Literature DB >> 19308107

Joining the conversation: newspaper journalists' views on working with researchers.

Charlotte Waddell1, Jonathan Lomas, John N Lavis, Julia Abelson, Cody A Shepherd, Twylla Bird-Gayson.   

Abstract

For health researchers who seek more research use in policy making to improve health and healthcare, working with the news media may represent an opportunity, given the media's pivotal role in public policy agenda-setting. Much literature on science and health journalism assumes a normative stance, focusing on improving the accuracy of news coverage. In this study, we investigated journalists' perspectives and experiences. We were particularly interested in learning how health researchers could work constructively with journalists as a means to increase research use in policy making. Qualitative methods were used to conduct and analyze interviews with experienced newspaper journalists across Canada, with children's mental health as a content example. In response, study participants emphasized journalistic processes more than the content of news coverage, whether children's mental health or other topics. Instead, they focused on what they thought researchers needed to know about journalists' roles, practices and views on working with researchers. Newspaper journalists balance business and social responsibilities according to their respective roles as editors, columnists and reporters. In practice, journalists must ensure newsworthiness, relevance to readers and access to sources in a context of daily deadlines. As generalists, journalists rely on researchers to be expert interpreters, although they find many researchers unavailable or unable to communicate with public audiences. While journalists are skeptical about such common organizational communications tools as news releases, they welcome the uncommon contributions of those researchers who cultivate relationships and invest time to synthesize and communicate research evidence on an ongoing basis. Some appealed for more researchers to join them in participating in public conversations. We conclude that there are opportunities for policy-oriented health researchers to work constructively with newspaper journalists--by appreciating journalists' perspectives and by taking seriously some of their suggestions for engaging in public conversations--and that such engagement can be a means to increase the use of research evidence in policy making and thereby improve health and healthcare.

Entities:  

Year:  2005        PMID: 19308107      PMCID: PMC2585242     

Source DB:  PubMed          Journal:  Healthc Policy        ISSN: 1715-6572


  19 in total

1.  Coverage by the news media of the benefits and risks of medications.

Authors:  R Moynihan; L Bero; D Ross-Degnan; D Henry; K Lee; J Watkins; C Mah; S B Soumerai
Journal:  N Engl J Med       Date:  2000-06-01       Impact factor: 91.245

2.  Public accountability: one rule for practitioners, one for scientists?

Authors:  N Black; S Carter
Journal:  J Health Serv Res Policy       Date:  2001-07

Review 3.  Health policy-makers' perceptions of their use of evidence: a systematic review.

Authors:  Simon Innvaer; Gunn Vist; Mari Trommald; Andrew Oxman
Journal:  J Health Serv Res Policy       Date:  2002-10

4.  How can research organizations more effectively transfer research knowledge to decision makers?

Authors:  John N Lavis; Dave Robertson; Jennifer M Woodside; Christopher B McLeod; Julia Abelson
Journal:  Milbank Q       Date:  2003       Impact factor: 4.911

5.  Do the print media "hype" genetic research? A comparison of newspaper stories and peer-reviewed research papers.

Authors:  Tania M Bubela; Timothy A Caulfield
Journal:  CMAJ       Date:  2004-04-27       Impact factor: 8.262

6.  Medical messages in the media--barriers and solutions to improving medical journalism.

Authors:  Anna Larsson; Andrew D Oxman; Cheryl Carling; Jeph Herrin
Journal:  Health Expect       Date:  2003-12       Impact factor: 3.377

7.  A meta-analysis of the effect of mediated health communication campaigns on behavior change in the United States.

Authors:  Leslie B Snyder; Mark A Hamilton; Elizabeth W Mitchell; James Kiwanuka-Tondo; Fran Fleming-Milici; Dwayne Proctor
Journal:  J Health Commun       Date:  2004

8.  Scientists' and science writers' experiences reporting genetic discoveries: toward an ethic of trust in science journalism.

Authors:  Gail Geller; Barbara A Bernhardt; Mary Gardner; Joann Rodgers; Neil A Holtzman
Journal:  Genet Med       Date:  2005-03       Impact factor: 8.822

9.  Setting the agenda: does the medical literature set the agenda for articles about medicines in the newspapers?

Authors:  A M van Trigt; L T de Jong-van den Berg; L M Voogt; J Willems; T F Tromp; F M Haaijer-Ruskamp
Journal:  Soc Sci Med       Date:  1995-09       Impact factor: 4.634

10.  Research use in children's mental health policy in Canada: maintaining vigilance amid ambiguity.

Authors:  Charlotte Waddell; John N Lavis; Julia Abelson; Jonathan Lomas; Cody A Shepherd; Twylla Bird-Gayson; Mita Giacomini; David R Dan Offord
Journal:  Soc Sci Med       Date:  2005-04-26       Impact factor: 4.634

View more
  7 in total

1.  A decision-maker's perspective on Lavis and Lomas.

Authors:  Rick Roger
Journal:  Healthc Policy       Date:  2006-01

2.  The social group influences of US health journalists and their impact on the newsmaking process.

Authors:  M P McCauley; K D Blake; H I Meissner; K Viswanath
Journal:  Health Educ Res       Date:  2012-08-20

3.  Health technology assessment and the media: more compatible than one may think?

Authors:  Myriam Hivon; Pascale Lehoux; Melanie Rock; Jean-Louis Denis
Journal:  Healthc Policy       Date:  2012-05

4.  Climate for evidence-informed health systems: A print media analysis in 44 low- and middle-income countries that host knowledge-translation platforms.

Authors:  Andrew Cheung; John N Lavis; Ali Hamandi; Fadi El-Jardali; Jonathan Sachs; Nelson Sewankambo
Journal:  Health Res Policy Syst       Date:  2011-02-08

5.  Use of Pooled State Administrative Data for Mental Health Services Research.

Authors:  Kimberly Eaton Hoagwood; Susan Essock; Joseph Morrissey; Anne Libby; Sheila Donahue; Benjamin Druss; Molly Finnerty; Linda Frisman; Meera Narasimhan; Bradley D Stein; Jennifer Wisdom; Judy Zerzan
Journal:  Adm Policy Ment Health       Date:  2016-01

6.  Health Reporting in Print Media in Lebanon: Evidence, Quality and Role in Informing Policymaking.

Authors:  Fadi El-Jardali; Lama Bou Karroum; Lamya Bawab; Ola Kdouh; Farah El-Sayed; Hala Rachidi; Malak Makki
Journal:  PLoS One       Date:  2015-08-26       Impact factor: 3.240

7.  Print media coverage of primary healthcare and related research evidence in South Africa.

Authors:  Olagoke Akintola; John N Lavis; Ryan Hoskins
Journal:  Health Res Policy Syst       Date:  2015-11-12
  7 in total

北京卡尤迪生物科技股份有限公司 © 2022-2023.