BACKGROUND: In nontraumatic femoral head osteonecrosis, characterization of femoral head collapse is important in staging disease progression and planning treatment. Few prior studies have quantitatively compared the ability of sagittal and coronal MR images to detect femoral head collapse. OBJECTIVE: We hypothesized that sagittal MR images show a greater degree and angular span of femoral head collapse than coronal images. MATERIALS AND METHODS: We reviewed 38 hip MRI scans of nontraumatic femoral head osteonecrosis from 34 pediatric patients. In both sagittal and coronal images, the maximal extent and angular location along with the angular span of the femoral head collapse were measured. Differences were evaluated using a paired t-test. The extent of bone and cartilage loss from the femoral head was evaluated. RESULTS: Sagittal MR images showed 29% maximal femoral head radius collapse, whereas coronal images showed 16% collapse (P<0.001). Sagittal images showed a larger angular span of collapse (115 degrees ) than coronal images (55 degrees , P<0.001). Sagittal images showed greater epiphyseal bone loss in the anterior than in the posterior portion (P<0.001), whereas coronal images did not show a significant difference in bone loss between the medial and lateral portion (P=0.32). CONCLUSION: Sagittal images show greater femoral head collapse than coronal images in nontraumatic femoral head osteonecrosis.
BACKGROUND: In nontraumatic femoral head osteonecrosis, characterization of femoral head collapse is important in staging disease progression and planning treatment. Few prior studies have quantitatively compared the ability of sagittal and coronal MR images to detect femoral head collapse. OBJECTIVE: We hypothesized that sagittal MR images show a greater degree and angular span of femoral head collapse than coronal images. MATERIALS AND METHODS: We reviewed 38 hip MRI scans of nontraumatic femoral head osteonecrosis from 34 pediatric patients. In both sagittal and coronal images, the maximal extent and angular location along with the angular span of the femoral head collapse were measured. Differences were evaluated using a paired t-test. The extent of bone and cartilage loss from the femoral head was evaluated. RESULTS: Sagittal MR images showed 29% maximal femoral head radius collapse, whereas coronal images showed 16% collapse (P<0.001). Sagittal images showed a larger angular span of collapse (115 degrees ) than coronal images (55 degrees , P<0.001). Sagittal images showed greater epiphyseal bone loss in the anterior than in the posterior portion (P<0.001), whereas coronal images did not show a significant difference in bone loss between the medial and lateral portion (P=0.32). CONCLUSION: Sagittal images show greater femoral head collapse than coronal images in nontraumatic femoral head osteonecrosis.
Authors: Sebastian F Cherian; Alan Laorr; Khaled J Saleh; Michael A Kuskowski; Robert F Bailey; Edward Y Cheng Journal: J Bone Joint Surg Am Date: 2003-02 Impact factor: 5.284
Authors: Aristidis H Zibis; Apostolos H Karantanas; Nikolaos T Roidis; Michael E Hantes; Paraskevi Argiri; Theofanis Moraitis; Konstantinos N Malizos Journal: Eur J Radiol Date: 2007-06-06 Impact factor: 3.528