].

For this reason, the main objective of this work was to study the effect of parabens on the life prolongation of overall, trans, cis and individual crocetin esters and picrocrocin in aqueous saffron solutions to reduce their degradation in order to know the real colour composition of saffron extract; and to make faster and cost-effective the determination of crocetin esters when a great number of samples arrive in the laboratory in a short period of time. The effect of propyl paraben on saffrons with different content of crocetin esters was also studied.

2. Results and Discussion

Quality parameters of a control saffron sample were evaluated according to ISO 3632 (2003) [21]. Results indicated that the sample used belonged to category I: moisture and volatile content, 9.3%; colouring strength ( 440 nm), 291; 257 nm, 94; 330 nm, 30. Table 1 reports the overall and individual crocetin ester composition of the control sample, expressed as percentage on a dry basis, their retention times and also their kinetic parameters as rate constants (k), determination coefficients (R2) and half-life periods (t1/2). It is noteworthy that all rate constants were negative, as it was degradation, but they were expressed in absolute value. It is necessary to point out that the trans-crocetin di-(β-d-gentiobiosyl) ester (trans-4-GG; Figure 1) represents almost the 60% of the total crocetin ester content present in the aqueous extract and the first two (trans-4-GG and trans-3-Gg) comprise over 80% of the total esters. The half-life period of total crocetin esters was 47 hours, while for trans and cis it was 51 and 39 hours, respectively, indicating a strong effect due to the trans isomer content. The results pointed out that the 3-Gg crocetin esters were more stable than the 4-GG regardless of the isomer (trans or cis) considered.

Table 1

Total and individual crocetin esters composition, retention time (tR), rate constants (k), determination coefficients (R2) and half-life periods (t1/2) of each crocetin ester in saffron aqueous extract of the control sample.

Compound	Mean contentab±SD (g/100g)	% contenta ± SD	tR (min)	(k±SD)*103 (h-1)	R2	t1/2 (h)
Total crocetin esters	31.15±0.05	100.00±0.01		14.6	0.995	47
Total trans	28.21±0.08	93.09±0.22		13.7	0.995	51
Total cis	2.94±0.17	6.91±0.32		17.7	0.946	39
Trans-4-GG	18.72±0.38	58.61±1.19	10.3	29.3	0.998	24
Trans-3-Gg	6.75±0.39	25.34±1.45	10.8	11.9	0.912	58
Trans-2–G	0.87±0.12	4.08±0.56	11.5	41.8	0.972	17
Cis-4-GG	1.97±0.32	4.39±0.71	12.0	18.8	0.991	37
Cis-3-Gg	0.82±0.10	2.20±0.28	12.7	11.4	0.974	61

a Values are the means of trials performed in triplicate; b g of compound/100g of saffron, dry basis.

Figure 1

Structure of crocetin esters, picrocrocin and parabens. In the case of crocetin esters with cis-configuration, the position of the substitutes R1 and R2 could not be exactly determined in relation to the C13-14 bond.

The trials carried out at 25 ºC showed that the crocetin esters follow a first-order kinetic model in aqueous extracts. Also, with respect to the rate constants (k) and half-life periods (t1/2) of the major crocetin esters, the data obtained at 25 ºC were intermediate values with regard to those reported by Sanchez et al. and measured between 5 and 30 ºC [9].

As it can been observed in Table 1, the degradation of crocetin esters is important, but these compounds need some time for extraction. According to ISO 3632 (2003) [21] to standardize saffron quality analysis, the extraction time is set to 1 hour, but this is evidently not enough time to completely extract all the crocetin esters as the vegetable material still has an intense red colour. Other authors have reported more exhaustive extraction times, up to 24 hours [3,7], so some stabilizers such as the parabens maybe useful for addition to the aqueous saffron samples for the purpose of improving the analysis time. As well, during saffron post-harvesting period many samples have to be analysed in short period of time. Table 2 shows the kinetic parameters for trans and cis crocetin esters in saffron aqueous extracts in presence of different concentrations of methyl paraben and propyl paraben, respectively. In most cases studied the degradation of crocetin esters adjusted to a first-order kinetics model although this was not always possible since their content was constant. As has been observed, when increasing the concentration of parabens the k values showed a marked decrease in comparison with the data obtained for control sample. For trans-2-G, the degradation of two esters ceases, with their content remaining constant in presence of 100 mg/L of MP or PP and also for higher concentrations. At 150 and 200 mg/L of the two parabens cis-3-Gg remained at a constant level, showing the positive effect of their addition to this crocetin ester. In all tested conditions both parabens gave good results, especially propyl paraben, which showed a greater influence on the degradation rate constant. The only exceptions were cis-4-GG at all concentrations of methyl paraben and cis-3-Gg at 50 and 100 mg/L, where the degradation rate constants were higher than for propyl paraben. In the presence of MP cis-isomers had lowest k and therefore they degraded more slowly. With respect to the 3-Gg and 4-GG crocetin esters, also in presence of parabens, it was established that 3-Gg had a longer half-life period, regardless of the isomer considered (trans or cis).

Table 2

Degradation rate constant (k), determination coefficient (R2) and half-life period (t1/2) of overall, trans, cis and individual crocetin esters in saffron aqueous extract in presence of methylparaben and propylparaben, respectively, at 25 ºC.

Crocetin esters	Methylparaben
	50 mg/L			100 mg/L			150 mg/L			200 mg/L
	(K±SD)*103 (h-1)	R2	t1/2 (h)	(K±SD)*103 (h-1)	R2	t1/2 (h)	(K±SD)* 103 (h-1)	R2	t1/2 (h)	(K±SD)*103 (h-1)	R2	t1/2 (h)
Total crocetin esters	17.6	0.989	39	14.8	0.966	47	9.4	0.974	74	8.8	0.972	79
Total trans	18.2	0.987	38	15.5	0.964	45	9.2	0.977	75	9.2	0.971	75
Total cis	6.8	0.931	101	6.4	0.930	108	4.1	0.939	169	2.6	0.840	267
Trans-4-GG	24.3	0.996	29	20.4	0.920	34	9.6	0.999	72	8.2	0.940	85
Trans-3-Gg	10.1	0.966	69	10.0	0.950	69	9.7	0.903	71	9.4	0.923	74
Trans-2-G	26.4	0.961	26	*			*			*
Cis-4-GG	14.9	0.917	47	9.7	0.981	71	6.6	0.938	105	5.0	0.915	139
Cis-3-Gg	9.2	0.947	75	4.6	0.983	151	*			*
	Propylparaben
	50 mg/L			100 mg/L			150 mg/L			200 mg/L
Total crocetin esters	14.4	0.995	48	13.1	0.983	54	11.8	0.958	83	7.5	0.988	92
Total trans	14.2	0.998	49	12.8	0.961	52	9.6	0.971	80	7.8	0.978	86
Total cis	8.0	0.940	94	7.3	0.989	99	*			*
Trans-4-GG	14.8	0.998	47	14.3	0.990	48	8.5	0.982	82	7.4	0.981	94
Trans-3-Gg	11.7	0.980	59	4.9	0.917	141	4.3	0.944	161	4.3	0.971	161
Trans-2-G	16.2	0.930	43	15.2	0.916	46	*			*
Cis-4-GG	16.0	0.996	43	11.4	0.922	61	8.4	0.999	83	8.2	0.923	85
Cis-3-Gg	9.9	0.946	70	9.0	0.938	77	*			*

* First-order kinetics was not followed, crocetin ester content was constant

Since trans-4-GG is approximately 60% of total content, its behaviour is dominant in comparison with the behaviour of other crocetin esters. Upon increasing the concentration of propyl paraben up to 200 mg/L, the effect on trans-4-GG improved the half-life periods considerably, going from the 24 hours obtained at 25 ºC without the addition of paraben to 94 h after adding 200 mg/L of propyl paraben, a four-fold improvement. Moreover, the degradation rate constant decreased to 0.0074 h-1, so it indicates a higher stability of this compound and also a slower degradation. In the conditions used to carry out these trials, the addition of PP gave better results than MP, showing a positive effect especially on the trans-crocetin esters that represent the almost total content.

The effect of two parabens on picrocrocin was then studied. In both cases, it was observed that picrocrocin follows a second-order kinetic model according to Alonso et al. [5]. It therefore seems that the addition of paraben did not influence its degradation since its half-life period was very long. According to Morteza et al. [22], the rate of methyl paraben decomposition was higher than propyl paraben.

2.1. Stability of saffron from different geographical zones

Next the influence of propyl paraben (200 mg/L) on the degradation of saffron with different content of crocetin esters was valued on 46 saffron samples coming from four different countries (Table 3). Data indicated that these samples all belonged to category I according to ISO 3632 (2003) [21]. The saffrons coming from Greece, Italy, Spain and Iran had different colouring strength, thus showing a different content of trans and cis crocetin esters. The correlation between colouring strength and mean content of total, trans and cis crocetin esters is shown in Figure 2. As can be observed, the values of colouring strength seem to be directly proportional to the content of trans crocetin esters. For Greece, Italy, Spain and Iran the first two in percentage content are trans-isomers, representing more than 70%. For the four countries, the total content of trans-isomers varies in a range between 83 and 91%, so the kinetic behaviour of these saffrons will follow the trend imposed by the predominant crocetin esters. By analysis of variance (ANOVA) it is noteworthy that there were differences between the saffrons coming from Greece and Spain. This can be explained by the different production processes. Olive oil was added to Italian saffron to improve storage. Iranian saffron was processed in a different way, when compared to Greece, Spain and Italy. With regard to the first two, the content of trans-4-GG is different for the four countries, while trans-3-Gg content was not significantly different between Greece and Italy, nor between Greece and Spain, unlike Iran. Thus, the greater advantages deriving from the addition of propyl paraben will be observed in saffrons with a relative higher content of trans-crocetin esters. Considering the data obtained, Italian and Iranian saffrons have the higher content of trans-isomers, so the positive effect of PP should be greater on them. In the conditions tested, PP is able to prolong the life of crocetin esters in saffron aqueous extracts and allows for analysis of compounds with a fast degradation and also a better use of the equipments as the autosamplers. Furthermore, the addition of PP in aqueous solution could be extended to other products.

Table 3

Quality characteristics and content of each crocetin ester in saffron aqueous extracts coming from Greece, Italy, Spain and Iran, stabilized by means of propylparaben addition (200 mg/L).

Country

Greece (9)

Italy (11)

Spain (14)

Iran (12)

Moisture & volatile content % ± SD

8.51±0.69

8.78±0.43

6.59±1.24

7.29±0.57

Colouring strength ± SD

239.30±9.87

279.14±12.15

260.63±20.39

233.11±7.86

Crocetin Esters

Mean content (g/100g)

(Content± SD)%

Δ mean content*±SD

Mean content (g/100g)

(Content± SD)%

Δ mean content*±SD

Mean content (g/100g)

(Content± SD)%

Δ mean content*±SD

Mean content (g/100g)

(Content± SD)%

Δ mean content*±SD

Total

25.94b

100.00±0.01

1.08±0.58

29.88c

100.02±0.03

1.42±1.09

29.31c

100.00±0.01

-1.94±0.19

24.99a

100.00±0.01

1.55±0.37

Total trans

20.37a

83.86a±0.93

0.99±0.12

26.67c

91.53c±0.65

1.45±1.07

22.98b

85.26a±1.45

-0.70±0.27

20.94a

88.09b±1.97

1.22±0.34

Total cis

5.57b

16.14c±0.93

0.96±0.34

3.21a

8.41a±0.65

0.73±0.41

6.33b

14.74c±1.45

1.52±0.72

4.05a

11.91b±1.97

1.60±0.46

Trans-4-GG

11.77a

44.79a±2.57

2.29±0.59

17.79c

58.05d±1.44

2.56±0.62

14.35b

50.15c±3.07

1.92±0.61

12.03a

47.01b±1.38

4.21±0.60

Trans-3-Gg

5.75a

26.25ab±0.84

-0.92±0.12

6.63a

25.92a±1.39

0.90±0.79

6.55a

27.45b±2.29

-1.13±0.32

6.37a

29.84c±1.54

-1.27±0.25

Trans-2-G

1.37c

7.78c±0.95

-2.61±0.41

0.50a

2.46a±0.53

-2.21±1.65

0.55a

2.87a±0.88

-2.32±0.59

1.01b

5.89b±1.77

-4.50±0.31

Cis-4-GG

3.44b

9.33b±0.48

1.97±0.43

2.06a

5.74a±0.75

1.41±1.27

4.51c

9.63b±3.37

1.32±0.21

2.57ab

7.16a±1.25

2.83±0.49

Cis-3-Gg

1.93b

6.26c±0.94

-0.75±0.49

0.89a

2.08a±0.28

2.14±0.78

1.46a

4.35b±1.46

-1.26±0.50

1.16ab

3.78b±0.72

-0.91±0.45

() Number of samples analyzed for each country. * Δ mean content % between 0 and 24 h. Different letters between rows indicate significant differences at 0.05% level.

Figure 2

Correlation between colouring strength and mean content of total, trans and cis crocetin esters in samples from Greece, Italy, Spain and Iran.

3. Experimental

3.1. Samples

A standard saffron sample belonging to commercial category I according to ISO 3632 (2003) [21] was used as control for all trials. Moreover, 46 samples of saffron (9 from Greece, 11 from Italy, 12 from Iran and 14 from Spain) were collected for studying the stability according to the production countries.

3.2. Chemicals and reagents

a) Standards: Methyl 4-hydroxybenzoate (methyl paraben, MP, Sigma reference) and n-propyl 4-hydroxybenzoate (n-propyl paraben, PP, 99%) were purchased from Sigma-Aldrich (Madrid, Spain). Exact masses (1.00 g) of the chemical standards were dissolved first in acetonitrile and then water was added (50%) in a volumetric flask (500 mL). Different volumes of these stocking solutions (2 g/L) were added to the saffron aqueous extracts to obtain the following concentrations of parabens 50-100-150-200 mg/L.

b) Solvents: acetonitrile was purchased from Panreac (Barcelona, Spain) while water was purified through a Milli-Q System (Millipore, Bedford, MA, USA).

3.3. Procedure and Instrumentation

The saffron aqueous extract (500 mg/L) was prepared according to ISO 3632 (2003) [21]. Different volumes of a methyl paraben solution, placed in an amber vial, were then added to this saffron aqueous extract to obtain different concentrations (50-100-150-200 mg/L) of this paraben. For propyl paraben, the same procedure was followed. As control sample a saffron aqueous extract with no addition of parabens was used (Figure 3). The control sample was analysed every 40 min for 24 hours. The solution was homogenized and 20 μL was injected into an Agilent 1100 HPLC chromatograph (Palo Alto, CA) equipped with a 150 mm x 4.6 mm I.d., 5 μm Phenomenex (Le Pecq Cedex, France) Luna C18 column thermostated at 30 ºC. The solvents were water (A) and acetonitrile (B) using the following gradient: 80% A for 5 min to 20 % A in 15 min, at a flow rate of 0.8 mL/min. The DAD detector was set at 250 nm for the determination of picrocrocin, and at 440 nm for determining the crocetin esters. The 46 saffron samples were also analysed. For each, a saffron aqueous extract (500 mg/L) was prepared according to ISO 3632 (2003) [21]. This solution was then placed in an amber vial and 200 mg/L of propylparaben added. All experiments were carried out in triplicate at 25 ± 2 ºC. Each compound was identified by HPLC-DAD and the results were in agreement with literature [1,9]. Respective maxima in the UV–Vis region and retention times were used as means of identification. Due to the lack of pure standards for each crocetin ester, quantification was based on the equation: where Mwi stands for the molecular weight of the crocetin ester i, is the colouring strength, A is the percentage peak area of the crocetin ester i at 440 nm, and Єt,c is the molecular coefficient absorbance value (89000 for trans-crocetin esters and 63350 for cis-crocetin esters) [23].

Figure 3

Scheme of workplan.

3.4. Geographical sample differentiation according to the stability

47 saffron aqueous extract samples (control sample and 46 saffrons coming from different countries) were analysed by UV-Vis using a Perkin-Elmer Lambda 25 spectrophotometer (Norwalk, CT) at 257, 330 and 440 nm. at 257 nm, at 330 nm and at 440 nm values were calculated according to ISO 3632 (2003) [21]. Every sample was measured in triplicate. The kinetic parameters of each reaction-reaction order, rate constants (k), and half-life periods (t1/2) were obtained using the integral method [24]. This method uses a trial-and-error procedure to find reaction order. If the order assumed is correct, the appropriate plot of the concentration-time data[concentration against time (zero-order), ln concentration against time (first-order), and concentration-1 against time (second-order)] should be linear. The result showing the best correlation coefficient (R2) was selected.

3.5. Statistical analysis

Evaluation of the statistical significance of differences was performed using analysis of variance (ANOVA) with the aid of the SPSS 15.0 for Windows (SPSS Inc.) statistical program.

4. Conclusions

Regarding the control sample, all crocetin esters followed a first-order kinetic model confirming the data reported in the literature. The 3-Gg crocetin esters were more stable than the 4-GG ones for both trans and cis-isomers. A stabilizing effect towards crocetin esters was observed for both parabens, especially for propyl paraben. The saffron samples analysed with the addition of 200 mg/L of propyl paraben showed significant differences in the total crocetin ester content, except for Italian and Spanish samples. Unlike the remaining crocetin esters, significant differences in the content of trans-3Gg between countries were not found. No significant differences have been found with pricrocrocin, as it is a very stable molecule. Therefore, the addition of these compounds would permit the faster and cost-effective determination of crocetin esters of numerous samples using the autosampler HPLC systems, with the subsequent improvement of routine saffron analysis.