A Martinage1, T Balaguer, B Chignon-Sicard, M-C Monteil, N Dréant, E Lebreton. 1. Service de chirurgie plastique, réparatrice et esthétique, chirurgie de la main, hôpital Saint-Roch, 5 rue Pierre-Dévoluy, B.P. 1319, Nice cedex 1, France. aurelienmartinage@hotmail.com
Abstract
OBJECTIVES: We report a retrospective series of 14 dislocations or perilunate fracture-dislocations. The results of our series are compared with the data of the literature and we discuss epidemiology, types of lesions, surgical treatment, complications and prognosis of this pathology. METHODS: The series included seven pure dislocations and seven fracture-dislocations including three trans-scapho-lunate forms (including one Fenton's syndrome). The displacement of all these lesions was posterior. The mean age was 35 years. Sixty-four percent were manual workers. All 14 patients had undergone surgical treatment through a dorsal approach in the first seven days following the injury. They were reviewed clinically and radiologically with a mean follow-up of 25 months. RESULTS: The average Cooney functional score was 72/100 with two excellent, six good, four fair and two poor results. Average flexion-extension motion arc was 74%, the grip strength was 77% compared to the other wrist. Persistent wrist pain was almost constant. One carpal instability was observed and one patient required a four-corner arthrodesis for SLAC wrist. Eighty-five percent of all patients were employed at least. CONCLUSIONS: Early diagnosis and anatomical reduction can provide satisfactory functional results. Emergency surgical treatment is required. We prefer a dorsal approach and we do not perform primary closed reductions.
OBJECTIVES: We report a retrospective series of 14 dislocations or perilunate fracture-dislocations. The results of our series are compared with the data of the literature and we discuss epidemiology, types of lesions, surgical treatment, complications and prognosis of this pathology. METHODS: The series included seven pure dislocations and seven fracture-dislocations including three trans-scapho-lunate forms (including one Fenton's syndrome). The displacement of all these lesions was posterior. The mean age was 35 years. Sixty-four percent were manual workers. All 14 patients had undergone surgical treatment through a dorsal approach in the first seven days following the injury. They were reviewed clinically and radiologically with a mean follow-up of 25 months. RESULTS: The average Cooney functional score was 72/100 with two excellent, six good, four fair and two poor results. Average flexion-extension motion arc was 74%, the grip strength was 77% compared to the other wrist. Persistent wrist pain was almost constant. One carpal instability was observed and one patient required a four-corner arthrodesis for SLAC wrist. Eighty-five percent of all patients were employed at least. CONCLUSIONS: Early diagnosis and anatomical reduction can provide satisfactory functional results. Emergency surgical treatment is required. We prefer a dorsal approach and we do not perform primary closed reductions.
Authors: Issam Elouakili; Younes Ouchrif; Abdeljaouad Najib; Redouane Ouakrim; Omar Lamrani; Mohammed Kharmaz; Farid Ismael; Abdo Lahlou; Mohammed Elouadghiri; Ahmed El Bardouni; Mustapha Mahfoud; Mohammed Saleh Berrada; Mouradh El Yaccoubi Journal: Pan Afr Med J Date: 2014-06-03