Chiung-ju Liu1, Susan Kemper, Joan McDowd. 1. Department of Occupational Therapy, Indiana University at Indianapolis, Indianapolis, IN 46202-5199, USA.
Abstract
OBJECTIVE: To examine whether explanatory illustrations can improve older adults' comprehension of written health information. METHODS: Six short health-related texts were selected from websites and pamphlets. Young and older adults were randomly assigned to read health-related texts alone or texts accompanied by explanatory illustrations. Eye movements were recorded while reading. Word recognition, text comprehension, and comprehension of the illustrations were assessed after reading. RESULTS:Older adults performed as well as or better than young adults on the word recognition and text comprehension measures. However, older adults performed less well than young adults on the illustration comprehension measures. Analysis of readers' eye movements showed that older adults spent more time reading illustration-related phrases and fixating on the illustrations than did young adults, yet had poorer comprehension of the illustrations. CONCLUSION:Older adults might not benefit from text illustrations because illustrations can be difficult to integrate with the text. PRACTICE IMPLICATIONS: Health practitioners should not assume that illustrations will increase older adults' comprehension of health information.
RCT Entities:
OBJECTIVE: To examine whether explanatory illustrations can improve older adults' comprehension of written health information. METHODS: Six short health-related texts were selected from websites and pamphlets. Young and older adults were randomly assigned to read health-related texts alone or texts accompanied by explanatory illustrations. Eye movements were recorded while reading. Word recognition, text comprehension, and comprehension of the illustrations were assessed after reading. RESULTS: Older adults performed as well as or better than young adults on the word recognition and text comprehension measures. However, older adults performed less well than young adults on the illustration comprehension measures. Analysis of readers' eye movements showed that older adults spent more time reading illustration-related phrases and fixating on the illustrations than did young adults, yet had poorer comprehension of the illustrations. CONCLUSION: Older adults might not benefit from text illustrations because illustrations can be difficult to integrate with the text. PRACTICE IMPLICATIONS: Health practitioners should not assume that illustrations will increase older adults' comprehension of health information.
Authors: Ping Yein Lee; Ee Ming Khoo; Wah Yun Low; Yew Kong Lee; Khatijah Lim Abdullah; Syahidatul Akmal Azmi; Chirk Jenn Ng Journal: Health Expect Date: 2015-04-06 Impact factor: 3.377
Authors: Izadora Mc Barros; Thaciana S Alcântara; Alessandra R Mesquita; Monica L Bispo; Chiara E Rocha; Vagner Porto Moreira; Divaldo P Lyra Junior Journal: Patient Prefer Adherence Date: 2014-10-29 Impact factor: 2.711
Authors: Deb Feldman-Stewart; Mary Ann O'Brien; Marla L Clayman; B Joyce Davison; Masahito Jimbo; Michel Labrecque; Richard W Martin; Heather Shepherd Journal: BMC Med Inform Decis Mak Date: 2013-11-29 Impact factor: 2.796
Authors: Julia C M van Weert; Barbara C van Munster; Remco Sanders; René Spijker; Lotty Hooft; Jesse Jansen Journal: BMC Med Inform Decis Mak Date: 2016-04-21 Impact factor: 2.796