Literature DB >> 19274515

"Couldn't you have done just as well without the screening?". A qualitative study of benefits from screening as perceived by people without a high cardiovascular risk score.

Karen-Dorthe Bach Nielsen1, Lise Dyhr, Torsten Lauritzen, Kirsti Malterud.   

Abstract

OBJECTIVE: To explore how individuals whose health screening does not reveal a high cardiovascular risk score (CRS) interpret and respond to this result.
DESIGN: Qualitative semi-structured interviews. Purposeful sampling reflected variations in age, gender, and self-rated health within the sample. Analysis and interpretation were informed by the Health Belief Model concerning individuals' cues to act when told there is a health threat, and by Hollnagel and Malterud's theories about personal self-assessed health resources.
SETTING: Participants were recruited among participants without a high cardiovascular risk score in a Danish health-screening project.
SUBJECTS: Seven men and 15 women aged 36-50 years with a low or moderate cardiovascular risk score.
RESULTS: The screening confirmed the participants' feeling of being in good health and they put emphasis on this acquired peace of mind. Participants used the results to eliminate worries and confirm their lifestyle up to now but were aware that the results gave no guarantee that there was nothing the matter elsewhere. Some paid a price for the reassurance since they had to undergo further examinations, had unfulfilled expectations, or were irritated at not being left in peace with their reassurance.
CONCLUSION: Screened individuals who were shown not to have a high risk score appear to be reassured and confirmed in their own feeling of being healthy, and to be aware of the limitations of the screening. Consideration should be given to the possible risk of creating either insecurity or over-complacency through population screening.

Entities:  

Mesh:

Year:  2009        PMID: 19274515      PMCID: PMC3410458          DOI: 10.1080/02813430902808619

Source DB:  PubMed          Journal:  Scand J Prim Health Care        ISSN: 0281-3432            Impact factor:   2.581


  18 in total

1.  Telling people about screening programmes and screening test results: how can we do it better?

Authors:  E Goyder; A Barratt; L M Irwig
Journal:  J Med Screen       Date:  2000       Impact factor: 2.136

Review 2.  Lay experiences of health and illness: past research and future agendas.

Authors:  Julia Lawton
Journal:  Sociol Health Illn       Date:  2003

3.  The ethics of informed consent in relation to prevention screening programmes.

Authors:  J O'Hagan
Journal:  N Z Med J       Date:  1991-03-27

Review 4.  Psychological costs of screening.

Authors:  T M Marteau
Journal:  BMJ       Date:  1989-08-26

5.  The ethics, the risks and the benefits of screening.

Authors:  A B Miller
Journal:  Biomed Pharmacother       Date:  1988       Impact factor: 6.529

6.  High cholesterol levels: is mass screening the best option?

Authors:  S Kinlay
Journal:  Med J Aust       Date:  1988-06-20       Impact factor: 7.738

7.  General health screenings to improve cardiovascular risk profiles: a randomized controlled trial in general practice with 5-year follow-up.

Authors:  Marianne Engberg; Bo Christensen; Bo Karlsmose; Jorgen Lous; Torsten Lauritzen
Journal:  J Fam Pract       Date:  2002-06       Impact factor: 0.493

8.  How do patients at risk portray candidates for coronary heart disease? A qualitative interview study.

Authors:  Jan C Frich; Kirsti Malterud; Per Fugelli
Journal:  Scand J Prim Health Care       Date:  2007-06       Impact factor: 2.581

9.  You can't prevent everything anyway: a qualitative study of beliefs and attitudes about refusing health screening in general practice.

Authors:  Karen-Dorthe Bach Nielsen; Lise Dyhr; Torsten Lauritzen; Kirsti Malterud
Journal:  Fam Pract       Date:  2004-02       Impact factor: 2.267

10.  The psychosocial impact of mass screening for cardiovascular risk factors.

Authors:  T Tymstra; B Bieleman
Journal:  Fam Pract       Date:  1987-12       Impact factor: 2.267

View more
  1 in total

1.  "Am I carrier?" The patient's lived experience of thrombophilia genetic screening and its outcome.

Authors:  Guendalina Graffigna; Daniela Leone; Elena Vegni
Journal:  Health Psychol Behav Med       Date:  2014-06-04
  1 in total

北京卡尤迪生物科技股份有限公司 © 2022-2023.