Wojciech Wozniak1, Marek W Karwacki. 1. NF Outpatient Clinic, Clinical Department of Oncological Surgery for Children and Youth, National Research Institute of Mother and Child, Kasprzaka 17a, 01-211, Warsaw, Poland.
Abstract
AIM: The aim of this study was to compare aggressive surgery to "watchful waiting" in neurofibromatosis type 1 (NF-1) patients with benign peripheral nerve sheath tumors exceeding 150 cm(3). MATERIALS AND METHODS: Observational study based on imaging studies and results of surgery was utilized. RESULTS: Twenty-seven out of 114 NF-1 patients (mean age of 12.8 years) registered throughout the last 10 years were studied. The mean tumor volume was 237 cm(3). Among them, 18 (66%) underwent surgery. In 15 (84%), regrowth of a tumor was observed. Reoperation was necessary in five (27%). Two out of these five children (2/18, 11%) required a third operation. Stable process has been shown in the remaining nine children (34%) since diagnosis and in most operated children (10/18; 56%), besides the regrowth of the tumor. CONCLUSIONS: "Watchful waiting" could be superior to aggressive surgery in selected patients without "oncological awareness" confirmed by imaging techniques (mostly magnetic resonance imaging). NF-1 children with gross tumor mass require lifetime imaging monitoring and complex medical evaluation.
AIM: The aim of this study was to compare aggressive surgery to "watchful waiting" in neurofibromatosis type 1 (NF-1) patients with benign peripheral nerve sheath tumors exceeding 150 cm(3). MATERIALS AND METHODS: Observational study based on imaging studies and results of surgery was utilized. RESULTS: Twenty-seven out of 114 NF-1patients (mean age of 12.8 years) registered throughout the last 10 years were studied. The mean tumor volume was 237 cm(3). Among them, 18 (66%) underwent surgery. In 15 (84%), regrowth of a tumor was observed. Reoperation was necessary in five (27%). Two out of these five children (2/18, 11%) required a third operation. Stable process has been shown in the remaining nine children (34%) since diagnosis and in most operated children (10/18; 56%), besides the regrowth of the tumor. CONCLUSIONS: "Watchful waiting" could be superior to aggressive surgery in selected patients without "oncological awareness" confirmed by imaging techniques (mostly magnetic resonance imaging). NF-1children with gross tumor mass require lifetime imaging monitoring and complex medical evaluation.
Authors: Nicolas Amoretti; Anne Grimaud; Etienne Hovorka; Patrick Chevallier; Christian Roux; Jean Noël Bruneton Journal: Clin Imaging Date: 2006 May-Jun Impact factor: 1.605