Robert Sokolic1, Chimene Kesserwan, Fabio Candotti. 1. Disorders of Immunity Section, Genetics and Molecular Biology Branch, National Human Genome Research Institute, National Institutes of Health, MD 20892-4442, USA. fabio@nhgri.nih.gov
Abstract
PURPOSE OF REVIEW: To discuss new data on the safety and efficacy of the ongoing gene therapy trials for primary immune deficiencies, the first reports of new trials and the preclinical developments that are likely to be translated to the clinic in the near future. RECENT FINDINGS: Both clinical successes and severe adverse events continue to be reported in trials of gammaretroviral gene therapy for severe combined immune deficiency-X1, adenosine deaminase-deficient forms of severe combined immune deficiency and chronic granulomatous disease. Insertion site analyses of recently reported trials on all of these diseases have discovered preferential insertion in the 5' ends of genes, including potentially dangerous ones such as proto-oncogenes and signal transduction and proliferation genes. Preclinical work on rodent and canine models has tested novel vectors, including lentiviruses and foamy viruses. SUMMARY: Gene therapy for the most common forms of severe combined immune deficiency can lead to immune reconstitution in most patients, although a minority of patients has derived minimal clinical benefit and some have suffered severe adverse events including death. Ongoing preclinical work attempts to address the latter shortcoming. Meanwhile, in the presence of a careful risk-benefit assessment, gene therapy remains an appropriate subject of clinical investigation.
PURPOSE OF REVIEW: To discuss new data on the safety and efficacy of the ongoing gene therapy trials for primary immune deficiencies, the first reports of new trials and the preclinical developments that are likely to be translated to the clinic in the near future. RECENT FINDINGS: Both clinical successes and severe adverse events continue to be reported in trials of gammaretroviral gene therapy for severe combined immune deficiency-X1, adenosine deaminase-deficient forms of severe combined immune deficiency and chronic granulomatous disease. Insertion site analyses of recently reported trials on all of these diseases have discovered preferential insertion in the 5' ends of genes, including potentially dangerous ones such as proto-oncogenes and signal transduction and proliferation genes. Preclinical work on rodent and canine models has tested novel vectors, including lentiviruses and foamy viruses. SUMMARY: Gene therapy for the most common forms of severe combined immune deficiency can lead to immune reconstitution in most patients, although a minority of patients has derived minimal clinical benefit and some have suffered severe adverse events including death. Ongoing preclinical work attempts to address the latter shortcoming. Meanwhile, in the presence of a careful risk-benefit assessment, gene therapy remains an appropriate subject of clinical investigation.
Authors: Salima Hacein-Bey-Abina; Christof von Kalle; Manfred Schmidt; Françoise Le Deist; Nicolas Wulffraat; Elisabeth McIntyre; Isabelle Radford; Jean-Luc Villeval; Christopher C Fraser; Marina Cavazzana-Calvo; Alain Fischer Journal: N Engl J Med Date: 2003-01-16 Impact factor: 91.245
Authors: M Cavazzana-Calvo; S Hacein-Bey; G de Saint Basile; F Gross; E Yvon; P Nusbaum; F Selz; C Hue; S Certain; J L Casanova; P Bousso; F L Deist; A Fischer Journal: Science Date: 2000-04-28 Impact factor: 47.728
Authors: Salima Hacein-Bey-Abina; Françoise Le Deist; Frédérique Carlier; Cécile Bouneaud; Christophe Hue; Jean-Pierre De Villartay; Adrian J Thrasher; Nicolas Wulffraat; Ricardo Sorensen; Sophie Dupuis-Girod; Alain Fischer; E Graham Davies; Wietse Kuis; Lilly Leiva; Marina Cavazzana-Calvo Journal: N Engl J Med Date: 2002-04-18 Impact factor: 91.245
Authors: S Hacein-Bey-Abina; C Von Kalle; M Schmidt; M P McCormack; N Wulffraat; P Leboulch; A Lim; C S Osborne; R Pawliuk; E Morillon; R Sorensen; A Forster; P Fraser; J I Cohen; G de Saint Basile; I Alexander; U Wintergerst; T Frebourg; A Aurias; D Stoppa-Lyonnet; S Romana; I Radford-Weiss; F Gross; F Valensi; E Delabesse; E Macintyre; F Sigaux; J Soulier; L E Leiva; M Wissler; C Prinz; T H Rabbitts; F Le Deist; A Fischer; M Cavazzana-Calvo Journal: Science Date: 2003-10-17 Impact factor: 47.728
Authors: Susannah I Thornhill; Axel Schambach; Steven J Howe; Meera Ulaganathan; Elke Grassman; David Williams; Bernhard Schiedlmeier; Neil J Sebire; H Bobby Gaspar; Christine Kinnon; Christopher Baum; Adrian J Thrasher Journal: Mol Ther Date: 2008-01-08 Impact factor: 11.454
Authors: Rick S Mitchell; Brett F Beitzel; Astrid R W Schroder; Paul Shinn; Huaming Chen; Charles C Berry; Joseph R Ecker; Frederic D Bushman Journal: PLoS Biol Date: 2004-08-17 Impact factor: 8.029
Authors: Manuel Grez; Janine Reichenbach; Joachim Schwäble; Reinhard Seger; Mary C Dinauer; Adrian J Thrasher Journal: Mol Ther Date: 2010-11-02 Impact factor: 11.454
Authors: Francesco Marangoni; Marita Bosticardo; Sabine Charrier; Elena Draghici; Michela Locci; Samantha Scaramuzza; Cristina Panaroni; Maurilio Ponzoni; Francesca Sanvito; Claudio Doglioni; Marie Liabeuf; Bernard Gjata; Marie Montus; Katherine Siminovitch; Alessandro Aiuti; Luigi Naldini; Loïc Dupré; Maria Grazia Roncarolo; Anne Galy; Anna Villa Journal: Mol Ther Date: 2009-03-03 Impact factor: 11.454
Authors: Sam L Stephen; Katie Freestone; Sarah Dunn; Michael W Twigg; Shervanthi Homer-Vanniasinkam; John H Walker; Stephen B Wheatcroft; Sreenivasan Ponnambalam Journal: Int J Hypertens Date: 2010-08-17 Impact factor: 2.420
Authors: Florian Halbeisen; Claire Hogg; Mikkel C Alanin; Zuzanna Bukowy-Bieryllo; Francisco Dasi; Julie Duncan; Amanda Friend; Myrofora Goutaki; Claire Jackson; Victoria Keenan; Amanda Harris; Robert A Hirst; Philipp Latzin; Gemma Marsh; Kim Nielsen; Dominic Norris; Daniel Pellicer; Ana Reula; Bruna Rubbo; Nisreen Rumman; Amelia Shoemark; Woolf T Walker; Claudia E Kuehni; Jane S Lucas Journal: BMC Proc Date: 2018-03-05