M E Burman1, S McKay. 1. FayW. Whitney School of Nursing, University of Wyoming, Laramie, WY 82071, USA. mburman@uwyo.edu
Abstract
BACKGROUND: Although the widespread presence of girls who participate in fighting forces is increasingly recognized, they remain a highly marginalized group globally, receiving little attention either during or after armed conflict. This is especially true for "girl mothers," girls who return to communities with children born while members of fighting forces. AIM: The concept of marginalization (Hall et al. 1994) is used to examine what happens to girl soldiers, especially girl mothers, in the aftermath of armed conflict when they seek to reintegrate back into their communities. METHODS: This analysis, as part of a larger study of reintegration of girl mothers, is based on field work with girls who were in fighting forces in northwest Sierra Leone, especially those who returned with children. FINDINGS: The type and level of marginalization these girls experience is consistent with the conceptualization of marginalization; however, they lack voice and experience shame and vulnerability. Moreover, economics were fundamentally related to their marginalization. The girls' access to resources was significantly constrained because the area was heavily impacted by the war and because of widespread poverty throughout Sierra Leone. DISCUSSION: The findings raise important questions about marginalization of girls affected by war. Girls and girl mothers experience an extremely high level of marginalization; however, some aspects are not consistent with the original conceptualization of marginalization. Theory development in nursing needs to incorporate multiple voices, especially those of the very marginalized and be done in such a manner that benefits and empowers.
BACKGROUND: Although the widespread presence of girls who participate in fighting forces is increasingly recognized, they remain a highly marginalized group globally, receiving little attention either during or after armed conflict. This is especially true for "girl mothers," girls who return to communities with children born while members of fighting forces. AIM: The concept of marginalization (Hall et al. 1994) is used to examine what happens to girl soldiers, especially girl mothers, in the aftermath of armed conflict when they seek to reintegrate back into their communities. METHODS: This analysis, as part of a larger study of reintegration of girl mothers, is based on field work with girls who were in fighting forces in northwest Sierra Leone, especially those who returned with children. FINDINGS: The type and level of marginalization these girls experience is consistent with the conceptualization of marginalization; however, they lack voice and experience shame and vulnerability. Moreover, economics were fundamentally related to their marginalization. The girls' access to resources was significantly constrained because the area was heavily impacted by the war and because of widespread poverty throughout Sierra Leone. DISCUSSION: The findings raise important questions about marginalization of girls affected by war. Girls and girl mothers experience an extremely high level of marginalization; however, some aspects are not consistent with the original conceptualization of marginalization. Theory development in nursing needs to incorporate multiple voices, especially those of the very marginalized and be done in such a manner that benefits and empowers.
Authors: Theresa Stichick Betancourt; Ivelina Ivanova Borisova; Timothy Philip Williams; Robert T Brennan; Theodore H Whitfield; Marie de la Soudiere; John Williamson; Stephen E Gilman Journal: Child Dev Date: 2010 Jul-Aug
Authors: Theresa S Betancourt; Ivelina Borisova; Timothy P Williams; Sarah E Meyers-Ohki; Julia E Rubin-Smith; Jeannie Annan; Brandon A Kohrt Journal: J Child Psychol Psychiatry Date: 2012-10-12 Impact factor: 8.982
Authors: Theresa S Betancourt; Jessica Agnew-Blais; Stephen E Gilman; David R Williams; B Heidi Ellis Journal: Soc Sci Med Date: 2009-10-28 Impact factor: 4.634
Authors: Aisha Hutchinson; Philippa Waterhouse; Jane March-McDonald; Sarah Neal; Roger Ingham Journal: Confl Health Date: 2017-08-17 Impact factor: 2.723