Charlotte Paterson1, Nicky Britten. 1. Institute of Health Services Research, Peninsula Medical School, University of Exeter, Exeter EX1 2LU, UK. charlotte.paterson@pms.ac.uk
Abstract
OBJECTIVES: To characterize the diverse nature of peoples' experiences of acupuncture treatment for chronic health problems. Specifically, the paper addresses how this analysis deepens our understanding of holism and its relation to the therapeutic theory base. METHODS: A secondary analysis of five longitudinal interview studies using a constant comparative method. Patients experienced different types of acupuncture--traditional (based on Chinese medicine) and Western-style (based on biomedicine) in a variety of settings in the U.K. and Australia. RESULTS: The markedly different experiences of acupuncture treatment were best characterized in relation to the concept of holism. Being treated ;as a whole person' was associated with traditional acupuncture in both private and NHS practice, but not within a research trial setting. In the trial, both patients and practitioners ;played their part' in a scientific experiment. Holism was especially important to people with several health problems. DISCUSSION: The findings suggests that the experience of holistic care, in the sense of ;being treated as a whole person' is dependent on four factors: (a) the therapeutic theory that underpins the treatment; (b) structural factors such as time and setting; (c) the intention of the practitioner; and (d) the intention and needs of the patient.
OBJECTIVES: To characterize the diverse nature of peoples' experiences of acupuncture treatment for chronic health problems. Specifically, the paper addresses how this analysis deepens our understanding of holism and its relation to the therapeutic theory base. METHODS: A secondary analysis of five longitudinal interview studies using a constant comparative method. Patients experienced different types of acupuncture--traditional (based on Chinese medicine) and Western-style (based on biomedicine) in a variety of settings in the U.K. and Australia. RESULTS: The markedly different experiences of acupuncture treatment were best characterized in relation to the concept of holism. Being treated ;as a whole person' was associated with traditional acupuncture in both private and NHS practice, but not within a research trial setting. In the trial, both patients and practitioners ;played their part' in a scientific experiment. Holism was especially important to people with several health problems. DISCUSSION: The findings suggests that the experience of holistic care, in the sense of ;being treated as a whole person' is dependent on four factors: (a) the therapeutic theory that underpins the treatment; (b) structural factors such as time and setting; (c) the intention of the practitioner; and (d) the intention and needs of the patient.
Authors: Charlotte Paterson; Rod S Taylor; Peter Griffiths; Nicky Britten; Sue Rugg; Jackie Bridges; Bruce McCallum; Gerad Kite Journal: Br J Gen Pract Date: 2011-06 Impact factor: 5.386
Authors: Fiona Barlow; Clare Scott; Beverly Coghlan; Philippa Lee; Peter White; George T Lewith; Felicity L Bishop Journal: BMC Med Res Methodol Date: 2011-05-25 Impact factor: 4.615
Authors: Felicity L Bishop; Fiona Barlow; Beverly Coghlan; Philippa Lee; George T Lewith Journal: BMC Health Serv Res Date: 2011-05-27 Impact factor: 2.655
Authors: Katherine Bradbury; Miznah Al-Abbadey; Dawn Carnes; Borislav D Dimitrov; Susan Eardley; Carol Fawkes; Jo Foster; Maddy Greville-Harris; J Matthew Harvey; Janine Leach; George Lewith; Hugh MacPherson; Lisa Roberts; Laura Parry; Lucy Yardley; Felicity L Bishop Journal: BMJ Open Date: 2016-05-27 Impact factor: 2.692