BACKGROUND: Although it is universally accepted that human disease and behavior depend upon both environmental and genetic variation, a view supported by family and twin studies, examples of environmental interactions with genes identified at the molecular level (G x E) are not so well established. METHODS: We carried out a systematic review and meta-analysis of the serotonin transporter (5-HTTLPR) polymorphic region x stressful life event (SLE) literature and investigated to what extent the main effects reported in this literature are consistent with a number of G x E hypotheses. Our aim was to provide a framework in which to assess the robustness of the claim for the presence of an interaction. RESULTS: The results from our systematic review and meta-analysis indicate that the main effect of 5-HTTLPR genotype and the interaction effect between 5-HTTLPR and SLE on risk of depression are negligible. We found that only a minority of studies report a replication that is qualitatively comparable to that in the original report. CONCLUSIONS: Given reasonable assumptions regarding likely genetic and environmental effect sizes, our simulations indicate that published studies are underpowered. This, together with other aspects of the literature, leads us to suggest that the positive results for the 5-HTTLPR x SLE interactions in logistic regression models are compatible with chance findings.
BACKGROUND: Although it is universally accepted that human disease and behavior depend upon both environmental and genetic variation, a view supported by family and twin studies, examples of environmental interactions with genes identified at the molecular level (G x E) are not so well established. METHODS: We carried out a systematic review and meta-analysis of the serotonin transporter (5-HTTLPR) polymorphic region x stressful life event (SLE) literature and investigated to what extent the main effects reported in this literature are consistent with a number of G x E hypotheses. Our aim was to provide a framework in which to assess the robustness of the claim for the presence of an interaction. RESULTS: The results from our systematic review and meta-analysis indicate that the main effect of 5-HTTLPR genotype and the interaction effect between 5-HTTLPR and SLE on risk of depression are negligible. We found that only a minority of studies report a replication that is qualitatively comparable to that in the original report. CONCLUSIONS: Given reasonable assumptions regarding likely genetic and environmental effect sizes, our simulations indicate that published studies are underpowered. This, together with other aspects of the literature, leads us to suggest that the positive results for the 5-HTTLPR x SLE interactions in logistic regression models are compatible with chance findings.
Authors: Erin C Dunn; Monica Uddin; S V Subramanian; Jordan W Smoller; Sandro Galea; Karestan C Koenen Journal: J Child Psychol Psychiatry Date: 2011-09-29 Impact factor: 8.982
Authors: Lot M Geels; Maria M Groen-Blokhuis; Catharina E M van Beijsterveldt; Jacqueline M Vink; Christel M Middeldorp; Meike Bartels; Kelly A Nelson; Patricia E Huizenga; Gareth E Davies; Dorret I Boomsma Journal: Am J Med Genet B Neuropsychiatr Genet Date: 2012-10-22 Impact factor: 3.568
Authors: Claudia M Haase; Laura R Saslow; Lian Bloch; Sarina R Saturn; James J Casey; Benjamin H Seider; Jessica Lane; Giovanni Coppola; Robert W Levenson Journal: Emotion Date: 2013-10-07