BACKGROUND: Bicortical fixation of proximal phalangeal fractures may damage underlying flexor tendons secondary to drilling and screw protrusion in the dorsal-ventral direction. The aim of this study was to measure and compare the pull-out force of unicortical screws compared to bicortical screws in human cadaveric proximal phalanges to identify optimal configuration for internal fixation. METHODS: Forty proximal phalanges were harvested. Bicortical and unicortical self tapping 1.7mm screws were inserted into paired phalanges at the distal and proximal metaphysis and at the mid-diaphysis placed in the dorso-ventral direction. Pull-out force of unicortical and bicortical screws were measured and compared. FINDINGS: Bicortical screw pull-out force is significantly higher than that of unicortical screws in the dorsal-ventral direction. Pull-out strength of unicortical screws at the mid-diaphysis was significantly higher than the pull-out strength of bicortical screws at the proximal metaphysis (181.8N versus 31.5N, P<0.0001). INTERPRETATION: Diaphyseal fixation is stronger than metaphyseal for both unicortical and bicortical configurations. Unicortical mid-diaphyseal is stronger than bicortical proximal metaphyseal screw pull-out strength. This study provides biomechanical data that may be helpful for individualizing fracture fixation techniques at the proximal phalanx.
BACKGROUND: Bicortical fixation of proximal phalangeal fractures may damage underlying flexor tendons secondary to drilling and screw protrusion in the dorsal-ventral direction. The aim of this study was to measure and compare the pull-out force of unicortical screws compared to bicortical screws in human cadaveric proximal phalanges to identify optimal configuration for internal fixation. METHODS: Forty proximal phalanges were harvested. Bicortical and unicortical self tapping 1.7mm screws were inserted into paired phalanges at the distal and proximal metaphysis and at the mid-diaphysis placed in the dorso-ventral direction. Pull-out force of unicortical and bicortical screws were measured and compared. FINDINGS: Bicortical screw pull-out force is significantly higher than that of unicortical screws in the dorsal-ventral direction. Pull-out strength of unicortical screws at the mid-diaphysis was significantly higher than the pull-out strength of bicortical screws at the proximal metaphysis (181.8N versus 31.5N, P<0.0001). INTERPRETATION: Diaphyseal fixation is stronger than metaphyseal for both unicortical and bicortical configurations. Unicortical mid-diaphyseal is stronger than bicortical proximal metaphyseal screw pull-out strength. This study provides biomechanical data that may be helpful for individualizing fracture fixation techniques at the proximal phalanx.
Authors: Eirini Liodaki; Robert Wendlandt; Klaus Waizner; Brigitte E Schopp; Peter Mailänder; Felix Stang Journal: Medicine (Baltimore) Date: 2017-07 Impact factor: 1.889