Literature DB >> 18833344

Anthropology and Epidemiology: learning epistemological lessons through a collaborative venture.

Dominique Pareja Béhague1, Helen Gonçalves, Cesar Gomes Victora.   

Abstract

Collaboration between anthropology and epidemiology has a long and tumultuous history. Based on empirical examples, this paper describes a number of epistemological lessons we have learned through our experience of cross disciplinary collaboration. Although critical of both mainstream epidemiology and medical anthropology, our analysis focuses on the implications of addressing each discipline's main epistemological differences, while addressing the goal of adopting a broader social approach to health improvement. We believe it is important to push the boundaries of research collaborations from the more standard forms of "multidisciplinarity," to the adoption of theoretically imbued "interdisciplinarity." The more we challenge epistemological limitations and modify ways of knowing, the more we will be able to provide in-depth explanations for the emergence of disease-patterns and thus, to problem-solve. In our experience, both institutional support and the adoption of a relativistic attitude are necessary conditions for sustained theoretical interdisciplinarity. Until researchers acknowledge that methodology is merely a human-designed tool to interpret reality, unnecessary methodological hyper-specialization will continue to alienate one field of knowledge from the other.

Entities:  

Mesh:

Year:  2008        PMID: 18833344      PMCID: PMC2647662          DOI: 10.1590/s1413-81232008000600002

Source DB:  PubMed          Journal:  Cien Saude Colet        ISSN: 1413-8123


  27 in total

1.  [Work, schooling, and reproductive health: an ethno-epidemiological study of adolescent women belonging to a birth cohort].

Authors:  Helen Gonçalves; Denise Gigante
Journal:  Cad Saude Publica       Date:  2006-06-14       Impact factor: 1.632

2.  Who needs 'pukka anthropologists'? A study of the perceptions of the use of anthropology in tropical public health research.

Authors:  Dora A Napolitano; Caroline O H Jones
Journal:  Trop Med Int Health       Date:  2006-08       Impact factor: 2.622

3.  Pacifier use and short breastfeeding duration: cause, consequence, or coincidence?

Authors:  C G Victora; D P Behague; F C Barros; M T Olinto; E Weiderpass
Journal:  Pediatrics       Date:  1997-03       Impact factor: 7.124

4.  Methodological aspects of the 1993 Pelotas (Brazil) Birth Cohort Study.

Authors:  Cesar Gomes Victora; Cora Luiza Pavin Araújo; Ana Maria Batista Menezes; Pedro Curi Hallal; Maria de Fátima Vieira; Marilda Borges Neutzling; Helen Gonçalves; Neiva Cristina Valle; Rosangela Costa Lima; Luciana Anselmi; Dominique Behague; Denise Petrucci Gigante; Fernando Celso Barros
Journal:  Rev Saude Publica       Date:  2006-01-04       Impact factor: 2.106

5.  Research steps in the development and evaluation of public health interventions.

Authors:  I de Zoysa; J P Habicht; G Pelto; J Martines
Journal:  Bull World Health Organ       Date:  1998       Impact factor: 9.408

6.  Recasting the "ethno" in "epidemiology".

Authors:  M Agar
Journal:  Med Anthropol       Date:  1996-03

7.  The role of conceptual frameworks in epidemiological analysis: a hierarchical approach.

Authors:  C G Victora; S R Huttly; S C Fuchs; M T Olinto
Journal:  Int J Epidemiol       Date:  1997-02       Impact factor: 7.196

8.  Overcoming ethnocentrism: how social science and medicine relate and should relate to one another.

Authors:  S van der Geest
Journal:  Soc Sci Med       Date:  1995-04       Impact factor: 4.634

9.  Qualitative and quantitative methods: in-depth or rapid assessment?

Authors:  F J Bennett
Journal:  Soc Sci Med       Date:  1995-06       Impact factor: 4.634

10.  [Sociocultural factors and physical activity level in early adolescence].

Authors:  Helen Gonçalves; Pedro C Hallal; Tales C Amorim; Cora L P Araújo; Ana M B Menezes
Journal:  Rev Panam Salud Publica       Date:  2007-10
View more
  12 in total

1.  Beyond interviews and focus groups: a framework for integrating innovative qualitative methods into randomised controlled trials of complex public health interventions.

Authors:  Katy Davis; Nicole Minckas; Virginia Bond; Cari Jo Clark; Tim Colbourn; Sarah J Drabble; Therese Hesketh; Zelee Hill; Joanna Morrison; Oliver Mweemba; David Osrin; Audrey Prost; Janet Seeley; Maryam Shahmanesh; Esther J Spindler; Erin Stern; Katrina M Turner; Jenevieve Mannell
Journal:  Trials       Date:  2019-06-06       Impact factor: 2.279

2.  Risk of psychological distress following severe obstetric complications in Benin: the role of economics, physical health and spousal abuse.

Authors:  Edward Fottrell; Lydie Kanhonou; Sourou Goufodji; Dominique P Béhague; Tom Marshall; Vikram Patel; Véronique Filippi
Journal:  Br J Psychiatry       Date:  2010-01       Impact factor: 9.319

3.  Critically engaging: integrating the social and the biomedical in international microbicides research.

Authors:  Catherine M Montgomery; Robert Pool
Journal:  J Int AIDS Soc       Date:  2011-09-27       Impact factor: 5.396

4.  Taming troubled teens: the social production of mental morbidity amongst young mothers in Pelotas, Brazil.

Authors:  D P Béhague; H D Gonçalves; D Gigante; B R Kirkwood
Journal:  Soc Sci Med       Date:  2011-11-27       Impact factor: 4.634

Review 5.  At the crossroads of anthropology and epidemiology: current research in cultural psychiatry in the UK.

Authors:  Simon Dein; Kamaldeep Singh Bhui
Journal:  Transcult Psychiatry       Date:  2013-10-10

6.  Taking pills for developmental ails in Southern Brazil: The biologization of adolescence?

Authors:  Dominique P Béhague
Journal:  Soc Sci Med       Date:  2014-11-13       Impact factor: 4.634

Review 7.  Physical activity and the environment: conceptual review and framework for intervention research.

Authors:  Jenna Panter; Cornelia Guell; Rick Prins; David Ogilvie
Journal:  Int J Behav Nutr Phys Act       Date:  2017-11-15       Impact factor: 8.915

8.  Value and Limitations of Broad Brush Surveys Used in Community-Randomized Trials in Southern Africa.

Authors:  Virginia Bond; Fredrick Ngwenya; Emma Murray; Nothando Ngwenya; Lario Viljoen; Dumile Gumede; Chiti Bwalya; Jabulile Mantantana; Graeme Hoddinott; Peter J Dodd; Helen Ayles; Musonda Simwinga; Sandra Wallman; Janet Seeley
Journal:  Qual Health Res       Date:  2018-12-17

9.  Ethnographic methods for process evaluations of complex health behaviour interventions.

Authors:  Sarah Morgan-Trimmer; Fiona Wood
Journal:  Trials       Date:  2016-05-04       Impact factor: 2.279

10.  Digging deeper in Shanghai: towards a 'mechanism-rich' epidemiology.

Authors:  Jie Li; Nick Manning; Andrea Mechelli
Journal:  Int Health       Date:  2019-10-31       Impact factor: 2.473

View more

北京卡尤迪生物科技股份有限公司 © 2022-2023.