Cell-cell and cell-matrix adhesion are crucial during many stages of eukaryotic development. Here, we provide the first example that mucin-type O-linked glycosylation is involved in a developmentally regulated cell adhesion event in Drosophila melanogaster. Mutations in one member of the evolutionarily conserved family of enzymes that initiates O-linked glycosylation alter epithelial cell adhesion in the Drosophila wing blade. A transposon insertion mutation in pgant3 or RNA interference to pgant3 resulted in blistered wings, a phenotype characteristic of genes involved in integrin-mediated cell interactions. Expression of wild type pgant3 in the mutant background rescued the wing blistering phenotype, whereas expression of another family member (pgant35A) did not, revealing a unique requirement for pgant3. pgant3 mutants displayed reduced O-glycosylation along the basal surface of larval wing imaginal discs, which was restored with wild type pgant3 expression, suggesting that reduced glycosylation of basal proteins is responsible for disruption of adhesion in the adult wing blade. Glycosylation reactions demonstrated that PGANT3 glycosylates certain extracellular matrix (ECM) proteins. Immunoprecipitation experiments revealed that PGANT3 glycosylates tiggrin, an ECM protein known to bind integrin. We propose that this glycosyltransferase is uniquely responsible for glycosylating tiggrin in the wing disc, thus modulating proper cell adhesion through integrin-ECM interactions. This study provides the first evidence for the role of O-glycosylation in a developmentally regulated, integrin-mediated, cell adhesion event and reveals a novel player in wing blade formation during Drosophila development.
Cell-cell and cell-matrix adhesion are crucial during many stages of eukaryotic development. Here, we provide the first example that mucin-type O-linked glycosylation is involved in a developmentally regulated cell adhesion event in Drosophila melanogaster. Mutations in one member of the evolutionarily conserved family of enzymes that initiates O-linked glycosylation alter epithelial cell adhesion in the Drosophila wing blade. A transposon insertion mutation in pgant3 or RNA interference to pgant3 resulted in blistered wings, a phenotype characteristic of genes involved in integrin-mediated cell interactions. Expression of wild type pgant3 in the mutant background rescued the wing blistering phenotype, whereas expression of another family member (pgant35A) did not, revealing a unique requirement for pgant3. pgant3 mutants displayed reduced O-glycosylation along the basal surface of larval wing imaginal discs, which was restored with wild type pgant3 expression, suggesting that reduced glycosylation of basal proteins is responsible for disruption of adhesion in the adult wing blade. Glycosylation reactions demonstrated that PGANT3 glycosylates certain extracellular matrix (ECM) proteins. Immunoprecipitation experiments revealed that PGANT3 glycosylates tiggrin, an ECM protein known to bind integrin. We propose that this glycosyltransferase is uniquely responsible for glycosylating tiggrin in the wing disc, thus modulating proper cell adhesion through integrin-ECM interactions. This study provides the first evidence for the role of O-glycosylation in a developmentally regulated, integrin-mediated, cell adhesion event and reveals a novel player in wing blade formation during Drosophila development.
Cell interactions and adhesion are critical in many diverse processes, from
events occurring during embryogenesis and organogenesis to wound healing and
the alterations in cell adhesion seen upon tumor formation and metastasis
(1). Drosophila wing
development has been used as a model system to identify factors responsible
for regulating cell adhesion
(2–5).
Aberrant adhesion of the two epithelial cell layers that comprise the adult
wing blade results in separation of the cell layers, creating a localized
blister shortly after eclosion. Mutations in the integrin family of cell
surface receptors (2,
3,
5–7)
as well as proteins that interact with integrins
(4,
5,
8–13)
have been shown to produce wing blisters, highlighting the central role of
integrin-mediated cell adhesion events during wing blade formation.
Interestingly, many cell surface and extracellular matrix
(ECM)2 proteins that
influence wing blistering also interact with integrins in other
developmentally regulated cell adhesion events
(2,
14,
15).Cell surface, secreted, and ECM proteins undergo a number of
post-translational modifications as they transit the secretory apparatus to
their final destinations. Although the roles of classical N-linked
glycans and proteoglycans are widely appreciated, recent studies have
elucidated crucial roles for other types of glycans during development. The
disaccharide GlcNAcβ1–3Fuc on the Notch receptor and its ligands
has been shown to regulate receptor/ligand interactions and downstream
signaling events
(16–19).
Protein O-fucosylation and the fucosyltransferase catalyzing this
modification have roles in protein folding, trafficking
(20,
21), and secretion
(22). Most recently,
O-linked glucose has been shown to have a modulatory role in Notch
signaling events, influencing lateral inhibition and cell-fate specification
(23). Taken together, these
studies highlight the diversity of glycans found on proteins and the unique
functional roles they play during development.Studies from our laboratory and others have demonstrated the abundant
presence of another type of glycosylation, known as mucin-type
O-linked glycosylation (referred to as O-linked
glycosylation) throughout development in diverse species
(24–27).
In contrast to the previously mentioned types of glycosylation, mucin-type
O-glycosylation is initiated by a large family of enzymes known as
the UDP-GalNAc: polypeptide N-acetylgalactosaminyltranferases (PGANTs
in Drosophila or ppGalNAcTs in mammals) that transfer
N-acetylgalactosamine (GalNAc) to serine or threonine residues of
proteins destined to be membrane-bound or secreted
(28,
29). Members of this family
have unique but overlapping developmental expression patterns, and many show
distinct substrate preferences in vitro, suggesting that each enzyme
may be responsible for glycosylating a unique subset of proteins in
vivo (25,
28,
29). In vitro data
further indicate that there exists a hierarchy of activity within the family,
with some members initiating the glycosylation of unmodified substrates and
others acting only on previously glycosylated substrates, adding GalNAc at
positions vicinal to sites previously modified by other family members
(30–32).
The unique spatial and temporal expression patterns, substrate preferences,
and hierarchical action of members of this family suggest a highly regulated
process governing the acquisition of this type of glycan.Mucin-type O-glycans on secreted and membrane-bound proteins are
uniquely positioned to mediate many events regulating homeostasis and
development. Indeed, mutations in ppGalNAc-T3 are thought to be responsible
for familial tumoral calcinosis, a rare human disease characterized by
hyperphosphatemia and the development of calcified “tumors” in
cutaneous and subcutaneous tissues
(33). Mice deficient in
ppGalNAc-T1, although viable and fertile, display reduced lymphocyte homing
and bleeding disorders (34).
Studies from our laboratory have demonstrated a role for another member of
this family (pgant35A) in the proper formation of the embryonic
tracheal system in Drosophila
(35,
36). Finally, mice deficient
in the core 1 β3-galactosyltransferase, which adds a galactose to the
O-GalNAc of mucin-type O-glycans, die embryonically from
defective angiogenesis resulting in fatal brain hemorrhages
(37); hypomorphic mutations
result in thrombocytopenia and kidney defects later in development
(38). Altogether, these
studies highlight the diverse consequences of alterations in
O-glycosylation that have only recently been discovered due to the
inherent complexity of the ppGalNAcT family.Here, we examine the developmental role of another member of this family,
pgant3. Previous work from our laboratory demonstrated that PGANT3 is
one of the initiating glycosyltransferases, transferring GalNAc to previously
unmodified substrates (25).
Additionally, pgant3 gene expression is highly regulated during
development (27). In this
study we find that a transposon mutation in pgant3 or RNA
interference (RNAi) to pgant3 results in wing blistering, implicating
O-glycosylation in integrin-mediated cell adhesion occurring during
wing blade formation. A reduction in O-glycoproteins was seen along
the basal surface of the pgant3 mutant wing imaginal discs along with
altered disc morphology. Based on our studies, we propose that
O-glycosylation of specific ECM proteins known to bind integrin is
required for proper epithelial cell adhesion in the wing disc. This finding
provides the first direct evidence for the role of mucin type
O-glycans in a developmentally regulated cell adhesion event and
identifies a novel protein modification required for proper wing blade
formation in the fly.
EXPERIMENTAL PROCEDURES
Fly Strains Used—The stocks used in this study are as
follows: Bloomington stocks #5138 (y1, w*;
P{w+mC = tubP-GAL4}LL7/TM3, Sb1) (the
tubulin-Gal4 driver line); #8860 (w1118,
P{w+mW.hs = GawB}BxMS1096) (the wing-specific Gal4
driver line); #1561 (w*; P{w+mW.hs = Gal4-arm}4a,
P{w+mW.hs = Gal4-arm}4b/TM3, Sb1, Ser1) (the
armadillo-Gal4 driver line); #7748 (w1118; Df(2R)Exel
6283, PXP-UExel6263); #8283 (w1118; CyO,
P{w+mc = FRT (w+)Tub-PBac™}2/wgsp-1);
#8795 (w*; TigA1/CyO,P{lacZ-un3}276); #8796
(w*; TigX/CyO,P{lacZ-un3}276). Additionally, the
following stocks from other sources were used:
PBac{PB}pgant3c01318 from the Exelixis Drosophila
Stock Collection (39); w;
Dr/TM3, Sb1, twi-2XGFP stock (the kind gift of D. Andrew); w; TM6C,
cu, Sb, e, ca/Su(Tpl)s1, red, e stock (the kind gift of J.
Kennison).Construction of Gal4-inducible pgant3 and pgant3IR Vectors and
Transgenic Lines—The pUAST plasmid
(40) was used to generate a
Gal4-inducible construct expressing wild type pgant3 cDNA that was
then used to create transgenic flies. The complete coding region from the wild
type pgant3 gene was excised from the GH09147 cDNA clone (Invitrogen)
using EcoRI and XbaI and cloned into the same sites of pUAST to generate the
plasmid pUAS-pgant3. To generate the Gal4-inducible pgant3IR
construct, sense (taatacctaggAAGGTGAATGTTACGGAGCGTGTGG) and antisense
(taatacctaggCTGCGCCAGCATTACATTCGAAGTG) primers were used to amplify a 500-bp
fragment from the catalytic region of pgant3. The PCR product was
then cloned stepwise into the AvrII and NheI sites on either side of the
white intron in the vector pWIZ
(41) to generate a vector
containing two inversely oriented pgant3 fragments flanking the
white intron. Transformants were produced by Genetic Services Inc.
(Cambridge, MA) using methodology based on the procedure described previously
(42,
43).Fly Crosses—Rescue and overexpression experiments were
performed using flies from a UAS-pgant35A transgenic line
(36) or three independent
UAS-pgant3 transgenic lines (w; P{UAS-pgant3#3}, on the
third chromosome) (w; P{UAS-pgant3#7}, on the X chromosome) (w;
P{UAS-pgant3#10}, on the third chromosome) and the Gal4-driver stocks
described herein. All stocks used in the rescue experiments were first crossed
into the pgant3c01318 background to generate both Gal4
driver lines and P{UAS-pgant} transgenic lines heterozygous for
pgant3c01318. These heterozygous lines were then crossed
as follows, and rescue of the wing blister phenotype was assessed by scoring
straight winged progeny with or without Sb1:
pgant3c01318/CyO;
P{UAS-pgant}/P{UAS-pgant} females X
pgant3c01318/CyO;P{tubP-GAL4}LL7/TM3, Sb1
males. Crosses to assess the effect of pgant3 overexpression were
performed as shown in Table
2.
TABLE 2
Over-expression of
UAS-pgant3#3 and UAS-pgant3#10 are independent transgenic
lines generated as described under “Experimental Procedures.”
Crosses
Progeny overexpressing
pgant3a
Progeny without pgant3 overexpression
Survival of pgant3 overexpressing flies
(%)
UAS-pgant3#3/UAS-pgant3#3 × Tub-Gal4/TM3,
Sb1
0
312
0
UAS-pgant3#10/UAS-pgant3#10 × Tub-Gal4/TM3,
Sb1
6
171
4
UAS-pgant3#3/UAS-pgant3#3 × arm-Gal4/TM3,
Sb1
126
213
50
UAS-pgant3#3/TM6C, Sb1 × MS1096-Gal4/MS1096-Gal4
214
211
100
Assessed by the absence of Sb1
Over-expression of
UAS-pgant3#3 and UAS-pgant3#10 are independent transgenic
lines generated as described under “Experimental Procedures.”Assessed by the absence of Sb1Crosses to generate RNAi to pgant3 were performed by crossing
homozygous inverted repeat (IR) transgenic lines (w1118;
P{UAS-pgant3IR2#2} or w1118; P{UAS-pgant3IR2#9})
to a tubulin-Gal4-driver line (P{tubP-GAL4}LL7/TM3, Sb1, twi-2XGFP)
and comparing progeny with and without Sb1 and GFP. Crosses to the
wing-specific driver (MS1096-Gal4) were performed using homozygous
w1118, P{w+mW.hs = GawB}BxMS1096 females
crossed to homozygous transgene-containing males. All Drosophila
crosses were kept on MM media (KD Medical, Inc.) at 25 °C unless specified
otherwise.Mutant Sequencing and Quantitative Reverse
Transcription-PCR—The genomic region flanking each transposon
insertion was amplified and sequenced according to the previously described
procedures (39). To examine
the effect of the transposon on pgant3 gene expression levels,
pgant3c01318/pgant3c01318 homozygotes,
wild type, and transposon excision lines were used to isolate RNA and perform
real-time PCR. Briefly, RNA was isolated using the FastRNA Pro Green kit
(Q-BIOgene). cDNA synthesis was performed using the iScript cDNA synthesis kit
(Bio-Rad). PCR primers were designed using Beacon Designer software (Bio-Rad).
Quantitative reverse transcription-PCR was performed on a MyiQ real time PCR
thermocycler (Bio-Rad) using the SYBR-Green PCR Master Mix (Bio-Rad).
Quantitative reverse transcription-PCR to determine expression levels of all
pgant family members was performed using the PCR primers listed in
supplemental Table 1 with cDNA prepared from wild type,
Tub>pgant3IR2#2, and Tub>pgant3IR2#9 larval wing
discs.Wing Disc Fixation and Staining—Imaginal wing discs were
stained according to standard procedures and analyzed by confocal microscopy.
Mouse monoclonal anti-Tn antibody (Ca3638)
(44) (dilution, 1:50) was the
kind gift of Dr. Richard Cummings who had acquired the stocks of antibodies
and hybridomas from the late Dr. Georg F. Springer. Immunopositive signals
were developed using Cy3-conjugated donkey anti-mouse IgM antibody (dilution,
1:100) (Jackson Immuno-Research Laboratories). Stained wing discs were
analyzed using the Zeiss LSM 510 confocal laser scanning microscope. Images
were processed using the LSM Imager Browser and Photoshop. Measurements of
wing disc thickness and O-glycan staining in x-z
cross sections were performed in the center of each disc. Values were
averaged, and S.D. were calculated. Statistical significance was determined
using a Student's t test.Glycosylation Assays in Vitro—Assays for glycosyltransferase
activity were performed as described previously
(25). Briefly, media from COS7
cells expressing recombinant pgant3 or pgant35A
(25) was harvested and used in
the in vitro reactions with [14C]UDP-GalNAc, and the
acceptor substrates denoted in Table
3. Reaction products were purified by anion exchange
chromatography, and [14C]GalNAc incorporation was measured.
Reactions using media from cells expressing empty vector alone yielded
background values that were subtracted from each experimental value. Adjusted
experimental values were then averaged, and S.D. were calculated. All assays
were performed in duplicate. Glycosyltransferase activity is expressed as
dpm/h.
TABLE 3
Peptide substrates derived from proteins expressed in wing discs The
bold residues are sites of potential O-glycosylation based on
predictions performed by the NetOGlyc server. NA, no evidence from
references.
Peptide
Gene
Protein
Peptide sequence
Wing blisters in mutants
if
if
αPS2 integrin
EPQVNQTSFTTYSTSSSSSG
yes
lanA1
LanA
Laminin A
TLPPTTPTTTTTTTTT
yes
mew
mew
αPS1 integrin
VGFFKRIRPTDPTLSGNLE
yes
scab
scb
αPS3 integrin
VDPVEVTTTLSGGLERTV
yes
tigA
tig
Tiggrin
LEGETARPRPPNPAPIVSTPKP
yes
tigB
tig
Tiggrin
QQATKVEVEATSEPSFWEKLK
yes
tenM1
ten-m
Tenascin-major
FLLEGVTPTAPPDVPPRNPT
NA
tenM2
ten-m
Tenascin-major
TSNSGTAQGLQSTSASAEATSS
NA
tsp
tsp
Thrombospondin
IQIKLVNSTEGPGPMMRNS
NA
Peptide substrates derived from proteins expressed in wing discs The
bold residues are sites of potential O-glycosylation based on
predictions performed by the NetOGlyc server. NA, no evidence from
references.Western Blotting—Protein extracts were prepared from 3rd
instar larval wing discs of wild type, pgant3c01318
homozygotes, and transposon excision lines
(pgant3c01318revertant#7 homozygotes) as described
(45). Samples were
electrophoresed under reducing conditions in a 4–12% SDS-PAGE gradient
gel. Gels were transferred to nitrocellulose; membranes were blocked with
1× blocking buffer (Sigma), incubated with Tn antibody (dilution, 1:500)
or the tiggrin antibody (the kind gift of Drs. L. and J. Fessler)
(9) (dilution, 1:500), and
developed with horse-radish peroxidase-conjugated secondary antibody
(dilution, 1:10,000).Immunoprecipitation—Equivalent amounts of protein extracts
were prepared from 3rd instar larval wing discs from wild type and
pgant3c01318 homozygotes. 50 μl of immobilized protein
L suspension (Thermo Scientific) was added to 500 μl of protein extract and
incubated at 4 °C for 1 h to preclear. The mixtures were centrifuged, and
the precleared supernatant was collected. 10 μl of the tiggrin antibody
were added to the precleared supernatant and incubated at 4 °C overnight.
The following day 50 μl of washed immobilized protein L suspension was
added, and incubation was performed at 4 °C overnight. Immunocomplexed
proteins were collected by pulse centrifugation. Pellets were washed three
times with lysis buffer. The final pellet was resuspended in sample loading
buffer, heated to 95 °C for 5 min, and analyzed by reducing SDS-PAGE
followed by immunoblotting with the Tn Ab as described.
RESULTS
Transposon Insertion Decreases pgant3 Gene Expression and Causes Wing
Blistering—pgant3 is one of 12 members of the
Drosophila gene family encoding the polypeptide GalNAc
glycosyltransferases that are responsible for initiating mucin-type O-linked
glycosylation of secreted and membrane-bound proteins
(25,
27). pgant3 gene
expression is highly regulated both spatially and temporally during
development (27). We set out
to examine the biological roles of O-glycosylation mediated by this
glycosyltransferase using three putative transposon insertions in the
pgant3 gene from the Exelixis Drosophila stock collection
(39). Genomic sequencing of
the insertion sites revealed that only one transposon resided within the
pgant3 gene (PBac{PB}pgant3c01318); the line
containing this transposon is hereafter designated
pgant3c01318. pgant3c01318 contains a
piggyBac transposable element in the fourth intron of
pgant3, separating exons that encode the conserved catalytic region
of the enzyme (Fig.
1). Quantitative PCR was performed on wild type and
homozygous transposon insertion mutants to assess the effect of the transposon
on the expression levels of pgant3 as well as the flanking
tetraspanin genes (Tsp42Ep andTsp42Eq)
(Fig. 1). As shown in
Fig. 1,
pgant3 gene expression 3′ to the transposon insertion site was
significantly reduced in the transposon insertion line relative to wild type.
Expression of the flanking tetraspanin genes was not affected. This
result demonstrates that the transposon insertion specifically affects
pgant3 gene expression, thus supporting the use of this line to
investigate pgant3 gene function.
FIGURE 1.
A,
position of the transposon in intron 4 of the pgant3 gene is shown.
Exons are represented as boxes, and introns are represented as
lines. Functional elements of the pgant3 coding region are
shown in color. Nucleotide sequence of the transposon insertion site in the
pgant3c01318 stock is shown. B, the genomic
region of pgant3 and flanking genes are shown. The positions of the
primer pairs used for real-time PCR are shown as triangles. C,
real-time PCR analysis of pgant3 transcript levels using the primer
pairs shown in B reveals a significant decrease in pgant3
gene expression in
pgant3c01318/pgant3c01318 transposon
insertion homozygotes relative to
pgant3c01318revertant#7/pgant3c01318revertant#7
transposon excision homozygotes or wild type flies. Transcription from the
flanking Tsp42Ep and Tsp42Eq genes was unaffected. RNA
levels were normalized to 18 S rRNA.
Heterozygous transposon insertion flies were crossed to assess the effect
of the transposon on viability. Although a reduction in viability was seen
relative to heterozygotes, most homozygous transposon insertion mutants did
survive to adulthood. However, a significant number of
pgant3c01318 homozygous adults displayed abnormal wings
(Fig. 2 and
Table 1). Specifically, wings
of pgant3c01318 homozygotes developed blisters as they
unfolded, which later collapsed into crumpled areas in the wing blade
(Fig. 2). Wing blistering was
not seen in wild type flies or flies heterozygous for the transposon insertion
(Table 1). The extent of
blistering varied, with some wings having small blisters and others showing
blistering across the entire wing blade
(Fig. 2, ).
FIGURE 2.
Wild type (A)
pgant3c01318/pgant3c01318 transposon
insertion homozygotes (B and C),
pgant3c01318revertant#7/pgant3c01318revertant#7
transposon excision homozygotes (D), and rescued homozygous mutants
expressing a wild type pgant3 transgene
(pgant3c01318/pgant3c01318;
UAS-pgant3) (E) are shown. Close up views of wings are shown
in the panels on the right.
(number of flies displaying blistered wings/total number of flies of
denoted genotype) × 100
n = total number of flies of denoted genotype scored
Frequency of flies displaying blistered wings(number of flies displaying blistered wings/total number of flies of
denoted genotype) × 100n = total number of flies of denoted genotype scoredThe pgant3c01318 line was crossed to a deficiency line
that uncovered the pgant3 gene (Df(2R)Exel 6283,
PXP-UExel6263) to verify that the blistering phenotype is the
result of the transposon in pgant3 and not due to mutations elsewhere
on the chromosome. Progeny containing the transposon insertion over the
deficiency displayed wing blistering (Table
1), lending further support for the role of pgant3 in the
wing blistering phenotype.To conclusively demonstrate that the transposon insertion in
pgant3 is responsible for the wing blistering phenotype, the
piggyBac transposon was precisely excised from the pgant3
gene using the piggyBac transposase as described previously
(39). Transposon excision
lines (pgant3c01318revertant#7/
pgant3c01318revertant#7) showed restoration of
pgant3 gene expression levels and wing integrity
(Fig. 1 and
Fig. 2, and
Table 1).A,
position of the transposon in intron 4 of the pgant3 gene is shown.
Exons are represented as boxes, and introns are represented as
lines. Functional elements of the pgant3 coding region are
shown in color. Nucleotide sequence of the transposon insertion site in the
pgant3c01318 stock is shown. B, the genomic
region of pgant3 and flanking genes are shown. The positions of the
primer pairs used for real-time PCR are shown as triangles. C,
real-time PCR analysis of pgant3 transcript levels using the primer
pairs shown in B reveals a significant decrease in pgant3
gene expression in
pgant3c01318/pgant3c01318 transposon
insertion homozygotes relative to
pgant3c01318revertant#7/pgant3c01318revertant#7
transposon excision homozygotes or wild type flies. Transcription from the
flanking Tsp42Ep and Tsp42Eq genes was unaffected. RNA
levels were normalized to 18 S rRNA.RNAi to pgant3 Causes Wing Blistering—To confirm that
decreased levels of pgant3 expression are responsible for the wing
blistering observed, we constructed transgenic flies carrying Gal4-inducible
pgant3 IR constructs (UAS-pgant3IR) to specifically induce
double-stranded RNA to pgant3 and, thus, decrease pgant3
expression via RNAi (Fig. 3).
After crossing two independent UAS-pgant3IR transgenic lines to a
tubulin-Gal4 driver line (which expresses Gal4 ubiquitously), we found that
95–97% of the progeny expressing pgant3 double-stranded RNA
displayed wing blistering (Table
1). Induction of pgant3 RNAi exclusively in the wing disc
by crossing UAS-pgant3IR lines to a wing-specific Gal4 driver line
(MS1096-Gal4) resulted in 19–23% wing blistering
(Table 1). Quantitative PCR
verified that pgant3 expression levels were specifically reduced in
double-stranded RNA-expressing progeny, whereas expression of other
pgant family members was unchanged
(Fig. 3, ). Additionally, the degree of reduction in
pgant3 gene expression with each Gal4-driver correlated with the
frequency of wing blistering observed. The tubulin-Gal4 driver resulted in a
greater reduction in pgant3 gene expression in wing discs relative to
the MS1096-Gal4 driver and also gave a greater incidence of wing blistering
(Table 1 and
Fig. 3, ).
FIGURE 3.
RNAi to . A, the segment of the pgant3 coding region
used to construct the UAS-pgant3IR vector (below) is shown as a
diagonally striped box. Functional elements of the pgant3
coding region are shown in color. Quantitative PCR was employed to assess
pgant family member gene expression in wing discs from wild type and
two independent UAS-pgant3IR transgenic lines
(UAS-pgant3IR2#2 and UAS-pgant3IR2#9) under the control of
the tubulin-Gal4 driver (B) or the wing-specific MS1096-Gal4 driver
(C). In both instances induction of pgant3 double-stranded
RNA resulted in a specific reduction in pgant3 expression without
significantly affecting the expression of other family members.
Wild Type pgant3 Expression Restores Wing Integrity but Expression of
Another pgant Family Member Does Not—To demonstrate that
pgant3 expression is crucial for wing integrity, we constructed
Gal4-inducible transgenic lines carrying wild type pgant3 cDNA
(UAS-pgant3) to perform rescue experiments. The presence of the
UAS-pgant3 expression construct in the homozygous
pgant3c01318 transposon background resulted in significant
reduction or elimination of wing blistering
(Table 1 and
Fig. 2) even in the
absence of a Gal4 driver. This was seen with multiple independent transgenic
lines (Table 1). However,
transgenic lines overexpressing another pgant family member under the
control of the tubulin-Gal4 driver (pgant35A)
(27,
36) failed to completely
rescue wing blistering in the homozygous pgant3c01318
transposon background (Table
1). These results indicate that the restoration of wing integrity
is specific to pgant3 gene expression and cannot be achieved by
overexpression of another family member. This suggests that PGANT3 is uniquely
responsible for glycosylating a subset of proteins required for proper wing
blade formation.Overexpression of pgant3 Results in Lethality—While
performing the aforementioned rescue studies, we noticed that progeny
containing both UAS-pgant3 and certain Gal4 drivers were not viable.
This was seen with multiple independent UAS-pgant3 transgenic lines
(Table 2 and data not shown).
Overexpression of wild type pgant3 using the tubulin-Gal4 driver was
lethal, with most animals dying during embryogenesis and larva stages
(Table 2 and data not shown).
UAS-pgant3 expression under the control of the armadillo
driver (arm-Gal4, whose expression level is less than that of
Tub-Gal4) resulted in partial lethality, with 50% of the animals surviving to
adulthood. Expression of pgant3 under the control of a wing-specific
driver had no effect on viability or wing blade formation
(Table 2 and data not shown).
These results indicate that although overexpression of pgant3 is
tolerated in the wing, specific regulation of pgant3 levels in other
tissues and stages is necessary for development to proceed properly. This may
be the reason for the highly restricted pattern of expression seen for
pgant3 during embryonic development
(27).Wild type (A)
pgant3c01318/pgant3c01318 transposon
insertion homozygotes (B and C),
pgant3c01318revertant#7/pgant3c01318revertant#7
transposon excision homozygotes (D), and rescued homozygous mutants
expressing a wild type pgant3 transgene
(pgant3c01318/pgant3c01318;
UAS-pgant3) (E) are shown. Close up views of wings are shown
in the panels on the right.Altered O-Glycan Staining and Wing Disc Morphology is Seen in
pgant3—Wing
discs from pgant3c01318 homozygotes were stained with an
antibody (Tn Ab) that detects the Tn antigen, GalNAcα-S/T
(44), to visualize alterations
in protein O-glycosylation patterns in the mutant discs. Wing discs
from pgant3c01318 homozygotes did not show global changes
in O-glycosylation relative to wild type discs
(Fig. 4, ). However, examination of optical cross-sections
through the mutant wing discs revealed a decrease in O-glycoproteins
specifically along the basal surface of the columnar epithelial cells
(Fig. 4, ). The average height of O-glycan staining
along the basal surface of pgant3c01318 homozygous mutant
wing discs was 3-μm versus 7-μm for wild type discs
(Fig. 4); no
significant decrease in O-glycans along the apical surface was
observed. Additionally, mutant discs were decreased in thickness relative to
wild type (Fig. 4),
with mutants having an average thickness of 30 μm, whereas wild type had an
average of 44 μm. Furthermore, basal O-glycan staining and disc
thickness were restored in mutant discs expressing wild type pgant3
(Fig. 4, ),
concomitant with restoration of adult wing blade integrity
(Fig. 2). These
results demonstrate that decreased pgant3 gene expression results in
localized reductions in O-glycans along the basal region of wing
discs followed by separation of epithelial cell layers in the adult wing, both
of which can be rescued with wild type pgant3 expression. Because the
basal surface of larval wing discs will mediate contacts between epithelial
cell layers in the adult wing, this implicates basal O-glycoproteins
modified by PGANT3 in these cell adhesion events. Additionally, these studies
provide evidence that reduced O-glycosylation results in altered
columnar epithelial cell morphology, as mutant discs were significantly
thinner than wild type discs.
FIGURE 4.
Wing imaginal discs from wild
type (A and D),
pgant3c01318/pgant3c01318 transposon
insertion homozygotes (Mutant) (B and E), and
transposon homozygotes expressing wild type pgant3
(pgant3c01318/pgant3c01318;
UAS-pgant3) (Rescued) (C and F) were
stained with the Tn antibody and visualized by confocal microscopy.
D–F represent optical X-Z cross-sections of each disc in the
region of the white line shown in A–C. Anterior is to
the left, and posterior is to the right in
A–C. Apical is at the top, and basal is at the
bottom in D–F. G, average amount of O-glycan
staining seen in wild type, mutant, and rescued discs along the basal surface
of the wing pouch (measured as described under “Experimental
Procedures”). H, average thickness of the wing pouch in wild
type, mutant, and rescued discs. n = total number of wing discs of
each genotype analyzed. S.D. are shown. Scale bar = 20 μm.
**, p < 0.01.
PGANT3 Glycosylates ECM Proteins in Vitro—To identify
potential substrates for PGANT3, we compiled a list of secreted and
membrane-bound proteins expressed in wing discs that are predicted to have
potential sites of O-glycosylation
(Table 3) using the NetOGlyc
server. This software employs a neural network prediction program based on
confirmed sites of O-glycosylation in many diverse proteins. We then
performed in vitro glycosylation reactions using recombinant PGANT3
and peptides derived from these proteins to determine which substrates PGANT3
is capable of glycosylating. As shown in
Fig. 5, PGANT3
transfers a substantial amount of GalNAc to tenM1, a specific peptide derived
from the tenascin-major protein, and tigA, a peptide derived from the tiggrin
protein. No glycosylation was seen for tenM2 or tigB, additional peptides
derived from tenascin-major and tiggrin, respectively, suggesting that PGANT3
activity is specific to certain subregions within these proteins. A modest
amount of glycosylation was also seen with thrombospondin. No significant
transfer was seen to the other peptides tested in this assay, indicating that
PGANT3 glycosylates specific regions of certain extracellular matrix proteins
in vitro. To demonstrate specificity of the PGANT3 peptide
glycosylation observed, similar assays were performed using recombinant
PGANT35A. Although PGANT35A was able to transfer GalNAc to tenM1, no
glycosylation above background was seen for the other substrates tested
(Fig. 5). This in
vitro specificity is in accord with the pgant3-specific in
vivo rescue of wing blistering, supporting a unique role for PGANT3 in
the wing disc that cannot be compensated for by the activity of another
glycosyltransferase family member. The in vitro data presented here
suggests that tiggrin is one of the unique candidate targets for PGANT3.
FIGURE 5.
Glycosylation of ECM peptides by PGANT3. Peptides derived from
secreted and membrane-bound proteins expressed in wing discs were incubated
with recombinant PGANT3 (A) or PGANT35A (B) enzymes in
in vitro glycosylation reactions, and transfer of labeled GalNAc was
measured. Both PGANT3 and PGANT35A glycosylate the tenM1 peptide, but
glycosylation of the tigA peptide was only observed with PGANT3. Rates of
GalNAc incorporation (dpm/h) are shown on the vertical axes, and
peptide substrates tested are shown on the horizontal axes. Error
bars indicate S.D. Background values (no pep = no peptide
acceptor present in the reaction) are shown in each graph.
RNAi to . A, the segment of the pgant3 coding region
used to construct the UAS-pgant3IR vector (below) is shown as a
diagonally striped box. Functional elements of the pgant3
coding region are shown in color. Quantitative PCR was employed to assess
pgant family member gene expression in wing discs from wild type and
two independent UAS-pgant3IR transgenic lines
(UAS-pgant3IR2#2 and UAS-pgant3IR2#9) under the control of
the tubulin-Gal4 driver (B) or the wing-specific MS1096-Gal4 driver
(C). In both instances induction of pgant3 double-stranded
RNA resulted in a specific reduction in pgant3 expression without
significantly affecting the expression of other family members.Wing imaginal discs from wild
type (A and D),
pgant3c01318/pgant3c01318 transposon
insertion homozygotes (Mutant) (B and E), and
transposon homozygotes expressing wild type pgant3
(pgant3c01318/pgant3c01318;
UAS-pgant3) (Rescued) (C and F) were
stained with the Tn antibody and visualized by confocal microscopy.
D–F represent optical X-Z cross-sections of each disc in the
region of the white line shown in A–C. Anterior is to
the left, and posterior is to the right in
A–C. Apical is at the top, and basal is at the
bottom in D–F. G, average amount of O-glycan
staining seen in wild type, mutant, and rescued discs along the basal surface
of the wing pouch (measured as described under “Experimental
Procedures”). H, average thickness of the wing pouch in wild
type, mutant, and rescued discs. n = total number of wing discs of
each genotype analyzed. S.D. are shown. Scale bar = 20 μm.
**, p < 0.01.Loss of Specific O-Glycoproteins Is Seen in pgant3—Protein extracts from wing discs of wild type,
pgant3c01318 homozygotes, and transposon excision lines
were run on SDS-PAGE gels, Western-blotted, and probed with the Tn Ab to
detect changes in the presence of O-glycosylated proteins. No
differences were seen between the majority of bands present in wild type and
mutant lanes. However, glycoproteins of ∼68 and ∼200 kDa that were
present in wild type and transposon excision samples were absent or severely
reduced in staining intensity in pgant3c01318 mutant
samples; additionally, there was a slight reduction in intensity within the
high molecular weight region at the top of the gel in the
pgant3c01318 mutant sample
(Fig. 6). Western
blots further demonstrated that glycosylation of the ∼200-kDa band is
restored in rescued pgant3c01318 mutant wing discs
(expressing wild type pgant3)
(Fig. 6).
FIGURE 6.
Altered patterns of A,
protein extracts from the wing imaginal discs of wild type (W.T.),
pgant3c01318/pgant3c01318 transposon
insertion homozygotes (Mutant), and
pgant3c01318revertant#7/pgant3c01318revertant#7
transposon excision homozygotes (Excision) were subject to SDS-PAGE
electrophoresis, blotted, and probed with the Tn antigen antibody (Tn
Ab) to detect O-linked glycoproteins carrying the Tn antigen
structure (Gal-NAcα-S/T). Loss or severe reduction in ∼68- and
∼200-kDa bands in the mutant sample relative to the wild type or
transposon excision sample is seen. WB, Western blot. B,
Western blot of protein extracts from wild type and transposon homozygotes
expressing wild type pgant3
(pgant3c01318/pgant3c01318;
UAS-pgant3) (Rescued) wing discs probed with the Tn Ab.
C, Western blot from panel A was probed with the tiggrin
antibody. The position of the ∼200-kDa band is denoted on the right
side of each blot. Size markers (lane M) are shown to the
left of each panel.
Glycosylation of ECM peptides by PGANT3. Peptides derived from
secreted and membrane-bound proteins expressed in wing discs were incubated
with recombinant PGANT3 (A) or PGANT35A (B) enzymes in
in vitro glycosylation reactions, and transfer of labeled GalNAc was
measured. Both PGANT3 and PGANT35A glycosylate the tenM1 peptide, but
glycosylation of the tigA peptide was only observed with PGANT3. Rates of
GalNAc incorporation (dpm/h) are shown on the vertical axes, and
peptide substrates tested are shown on the horizontal axes. Error
bars indicate S.D. Background values (no pep = no peptide
acceptor present in the reaction) are shown in each graph.Altered patterns of A,
protein extracts from the wing imaginal discs of wild type (W.T.),
pgant3c01318/pgant3c01318 transposon
insertion homozygotes (Mutant), and
pgant3c01318revertant#7/pgant3c01318revertant#7
transposon excision homozygotes (Excision) were subject to SDS-PAGE
electrophoresis, blotted, and probed with the Tn antigen antibody (Tn
Ab) to detect O-linked glycoproteins carrying the Tn antigen
structure (Gal-NAcα-S/T). Loss or severe reduction in ∼68- and
∼200-kDa bands in the mutant sample relative to the wild type or
transposon excision sample is seen. WB, Western blot. B,
Western blot of protein extracts from wild type and transposon homozygotes
expressing wild type pgant3
(pgant3c01318/pgant3c01318;
UAS-pgant3) (Rescued) wing discs probed with the Tn Ab.
C, Western blot from panel A was probed with the tiggrin
antibody. The position of the ∼200-kDa band is denoted on the right
side of each blot. Size markers (lane M) are shown to the
left of each panel.Based on our in vitro data and the size of the predominant band
absent in the mutant discs (∼200 kDa), we hypothesized that this band may
be the tiggrin protein. Western blots probed with the tiggrin antibody
revealed that the lower tiggrin band runs in the exact position of the
∼200 kDa band detected with the Tn Ab
(Fig. 6), strongly
suggesting that the differentially glycosylated band is tiggrin. Collectively,
these results support the notion that pgant3 is responsible for
glycosylating specific proteins within the wing discs, one of which may be the
ECM protein tiggrin.Tiggrin Is an in Vivo Substrate for PGANT3—To conclusively
address whether tiggrin represents the ∼200-kDa O-glycosylated
band that is lost in pgant3c01318 mutants, we performed
immunoprecipitation experiments from wild type wing disc extracts using the
tiggrin antibody (Fig. 7).
Western blots of immunoprecipitated tiggrin blotted with the Tn Ab revealed
that tiggrin is O-glycosylated in wild type wing discs and runs at
the same position as the predominant ∼200-kDa band seen on previous
Western blots (Fig.
7). Nonspecific bands detected by the secondary antibody
are shown in Fig. 7.
No Tn Ab reactivity was seen in the immunoprecipitated sample from mutant wing
discs (Fig. 7),
suggesting that tiggrin is either not O-glycosylated or is
unstable/degraded. Although the data from
Fig. 6 indicate that tiggrin
from mutant discs is present but not glycosylated, we cannot rule out the
possibility that the lack of O-glycans may also result in altered
protein stability. Nonetheless, these results conclusively demonstrate that
tiggrin is a bona fide substrate for PGANT3 in vivo.
FIGURE 7.
Tiggrin is .
Immunoprecipitation (IP) of tiggrin from wild type and
pgant3c01318/pgant3c01318 mutants was
performed as described under “Experimental Procedures.”
A, the nonspecific wash (Wash) and immunoprecipitated
tiggrin (Beads) from each sample were subject to SDS-PAGE
electrophoresis, blotted, and probed with the Tn Ab. Tiggrin from wild type
discs is detected with the O-glycan specific antibody, but tiggrin
from mutant discs shows no reactivity. Wild type wing disc lysate (W.T.
Lysate) was included as a control for detection of
O-glycosylated tiggrin. B, Western blots (WB) were
reprobed with the secondary antibody alone to identify the nonspecific band
present in each sample (denoted with a white triangle to the
right of each blot). The position of the specific tiggrin band is
denoted with a black arrow.
Genetic Interactions between pgant3 and tiggrin Increase Wing
Blistering—To demonstrate an in vivo interaction between
tiggrin and pgant3 in mediating the wing blistering
phenotype, we performed genetic interaction experiments. Two distinct
tiggrin mutants (TigX and
TigA1)
(14) showed no blistering
heterozygously at 18 °C (Table
1); pgant3c01318 heterozygotes displayed 2%
wing blistering at 18 °C (Table
1). However, transheterozygotes consisting of
pgant3c01318 and Tig or
pgant3c01318 and TigA1 both resulted
in an increased wing blistering frequency
(Table 1). These genetic
interactions were only seen at 18 °C. We did not observe genetic
interactions between pgant3 and other genes known to be involved in
various aspects of wing blade adhesion (if, by, bsk, wb, mys, mew, Ten-m,
bs) (data not shown). Thus, pgant3 and tiggrin
mutations, when combined, function to exacerbate the same morphological
phenotype, further demonstrating that the glycosylation of tiggrin by PGANT3
has a functional consequence in modulating cell adhesive events in the adult
wing.
DISCUSSION
Cell adhesion and the factors that regulate it are crucial during many
diverse developmental stages. Here we describe for the first time the role of
mucin-type protein O-glycosylation in cell adhesion during
development. Mutations in the pgant3 gene, which encodes an enzyme
responsible for initiating protein O-glycosylation, resulted in
aberrant adhesion between the cell layers comprising the wing blade.
Epithelial cell adhesion in the Drosophila wing blade is regulated
primarily by integrin-ECM interactions
(2–5,
8,
14–15).
However, a role for O-glycosylation of these proteins in modulating
their cell adhesive functions during development has not been previously
described. Our data elucidate a novel role for O-glycosylation in
cell adhesion during wing development.Tiggrin is .
Immunoprecipitation (IP) of tiggrin from wild type and
pgant3c01318/pgant3c01318 mutants was
performed as described under “Experimental Procedures.”
A, the nonspecific wash (Wash) and immunoprecipitated
tiggrin (Beads) from each sample were subject to SDS-PAGE
electrophoresis, blotted, and probed with the Tn Ab. Tiggrin from wild type
discs is detected with the O-glycan specific antibody, but tiggrin
from mutant discs shows no reactivity. Wild type wing disc lysate (W.T.
Lysate) was included as a control for detection of
O-glycosylated tiggrin. B, Western blots (WB) were
reprobed with the secondary antibody alone to identify the nonspecific band
present in each sample (denoted with a white triangle to the
right of each blot). The position of the specific tiggrin band is
denoted with a black arrow.Here we show that a known integrin binding ECM protein, tiggrin, is
specifically glycosylated by PGANT3 and that the activity of PGANT3 is
functionally significant in mediating phenotypic consequences in the
developing wing. PGANT3 glycosylates tiggrin both in vitro and in
vivo; mutations in pgant3 result in a loss of tiggrin
glycosylation (accompanied by wing blistering), whereas expression of wild
type pgant3 restores tiggrin glycosylation and wing integrity.
Additionally, genetic interaction experiments reveal that the combination of
pgant3 and tiggrin mutations resulted in an increased
blistering frequency, demonstrating that these genes are acting in the same
phenotypic pathway. Prior studies have shown that tiggrin binds integrin
(9) and is involved in
integrin-mediated cell adhesive events during Drosophila development,
including muscle-tendon cell adhesion and wing blade adhesion
(14). Indeed, the wing
blistering seen in tiggrin mutants (along the posterior portion of
the wing blade) (14) is
similar to what was often observed in pgant3 mutants. Given this, we
propose that O-glycans on tiggrin mediate some aspect of integrin-ECM
adhesion in the wing blade. Our Western blots demonstrate that the tiggrin
protein is present in pgant3 mutants, suggesting that the loss of
O-glycans does not result in significant tiggrin degradation.
However, O-glycans on tiggrin may influence more subtle aspects of
protein stability as well as transport, secretion, localization, or binding
interactions. Indeed, prior work from our laboratory suggests that
O-glycosylation by another member of this glycosyltransferase family
is involved in protein transport during Drosophila development
(36). We are currently
investigating the specific mechanistic function of O-glycans on
tiggrin.To address the developmental origin of the wing defect in pgant3
mutants, we examined developing wing imaginal discs. Previous studies have
shown that defects in JNK signaling related to integrin function in the
developing wing can result in wing blistering
(11). However, we did not
detect changes in JNK phosphorylation or downstream signaling in
pgant3 mutants (data not shown). Detailed morphological examination
of mutant wing discs revealed that although global patterns of glycosylation
were unchanged, pgant3 mutants displayed a specific reduction in
O-glycans along the basal surface of the columnar epithelial cells.
Additionally, basal surface glycosylation was restored in mutants expressing
wild type pgant3, as was wing integrity and tiggrin glycosylation.
These regional alterations in glycosylation are significant, as integrins and
ECM proteins present along the basal surface mediate the adhesive contacts
that will form as the disc everts and opposing basal regions come in contact
with one another (2). Thus, we
hypothesize that the wing blisters that form in the adult are most likely the
result of an initial reduction in O-glycosylation of proteins
normally found along the basal surface of larval wing discs.Reduced basal glycosylation in larval wing discs was also accompanied by a
reduction in the height of the columnar cells comprising the wing disc. Again,
expression of wild type pgant3 restored glycosylation and columnar
cell height. It has been shown previously that alterations in integrin-ECM
interactions can affect cell size and shape in the wing disc
(46). We hypothesize that the
morphological changes seen in the pgant3 mutants are the result of
alterations in integrin-ECM interactions influencing cytoskeletal architecture
and cell shape.Although tiggrin appears to be the major O-glycosylated protein
affected in pgant3 mutants, our in vitro and Western blot
data suggest that PGANT3 may glycosylate other proteins in addition to
tiggrin. In vitro biochemical assays revealed that other wing disc
ECM proteins, such as tenascin-major (∼300 kDa) and thrombospondin
(∼120 kDa), are glycosylated by PGANT3. No significant glycosylation was
seen for the integrin peptides tested. Tenascin-major was also glycosylated by
another PGANT family member (PGANT35A), suggesting that its glycosylation is
not PGANT3-specific. Western blots further revealed an additional glycosylated
band (∼68 kDa) that is decreased in pgant3 mutants. These results
suggest that PGANT3 may glycosylate a subset of basal ECM proteins (including
tiggrin) in the developing wing disc. The aforementioned ECM proteins are also
known to specifically interact with αPS2 integrin to mediate cell
adhesion in a number of developmental contexts
(9,
10,
13,
14). We postulate that
glycosylation of ECM proteins in addition to tiggrin could also play a role in
the wing blade adhesion. We are currently trying to identify the ∼68-kDa
band.Our studies indicate that pgant3 is uniquely responsible for
glycosylating certain proteins such as tiggrin, which are required for proper
wing development and that the activity of another family member is not
compensatory. This unique requirement for pgant3 in the developing
wing disc is demonstrated by in vivo rescue experiments where wild
type pgant3 can restore wing integrity, but overexpression of another
related family member (pgant35A, which is normally expressed in the
wing disc and is also an initiating peptide transferase) cannot. This result
is likely due to isoform-specific substrate preferences that were also
observed in vitro. These data highlight the significance of substrate
preferences seen for PGANT family members in vitro and illustrate the
functional consequences of this specificity in vivo.The notion of unique roles for pgant3 during development is
further supported by the observation that overexpression of pgant3 is
lethal, whereas pgant35A overexpression has no obvious effect.
Although we currently do not know the specific nature of this lethality (most
pgant3 overexpressing animals died during embryonic and larval
stages), these results suggest that control of PGANT3 enzymatic levels during
development is critical. Indeed, we know from previous in situ
experiments that pgant3 gene expression is specifically regulated
during embryonic development, being found in a very restricted subset of
tissues, including the wing disc
(27). The unique substrate
preferences of PGANT3 may necessitate very strict spatial and temporal
regulation of enzymatic activity during development. The role of
pgant3 in other tissues and stages is currently under
investigation.In summary, we have identified a novel role for mucin-type
O-glycosylation during development. Here, we present evidence for the
requirement of O-glycans in cell adhesion processes during
development. Previous work has demonstrated the role of O- and
N-linked carbohydrates and sugar-binding proteins in cell adhesion
mediating lymphocyte homing and extravasation within the mammalian immune
system (34,
47–49).
The presence of mucin type O-glycans on secreted and membrane-bound
proteins across many species suggests a more widespread role for
O-glycans in cell adhesive events in many developing organ systems.
Building upon the studies presented here, it will be interesting to
investigate the role of O-glycans in other developmental
contexts.
Authors: D J Moloney; V M Panin; S H Johnston; J Chen; L Shao; R Wilson; Y Wang; P Stanley; K D Irvine; R S Haltiwanger; T F Vogt Journal: Nature Date: 2000-07-27 Impact factor: 49.962
Authors: K G Ten Hagen; G S Bedi; D Tetaert; P D Kingsley; F K Hagen; M M Balys; T M Beres; P Degand; L A Tabak Journal: J Biol Chem Date: 2001-02-06 Impact factor: 5.157
Authors: Mari Tenno; Kazuaki Ohtsubo; Fred K Hagen; David Ditto; Alexander Zarbock; Patrick Schaerli; Ulrich H von Andrian; Klaus Ley; Dzung Le; Lawrence A Tabak; Jamey D Marth Journal: Mol Cell Biol Date: 2007-10-08 Impact factor: 4.272
Authors: Nicholas H Brown; Stephen L Gregory; Wayne L Rickoll; Liselotte I Fessler; Mary Prout; Robert A H White; James W Fristrom Journal: Dev Cell Date: 2002-10 Impact factor: 12.270
Authors: Carolyn May; Suena Ji; Zulfeqhar A Syed; Leslie Revoredo; Earnest James Paul Daniel; Thomas A Gerken; Lawrence A Tabak; Nadine L Samara; Kelly G Ten Hagen Journal: J Biol Chem Date: 2020-07-15 Impact factor: 5.157
Authors: Thomas A Gerken; Oliver Jamison; Cynthia L Perrine; Jeremy C Collette; Helen Moinova; Lakshmeswari Ravi; Sanford D Markowitz; Wei Shen; Himatkumar Patel; Lawrence A Tabak Journal: J Biol Chem Date: 2011-02-24 Impact factor: 5.157