BACKGROUND: The neurobiology of panic disorder is incompletely understood. The aim of this study was to determine if functional abnormalities of the putamen occur in panic disorder. METHODS: Activation patterns of 12 female subjects with panic disorder were compared to 18 female healthy controls using functional MRI at 3 T. A motor activation paradigm was used to probe putamen function. RESULTS: A complex motor activation paradigm for the non-dominant hand revealed decreased activation of the bilateral putamen among subjects with panic disorder. LIMITATIONS: The sample size was a relatively small cohort of non-depressed females. Further, some panic disorder subjects were taking medications and/or had comorbid conditions. However, second-level regression analyses did not reveal any correlations between medication use or comorbidity and activation patterns demonstrated by the non-dominant hand complex task. Finally, we used a post-hoc approach to determine the magnitude of global fMRI signal as a surrogate index of the global cerebral blood flow as a means of controlling for possible confounds from reduction of BOLD signal secondary to cerebral vasoconstriction resulting from possible hyperventilation among panic subjects. A more compelling approach would have been to record the respiratory data from subjects during scanning. CONCLUSIONS: Our findings suggest that putamen dysfunction occurs in at least some cases of panic disorder. We also provide preliminary evidence that a complex motor task for the non-dominant hand is a useful probe of putamen function in this disorder.
BACKGROUND: The neurobiology of panic disorder is incompletely understood. The aim of this study was to determine if functional abnormalities of the putamen occur in panic disorder. METHODS: Activation patterns of 12 female subjects with panic disorder were compared to 18 female healthy controls using functional MRI at 3 T. A motor activation paradigm was used to probe putamen function. RESULTS: A complex motor activation paradigm for the non-dominant hand revealed decreased activation of the bilateral putamen among subjects with panic disorder. LIMITATIONS: The sample size was a relatively small cohort of non-depressed females. Further, some panic disorder subjects were taking medications and/or had comorbid conditions. However, second-level regression analyses did not reveal any correlations between medication use or comorbidity and activation patterns demonstrated by the non-dominant hand complex task. Finally, we used a post-hoc approach to determine the magnitude of global fMRI signal as a surrogate index of the global cerebral blood flow as a means of controlling for possible confounds from reduction of BOLD signal secondary to cerebral vasoconstriction resulting from possible hyperventilation among panic subjects. A more compelling approach would have been to record the respiratory data from subjects during scanning. CONCLUSIONS: Our findings suggest that putamen dysfunction occurs in at least some cases of panic disorder. We also provide preliminary evidence that a complex motor task for the non-dominant hand is a useful probe of putamen function in this disorder.
Authors: William R Marchand; James N Lee; Yana Suchy; Cheryl Garn; Gordon Chelune; Susanna Johnson; Nicole Wood Journal: Hum Brain Mapp Date: 2012-01-30 Impact factor: 5.038
Authors: Thomas Dresler; Anne Guhn; Sara V Tupak; Ann-Christine Ehlis; Martin J Herrmann; Andreas J Fallgatter; Jürgen Deckert; Katharina Domschke Journal: J Neural Transm (Vienna) Date: 2012-06-13 Impact factor: 3.575