OBJECTIVES: There is a growing call for greater consumer participation in health care encounters. Prior research suggests that older age is associated with a greater preference for a more passive role in clinical decision-making, yet little is known about preferences for persons with mental illness. This pilot study compared preferences for involvement in decision-making between older and younger adults with serious mental illness. DESIGN: Cross-sectional observational survey. PARTICIPANTS: The authors surveyed 33 older adults (>or=50 years) and 32 younger adults (<50 years) with serious mental illness from two mental health center clinics and one residential facility for their preferences on decision-making with their psychiatrists and primary care providers. MEASUREMENTS: Measures included the Control Preferences Scale, the Autonomy Preference Index, and the Decision Self-Efficacy Scale. RESULTS: Contrary to our primary hypothesis, older adults reported a stronger desire for involvement in decision-making compared with younger adults. However, both age groups were similar in their desire for information to aid in decision-making. The majority in both age groups also preferred a collaborative role with a psychiatrist for medication decisions, an autonomous role for decisions related to psychosocial interventions, and a passive role with their primary care provider. Older and younger adults expressed similar decision self-efficacy. CONCLUSION: Our study suggests that older persons with serious mental illness have a stronger desire for involvement in decision-making than younger consumers. Additionally, role preference for involvement in decision-making varies across different clinical decisions and for psychopharmacological versus psychosocial interventions.
OBJECTIVES: There is a growing call for greater consumer participation in health care encounters. Prior research suggests that older age is associated with a greater preference for a more passive role in clinical decision-making, yet little is known about preferences for persons with mental illness. This pilot study compared preferences for involvement in decision-making between older and younger adults with serious mental illness. DESIGN: Cross-sectional observational survey. PARTICIPANTS: The authors surveyed 33 older adults (>or=50 years) and 32 younger adults (<50 years) with serious mental illness from two mental health center clinics and one residential facility for their preferences on decision-making with their psychiatrists and primary care providers. MEASUREMENTS: Measures included the Control Preferences Scale, the Autonomy Preference Index, and the Decision Self-Efficacy Scale. RESULTS: Contrary to our primary hypothesis, older adults reported a stronger desire for involvement in decision-making compared with younger adults. However, both age groups were similar in their desire for information to aid in decision-making. The majority in both age groups also preferred a collaborative role with a psychiatrist for medication decisions, an autonomous role for decisions related to psychosocial interventions, and a passive role with their primary care provider. Older and younger adults expressed similar decision self-efficacy. CONCLUSION: Our study suggests that older persons with serious mental illness have a stronger desire for involvement in decision-making than younger consumers. Additionally, role preference for involvement in decision-making varies across different clinical decisions and for psychopharmacological versus psychosocial interventions.
Authors: Susan A Pickett; Sita M Diehl; Pamela J Steigman; Joy D Prater; Anthony Fox; Patricia Shipley; Dennis D Grey; Judith A Cook Journal: Community Ment Health J Date: 2012-03-30
Authors: Kelsey A Bonfils; Sadaaki Fukui; Erin L Adams; Heidi M Hedrick; Michelle P Salyers Journal: Psychiatry Res Date: 2014-07-31 Impact factor: 3.222
Authors: Kelsey A Bonfils; Erin L Adams; Kim T Mueser; Jennifer L Wright-Berryman; Michelle P Salyers Journal: Psychiatry Res Date: 2015-06-15 Impact factor: 3.222
Authors: Stephen J Bartels; Sarah I Pratt; Kim T Mueser; John A Naslund; Rosemarie S Wolfe; Meghan Santos; Haiyi Xie; Erik G Riera Journal: Psychiatr Serv Date: 2014-03-01 Impact factor: 3.084
Authors: Patrick J Raue; Herbert C Schulberg; Roberto Lewis-Fernandez; Carla Boutin-Foster; Amy S Hoffman; Martha L Bruce Journal: Int J Geriatr Psychiatry Date: 2010-11 Impact factor: 3.485