Martin Logan1, Mark Watts, James Owen, Peter Myers. 1. Brisbane Orthopaedic and Sports Medicine Centre, Brisbane Private Hospital, 259 Wickham Terrace, Brisbane, Queensland 4000, Australia. mlogan100@hotmail.com
Abstract
BACKGROUND: The preservation of meniscal tissue is important to protect joint surfaces. PURPOSE: We have an aggressive approach to meniscal repair, including repairing tears other than those classically suited to repair. Here we present the medium- to long-term outcome of meniscal repair (inside-out) in elite athletes. STUDY DESIGN: Case series; Level of evidence, 4. METHODS: Forty-two elite athletes underwent 45 meniscal repairs. All repairs were performed using an arthroscopically assisted inside-out technique. Eighty-three percent of these athletes had ACL reconstruction at the same time. Patients returned a completed questionnaire (including Lysholm and International Knee Documentation Committee [IKDC] scores). Mean follow-up was 8.5 years. Failure was defined by patients developing symptoms of joint line pain and/or locking or swelling requiring repeat arthroscopy and partial meniscectomy. RESULTS: The average Lysholm and subjective IKDC scores were 89.6 and 85.4, respectively. Eighty-one percent of patients returned to their main sport and most to a similar level at a mean time of 10.4 months after repair, reflecting the high level of ACL reconstruction in this group. We identified 11 definite failures, 10 medial and 1 lateral meniscus, that required excision; this represents a 24% failure rate. We identified 1 further patient who had possible failed repairs, giving a worst-case failure rate of 26.7% at a mean of 42 months after surgery. However, 7 of these failures were associated with a further injury. Therefore, the atraumatic failure rate was 11%. Age and size and location of the tears were not associated with a higher failure rate. Medial meniscal repairs were significantly more likely to fail than lateral meniscal repairs, with a failure rate of 36.4% and 5.6%, respectively (P < .05). CONCLUSION: Meniscal repair and healing are possible, and most elite athletes can return to their preinjury level of activity.
BACKGROUND: The preservation of meniscal tissue is important to protect joint surfaces. PURPOSE: We have an aggressive approach to meniscal repair, including repairing tears other than those classically suited to repair. Here we present the medium- to long-term outcome of meniscal repair (inside-out) in elite athletes. STUDY DESIGN: Case series; Level of evidence, 4. METHODS: Forty-two elite athletes underwent 45 meniscal repairs. All repairs were performed using an arthroscopically assisted inside-out technique. Eighty-three percent of these athletes had ACL reconstruction at the same time. Patients returned a completed questionnaire (including Lysholm and International Knee Documentation Committee [IKDC] scores). Mean follow-up was 8.5 years. Failure was defined by patients developing symptoms of joint line pain and/or locking or swelling requiring repeat arthroscopy and partial meniscectomy. RESULTS: The average Lysholm and subjective IKDC scores were 89.6 and 85.4, respectively. Eighty-one percent of patients returned to their main sport and most to a similar level at a mean time of 10.4 months after repair, reflecting the high level of ACL reconstruction in this group. We identified 11 definite failures, 10 medial and 1 lateral meniscus, that required excision; this represents a 24% failure rate. We identified 1 further patient who had possible failed repairs, giving a worst-case failure rate of 26.7% at a mean of 42 months after surgery. However, 7 of these failures were associated with a further injury. Therefore, the atraumatic failure rate was 11%. Age and size and location of the tears were not associated with a higher failure rate. Medial meniscal repairs were significantly more likely to fail than lateral meniscal repairs, with a failure rate of 36.4% and 5.6%, respectively (P < .05). CONCLUSION: Meniscal repair and healing are possible, and most elite athletes can return to their preinjury level of activity.
Authors: Nicolas Pujol; Nicolas Tardy; Philippe Boisrenoult; Philippe Beaufils Journal: Knee Surg Sports Traumatol Arthrosc Date: 2013-06-06 Impact factor: 4.342
Authors: Robert W Westermann; Rick W Wright; Kurt P Spindler; Laura J Huston; Brian R Wolf Journal: Am J Sports Med Date: 2014-07-14 Impact factor: 6.202
Authors: Kyle R Duchman; Robert W Westermann; Kurt P Spindler; Emily K Reinke; Laura J Huston; Annunziato Amendola; Brian R Wolf Journal: Am J Sports Med Date: 2015-10-01 Impact factor: 6.202