Examining the single and interactive effects of three insecticides on amphibian metamorphosis.

Although aquatic communities frequently are exposed to a number of pesticides, the effects of chemical mixtures are not well understood. In two separate studies, I examined how insecticide mixtures influenced the likelihood of unpredictable, nonadditive effects on American toad (Bufo americanus) and green frog (Rana clamitans) tadpoles reared in outdoor aquatic communities. I exposed tadpoles to single or multiple insecticides at approximately half the reported median lethal concentrations using insecticides that were either acetylcholinesterase inhibitors (carbaryl or malathion) or a sodium-channel disruptor (permethrin). I found that combinations of insecticides with the same mode of action were more likely to have nonadditive effects on amphibian metamorphosis compared with those having different modes of action. Additionally, in one study, a commercial formulation of permethrin led to near-complete elimination of American toads, suggesting that this formulation could have adverse effects on aquatic communities. Many community studies exploring the ecological effects of expected environmental concentrations of pesticides have suggested that indirect effects in the food web, rather than direct effects on individual physiology, have the largest effect on amphibians. The present study indicates that direct effects of pesticides may become particularly important when insecticides with the same mode of action are present in the environment.